Tractor Thread
Re: Tractor Thread
Maybe there is something about that tank we don't know.
Maybe it can walk/roll on water.
Maybe it is submersible.
Maybe it's a big mistake.
Only the Chinese know.
And the Shadow.
Maybe it can walk/roll on water.
Maybe it is submersible.
Maybe it's a big mistake.
Only the Chinese know.
And the Shadow.
roger
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
Re: Tractor Thread
Take a close look at the 4 missile launching trucks, particularly the front left side of the cabs. They're all identical. I'd bet that drove some poor f%&*#r crazy designin' the paint mask for that, what?
Kinda snazzy color combo, though. 
If you agree with the Progressives, it's freedom of speech. If you disagree, it's hate speech. There are no alternatives.
- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42237
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: Tractor Thread
Mitch wrote: Kinda snazzy color combo, though.
I'm thinking that will paint scheme look good on my Farmall Cub!!!
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
Re: Tractor Thread
MurphOnMillerAve wrote:...but what are they getting ready for?
Trump
I spend entirely too many hours a day tying my shoes
- MurphOnMillerAve
- Posts: 18489
- Joined: Fri Jul 18, 2008 10:18 pm
- Location: Kennywood Park
- Contact:
Re: Tractor Thread
robert. wrote:MurphOnMillerAve wrote:...but what are they getting ready for?
Trump
Naw, I think their aspirations and planning go way further back than his appearance on the political scene.
Re: Tractor Thread
Funny how the recent alarm bells from the current crop of geo-political and military analysts ignores the reality us old bastards know and remember. Is it their political handlers and the modern press (CNN through Fox in spectrum) or are they that unschooled in history as a baseline for analysis and interpretation?
There is absolutely nothing new here, no new boogeyman under the bed. The Chinese have maintained a large well-equipped military as a matter of policy since kicking a whimpering Chiang and his trollop off the mainland in the '40s. It's the same military that (the arrogant arse) MacArthur underestimated grossly in Korea, the same infrastructure that told the Soviets to piss off in the '60s and became then one of the largest producers of arms in the world (including solid competent combat aircraft), and has continued to keep place and pace today.
The press is full of scary stories of new-found military testicles in the South China Sea, but this is nothing different from the disputes (including shellfire) over islands between China and Formosa and in the SCS during Eisenhower's administration. It's all a very old expression of policy and business as usual.
I'm amased at how quick the American press and administration are to declare yet another falling sky event and how faithfully Americans sop this manna and gleefully join together in yet another Pavlovian throng running about in circles clutching at their willy all the while cheeping mightily and fervently.
There is cause for continued attention perhaps, but absolutely nothing new here. I guess anything crafted to look bad in the papers and upset civilians at their breakfast sells well, though.
There is absolutely nothing new here, no new boogeyman under the bed. The Chinese have maintained a large well-equipped military as a matter of policy since kicking a whimpering Chiang and his trollop off the mainland in the '40s. It's the same military that (the arrogant arse) MacArthur underestimated grossly in Korea, the same infrastructure that told the Soviets to piss off in the '60s and became then one of the largest producers of arms in the world (including solid competent combat aircraft), and has continued to keep place and pace today.
The press is full of scary stories of new-found military testicles in the South China Sea, but this is nothing different from the disputes (including shellfire) over islands between China and Formosa and in the SCS during Eisenhower's administration. It's all a very old expression of policy and business as usual.
I'm amased at how quick the American press and administration are to declare yet another falling sky event and how faithfully Americans sop this manna and gleefully join together in yet another Pavlovian throng running about in circles clutching at their willy all the while cheeping mightily and fervently.
There is cause for continued attention perhaps, but absolutely nothing new here. I guess anything crafted to look bad in the papers and upset civilians at their breakfast sells well, though.
- MurphOnMillerAve
- Posts: 18489
- Joined: Fri Jul 18, 2008 10:18 pm
- Location: Kennywood Park
- Contact:
Re: Tractor Thread
Sarge, I often find myself enjoying having to read your mini-tomes more than once to fully appreciate your perspective. I can see I have been paying attention elsewhere while you were scrutinizing far more important events and factors.
With appreciation and my compliments,
Murph
With appreciation and my compliments,
Murph
"Doing wrong is like a joke to a fool." Proverbs 10: 21-28
Re: Tractor Thread
Agreed. Much ado about nothing. Even the military wasn't excited, and said it's normal protocol to intrude on US territory so long as they are heading somewhere and are expeditious.
Re: Tractor Thread
healey36 wrote:There's always some joker in the neighborhood trying to muscle-up on everyone else...biggest pool, biggest BBQ grille, biggest SUV, biggest ATV:
Healey
Healy,
I thought everyone had one of those!!!
I'll take the "trade in" sitting there on the trailer.
Re: Tractor Thread
Nah, I'm not so sure about "nothing's changed". The Chinese have been a great modern land power since the 1950's, but now they are pushing out into the South China Sea and Western Pacific in a bid for territorial and mineral rights mutually claimed by Japan, the Philippines, Taiwan, Vietnam, Malaysia and Brunei, some of whom the U.S. has mutual defense arrangements with. They have a rapidly growing navy, and a tactical missile technology capable of challenging the U.S. If the Chinese build an "island" thirty miles off the Phillipines or the Ryukyu Islands, put an airbase on it and claim it as their territory with all associated mineral rights, what will the U.S. do? What can the U.S. do?
I think that's what the issue is, and that's a relatively new scenario.
Healey
http://www.defensenews.com/story/defense/naval/2015/09/03/chinas-parade-puts-us-navy-notice/71632918/
I think that's what the issue is, and that's a relatively new scenario.
Healey
http://www.defensenews.com/story/defense/naval/2015/09/03/chinas-parade-puts-us-navy-notice/71632918/
Re: Tractor Thread
My case exactly. The Defense News, the CNN of the "new" American Beltway bandit and DoD analyst culture, made up of all post-Cold War kids who have no idea what they are watching. They, as having input into American policy, should scare you more than the effing Chinese wanting a Navy as a trading economy and maritime nation.
History repeats itself. The Soviets finished the war precisely in that same mould, and built a bluewater navy afterwords in much the same mould. Maintaining that navy, especially as a nuclear force, was a major factor in breaking them, for a bluewater navy is the most expensive service traditionally, and even now compares to a nuclear air force in cost to maintain.
Again I'm not saying it doesn't bear watching, as the projection of naval power has always borne watching for all trading nations, but I'm sorry I don't see what is new here compared to any Chinese fortification of islands for air (and artillery) use such as during the Taiwan Straits crises (Quemoy and Matsu disputes, artillery use, misslile threats &c) from the 1950s through the 1990s.
These aren't mutually claimed areas, but disputed claims by all involved; nothing mutual about it. Again, nothing new here. The Spratley disputes have been ongoing since the late '60s, and the Senkaku dispute since perhaps the mid-70s also come to mind. All this, many "robust" actions by many nations involved, is really a tomcats-pissing-on-the-parlour-furniture exercise by all involved and only (strangely enough) after an exploitable oil reserve was confirmed in the area.
What is new perhaps is the Chinese development of a borderline bluewater force, but notice the actual power projection methodology is still land-based. That naval development is really just a normal technological keeping-with-the-times of any growing economic force for whom trade over the seas is an economic force. Any old sea-dog will expect it, and that expected development is of no surprise to the old establishment in the States (or in the Admiralty for that matter). It's an expectation that goes back for decades, learned by any of us who worked this in the Cold War and anyone who has read and actually understood Mahan in the process.
Historically, economic powers with a strong reliance on over-the-seas trade aspire to a bluewater naval force to protect the routes in their best interest.
Two last things though. The speed of assent of China's economic sun might also be the speed of its eclipse. The situation with their troubles today will bear watching and will (much like the Soviets) have an immediate effect on their ability to maintain a navy beyond a frigate-based force.
Second, although we at our breakfast tables can become rather nervous about this sort of thing, any navy has the right to transit international waters and to operate in those waters as a matter of maritime law (the recent press masturbation over Chinese frigates in the Bering Sea off the Aleutians). The Chinese are exercising that right, albeit tepidly (except as presented in the media) just as any nation has the right. With respect to the willy-clutchers at Defense News, they are all somehow presenting what has been going on for at least 50 years in the SCS as somehow a new thing. New developments and different methods being tried perhaps, but no. It's very old hat.
No-one has said nothing has changed, for it has and very predictably, perhaps only unusual in it's absolute lack of speed, really. What was said is:
Not only nothing new, but nothing that should be unexpected.
Edit to add a thought
Consider this, which is not the American point of view nor the one put forth as an assessment of American policy; worth a thought just to round out the perception beyond what the press spoonfeeds:
Mahan theorised (and history seems to back it up) that a major economic power engaged in overseas trade as a majority factor in that economic power is by requirement in need of a bluewater navy to protect that trade and forward the interests of that power.
The Beltway kid argument was always that the postwar Japanese followed by the South Korean examples as major exporting economic powers have successively disproved that theory in modern times.
Not so, from the detached viewpoint of nations outside the USA. They both did have major navies, but it was supplied by their good friends the Yanks (perhaps by default and perhaps by design). Next in line after the Koreans were the Chinese, who do not enjoy that same warmth and fuzziness from the US or the "use" of it's navy.
Denied that, it is rather interesting that the Yanks (especially their policy tanks full of young academics) are surprised and upset somehow when the Chinese take it upon themselves to provide that which other exporting economic powerhouses in turn have had provided for them in the Pacific.
Mahan's body of Naval theory is still valid.
Back to tractors? Pleeeeeeeeeze?
History repeats itself. The Soviets finished the war precisely in that same mould, and built a bluewater navy afterwords in much the same mould. Maintaining that navy, especially as a nuclear force, was a major factor in breaking them, for a bluewater navy is the most expensive service traditionally, and even now compares to a nuclear air force in cost to maintain.
Again I'm not saying it doesn't bear watching, as the projection of naval power has always borne watching for all trading nations, but I'm sorry I don't see what is new here compared to any Chinese fortification of islands for air (and artillery) use such as during the Taiwan Straits crises (Quemoy and Matsu disputes, artillery use, misslile threats &c) from the 1950s through the 1990s.
These aren't mutually claimed areas, but disputed claims by all involved; nothing mutual about it. Again, nothing new here. The Spratley disputes have been ongoing since the late '60s, and the Senkaku dispute since perhaps the mid-70s also come to mind. All this, many "robust" actions by many nations involved, is really a tomcats-pissing-on-the-parlour-furniture exercise by all involved and only (strangely enough) after an exploitable oil reserve was confirmed in the area.
What is new perhaps is the Chinese development of a borderline bluewater force, but notice the actual power projection methodology is still land-based. That naval development is really just a normal technological keeping-with-the-times of any growing economic force for whom trade over the seas is an economic force. Any old sea-dog will expect it, and that expected development is of no surprise to the old establishment in the States (or in the Admiralty for that matter). It's an expectation that goes back for decades, learned by any of us who worked this in the Cold War and anyone who has read and actually understood Mahan in the process.
Historically, economic powers with a strong reliance on over-the-seas trade aspire to a bluewater naval force to protect the routes in their best interest.
Two last things though. The speed of assent of China's economic sun might also be the speed of its eclipse. The situation with their troubles today will bear watching and will (much like the Soviets) have an immediate effect on their ability to maintain a navy beyond a frigate-based force.
Second, although we at our breakfast tables can become rather nervous about this sort of thing, any navy has the right to transit international waters and to operate in those waters as a matter of maritime law (the recent press masturbation over Chinese frigates in the Bering Sea off the Aleutians). The Chinese are exercising that right, albeit tepidly (except as presented in the media) just as any nation has the right. With respect to the willy-clutchers at Defense News, they are all somehow presenting what has been going on for at least 50 years in the SCS as somehow a new thing. New developments and different methods being tried perhaps, but no. It's very old hat.
No-one has said nothing has changed, for it has and very predictably, perhaps only unusual in it's absolute lack of speed, really. What was said is:
sarge wrote:There is cause for continued attention perhaps, but absolutely nothing new here.
Not only nothing new, but nothing that should be unexpected.
Edit to add a thought
Consider this, which is not the American point of view nor the one put forth as an assessment of American policy; worth a thought just to round out the perception beyond what the press spoonfeeds:
Mahan theorised (and history seems to back it up) that a major economic power engaged in overseas trade as a majority factor in that economic power is by requirement in need of a bluewater navy to protect that trade and forward the interests of that power.
The Beltway kid argument was always that the postwar Japanese followed by the South Korean examples as major exporting economic powers have successively disproved that theory in modern times.
Not so, from the detached viewpoint of nations outside the USA. They both did have major navies, but it was supplied by their good friends the Yanks (perhaps by default and perhaps by design). Next in line after the Koreans were the Chinese, who do not enjoy that same warmth and fuzziness from the US or the "use" of it's navy.
Denied that, it is rather interesting that the Yanks (especially their policy tanks full of young academics) are surprised and upset somehow when the Chinese take it upon themselves to provide that which other exporting economic powerhouses in turn have had provided for them in the Pacific.
Mahan's body of Naval theory is still valid.
Back to tractors? Pleeeeeeeeeze?
Last edited by sarge on Sat Sep 05, 2015 5:50 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Re: Tractor Thread
Sarge,
Your first paragraph, at least to me, is most telling. The old saying "history repeats itself" is certainly true.
But most do not study history anymore. I know enough history to worry about todays events.
Let us, well me anyway, hear more.
Here in Georgia, the state government seems to have a policy, unwritten of course, that could be
"If it looks good on paper we [Georgia] will try it". That it has been tried many times and ended in failure
is of no importance. I think the federal government is operating the same way.
Nuff said. Probably too much.
Your first paragraph, at least to me, is most telling. The old saying "history repeats itself" is certainly true.
But most do not study history anymore. I know enough history to worry about todays events.
Let us, well me anyway, hear more.
Here in Georgia, the state government seems to have a policy, unwritten of course, that could be
"If it looks good on paper we [Georgia] will try it". That it has been tried many times and ended in failure
is of no importance. I think the federal government is operating the same way.
Nuff said. Probably too much.
roger
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
Re: Tractor Thread
Perhaps I misinterpreted the original point. If it was the contention that the Chinese have had aspirations to dominate the western Pacific and East/South China Sea for the last 60-70 years, or even the last thousand years, absolutely, I agree, they view this as their pond. This is nothing new. They've been pissed off for years, and up until a few years ago, what could they do? Nothing. If the US chose to sail a carrier battle-group through all they could do was sit there, watch and whine about it. They had a very limited conventional capability to deny passage.
My only contention is that they have or are about to develop/deploy an as yet unproven capability to project their terms, limit/deny access to what they've laid out as their sphere. It is a capability for which there is no workable defense at this time. All I'm saying is there's a new card in the deck, it's a strong card, and it goes a long way toward leveling the playing field (pond).
We can discuss this further at your local watering-hole Wednesday...I'm buying.
Healey
Edit
I'm not saying that the Chinese aim to interdict the world's sea lanes. They are perfectly content with the post-war Japanese/South Korean model...much cheaper. However, I do believe they intend to wall off the limited portions of the Pacific which they deem their territorial waters and administer/regulate/control/defend as they see fit. Nothing new, they've wanted it this way for eons. However, now they are acquiring the upgraded tools and are moving to do it, and to hell with everybody else. In the big scheme of things the intent/desire remains the same as 75 years ago, but the capability is now coming to the fore.
I would also profess my own skepticism regarding their technology. My experience has been that they can't manufacture an MTH traditional e-unit that works 5 of 10 times out of the box...how can they manufacture a ballistic missile that hits a moving carrier 1,000-3,000 miles away. Still, one needs to presume and defend against the threat.
My only contention is that they have or are about to develop/deploy an as yet unproven capability to project their terms, limit/deny access to what they've laid out as their sphere. It is a capability for which there is no workable defense at this time. All I'm saying is there's a new card in the deck, it's a strong card, and it goes a long way toward leveling the playing field (pond).
We can discuss this further at your local watering-hole Wednesday...I'm buying.
Healey
Edit
I'm not saying that the Chinese aim to interdict the world's sea lanes. They are perfectly content with the post-war Japanese/South Korean model...much cheaper. However, I do believe they intend to wall off the limited portions of the Pacific which they deem their territorial waters and administer/regulate/control/defend as they see fit. Nothing new, they've wanted it this way for eons. However, now they are acquiring the upgraded tools and are moving to do it, and to hell with everybody else. In the big scheme of things the intent/desire remains the same as 75 years ago, but the capability is now coming to the fore.
I would also profess my own skepticism regarding their technology. My experience has been that they can't manufacture an MTH traditional e-unit that works 5 of 10 times out of the box...how can they manufacture a ballistic missile that hits a moving carrier 1,000-3,000 miles away. Still, one needs to presume and defend against the threat.
Re: Tractor Thread
healey36 wrote:
We can discuss this further at your local watering-hole Wednesday...I'm buying.
Healey
Oh, yes, we can have a lively discussion Wednesday! Very much looking forward to seeing you at Comfy Mayhem.
healey36 wrote:...how can they manufacture a ballistic missile that hits a moving carrier 1,000-3,000 miles away. Still, one needs to presume and defend against the threat.
Now, you touch on the true tipping point. Naval warfare and trade interdiction has changed dramatically with the missile, specifically the cruise missile. Stand-off is now the key. Once the Chinese can deliver accurate offensive power from a moving platform and from a distance greater then the range of defensive weaponry arrayed against the force, then you can start worrying.
Building islands from whence to fly missions is very WWII, and the theoretical American carrier force that would be arrayed against it would be both mobile and able to deliver from a greater stand-off distance more accurately. Once that tips, the game changes, but only somewhat. The Chinese then need an integrated force that equals in mobility and stand-off distance just to equal the game, and even then only if that force is sustainable at sea, so the logistics and fleet trains need also be built and in place.
If the current policy-makers hasten to understand what they indeed see, pay attention to it, and don't do any force reduction beyond the Chinese ability to build and man, it isn't a falling of sky. Islands as bases is a problem already well-known should the need arise to deal with it. Cruise missiles are old hat (remember SY, HY and FL Silkworm date back to the '80s in origin) already for the Chinese, so no new panic there.
The ability to put that capability to sea as an independent mobile force (read carrier task group) and sustain it there, that's a development of concern, probably coming one day as the natural evolution of a navy in the modern world, but even then the Yanks have access to how many like forces in the Pacific?
Tractors! I'm retired; talk about tractors, dammit!
Re: Tractor Thread
Isn't this what MTJ is best known for? Thread drift. I love it. You don't learn of stuff like this on other forums unless you go specifically hunting for it.
I am serious about liking it. Sarge just answered some questions and suggested we get back to tractors. I must think that on a different forum there
is a lot of stuff I wouldn't have learned because of the intolerance of thread drift.
Now you can go back to tractors if you want.
I am serious about liking it. Sarge just answered some questions and suggested we get back to tractors. I must think that on a different forum there
is a lot of stuff I wouldn't have learned because of the intolerance of thread drift.
Now you can go back to tractors if you want.
roger
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
Return to “The Club Car Lounge”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 49 guests