True, to a point. Let's pick on a segment of the model train hobby for a moment.
Greenberg's Pricing Guide.
Collectors in the know (what they know is questionable) had to purchase the latest issue when it came out. Sellers had them, knowledgeable purchasers had them in their sweaty hands.
Unfortunately, there was no science behind it. Every issue, they took one section, applied some kind of formula to the numbers, and Voila! things were worth more money!
They didn't troll shows and auctions, making copious notes on actual sale prices of these items. Just bumped the numbers with no reasoning to sell more books.
One wonders on the Hagerty pricing if the same stuff doesn't apply....maybe with a Microsoft Program to generate higher numbers.
I have seen references to some item "on ebay for $10K!" or some such. That was asking. Sometimes you have no idea what the sale price was. Like Worthpoint and other on-line auctioneers....you have to sign up (and put your contact information out there) to see what some POS actually sold for, then you find out it references some e-bay listing in 2011.
Reminds me of folks who are gonna make a killing on the stock market. By Gum, they know all about it. Same with evilbait sellers. Rare! Vintage! Collectible! Fisher! Pantages!
All to squeeze more bucks out of folks......and we won't talk about splitting engines and tenders for more PROFIT!
Thousand buck a piece, roughly
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: Thousand buck a piece, roughly
Dave....gone by invitation
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: Thousand buck a piece, roughly
Part of the issue, to me anyway, is the idea that something is worth what it sells for. All you have to do is watch some of the MotorTrend car shows and find out what you paid for....isn't. Rusted, bondoed, faked.
Evilbait, BIN is often unrealistic. Probably always unrealistic, but I'd get jumped on for saying that.
When there is a starting bid, that's setting a price, now folks think that's the value, which it isn't. There is a thread here on a NP NW2, where it was BIN for $150. Horrible paint (handpainted stripes), no underneath shots to find out what was there. WAY too much even for a nice one.
Maybe the seller reads MTJ, because it got re-listed, WITH underneath shots, didn't see what starting was, but now 16 bids to $57 with two days and change left. That is still a bit much (with shipping) for the work required to fix the stripes, and it may need strip and repaint, which makes it worth less than a bare shell due to labor:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/O-scale-2-rail ... 3039334092
Evilbait, BIN is often unrealistic. Probably always unrealistic, but I'd get jumped on for saying that.
When there is a starting bid, that's setting a price, now folks think that's the value, which it isn't. There is a thread here on a NP NW2, where it was BIN for $150. Horrible paint (handpainted stripes), no underneath shots to find out what was there. WAY too much even for a nice one.
Maybe the seller reads MTJ, because it got re-listed, WITH underneath shots, didn't see what starting was, but now 16 bids to $57 with two days and change left. That is still a bit much (with shipping) for the work required to fix the stripes, and it may need strip and repaint, which makes it worth less than a bare shell due to labor:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/O-scale-2-rail ... 3039334092
Dave....gone by invitation
Re: Thousand buck a piece, roughly
Treat eBay like politics . If you take it to heart you'll get agida.
I spend entirely too many hours a day tying my shoes
- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42237
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: Thousand buck a piece, roughly
ScaleCraft wrote:When there is a starting bid, that's setting a price, now folks think that's the value, which it isn't.
Of course it isn't. It hasn't sold yet,
There is a thread here on a NP NW2, where it was BIN for $150. Horrible paint (handpainted stripes), no underneath shots to find out what was there. WAY too much even for a nice one. Maybe the seller reads MTJ, because it got re-listed, WITH underneath shots, didn't see what starting was, but now 16 bids to $57 with two days and change left. That is still a bit much (with shipping) for the work required to fix the stripes, and it may need strip and repaint, which makes it worth less than a bare shell due to labor:
Yes, it's still a mess, but you can see the drive now; maybe that's what's driving the price/bidding now? I used to routinely sell just the basic transmission part and axle for $45.
Curious to see what that sells for now.
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 51 guests