Page 1 of 2
New Lionel E-8
Posted: Sat Nov 11, 2017 2:03 pm
by bob turner
Just saw a photo on NK of an L&N E-8. They were raving about it.
I am of the opinion that the Lionel Alco PA is as accurate as they get, but it looks like Lionel kind of missed on the windshield and headlight of the EMD model (not to mention the L&N paint). That is just a gut feel from the photos posted.
Any opinions from bulldog nose specialists?
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Sat Nov 11, 2017 6:10 pm
by E7
Looks like the headlight is dead on vertical and it should be tilted back at the top just a tad.. The F9 is the only covered wagon that is oriented straight up and down to my knowledge. Take a look at the Norfolk Southern executive units. The old Roco F9's got that aspect correct. As always, there is the swinging pilot and the lobster claw. No expertise needed for that, just look closely at pics of the real thing.
edit for typo
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Sat Nov 11, 2017 9:43 pm
by bob turner
I was thinking the windsield might be too high. I do have an E-unit book - I will look at the E-8s to see if windshield is different.
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Sun Nov 12, 2017 12:55 am
by E7
bob turner wrote:I was thinking the windsield might be too high.
Stuff like that is hard to tell unless you have photo to compare it to, or the thing is so far off it's obvious.
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Tue Nov 14, 2017 11:00 pm
by De Bruin
Bob, sorry but where did you see a Lionel L&N E8 on NK?
Not having any luck finding it over there.
I have rubbed my eyeballs on a lot of photos of L&N E-units and I'd like to see how the "orange box" would do one of them.
Pete
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Tue Nov 14, 2017 11:29 pm
by bob turner
https://ogrforum.ogaugerr.com/topic/new ... landn-e8-sThese things move down the pages so fast - that is one active forum. Page six, I think.
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2017 12:58 am
by De Bruin
Thanks,
Agree the headlight bezel is too vertical as in 90 degree. Of course I guess we'll never know what this looks like without the split pilot either.
Otherwise not bad, no one into fine scale would take this version seriously but I have to admit to buying one their GG1's recently; it's one of the few versions if maybe only version I've seen with the high air intakes for the snow separators. Looks great.
My main beef with virtually all things E8 via the PRC as with the Korean Weavers is the infernal insistence on the Dynamic Brake Fan, the rest of the specific missing details can be addressed but you know, a lot of dough to buy and then spend more dough and time on making it look right.
Don't get me started on that blue base coat though, though I believe the road number is actually correct.
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2017 3:18 pm
by robert.
Why are the windshield wipers always placed mid action? If that was mine I'd snap them off.
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Thu Nov 16, 2017 3:25 am
by E7
robert. wrote:Why are the windshield wipers always placed mid action? If that was mine I'd snap them off.
Before you start snapping, take a look at some prototype Pics:
https://images.search.yahoo.com/yhs/sea ... tion=clickClick the right arrow and check out the GN unit
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Thu Nov 16, 2017 7:01 am
by robert.
Very odd placement on the prototypes. It would drive me crazy if i was an engineer with that right in front of me all day. Look at this one.
E8-08.jpg
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Thu Nov 16, 2017 7:19 am
by E7
Doesn't look like that one ever had wipers!
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Thu Nov 16, 2017 7:34 am
by robert.
#796 is in the link to NK. When all those prototype guys go crazy over little details they'll start snapping.

It was by chance that i found that photo and luck that it had the same #. I had an old Jeep Willys. When i drove the wipers were always in my view. You had to crank them by hand. I found it easier to drove with the window folded down.
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Thu Nov 16, 2017 8:19 am
by sarge
If they (the self-anointed proto-experts that rule OGR) are going ballistic over L&N 796 as an example to use for correctness, they are just irritating themselves needlessly. Silly boys.
Its a cosmetically stabilised display loco of today, not an example of what configuration, form, scheme, or even of completeness they would be in, say, in 1960. It's not even an L&N loco, for God's sake; how can it remotely be considered a detail reference? It's a resto using a Northwestern/METRA hulk, and absolutely useless for the purpose of determining how one looked in service. I'd bet they just bondo'd over the spindle holes and painted away, not knowing or caring about little $hit like wipers.
It's a great big effing model, with all the detail flaws of any model.
Look at photos mindful of date and location if you want to niggle the details. Museum pieces, exec rebuilds, and outdoor displays are useless references not worth anything in the quest for accuracy, unless you are modelling a particular museum piece, exec rebuild, or outdoor display.
Good Lord how they scratch themselves sore whilst trumpeting their ignorance....
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Thu Nov 16, 2017 9:40 am
by Chris Rock
Hi,
In the thread linked above, it doesn't look like anyone is talking about detail except that they think the paint scheme is pretty and that he is going to change the couplers. It is more like someone stating that they like their new toy which is okay by me, not rivet counting to any degree and not even pretending to do so.
In that thread, to say they are raving over it looks like an exageration to me. Am I looking at the wrong thread? I see about 5 posts in the thread and 4 out of those five are congratulations, nice engine and beautiful type comments.
Brian, what thread are you looking at?
Re: New Lionel E-8
Posted: Thu Nov 16, 2017 1:07 pm
by E7
robert.
Just for sh*ts and giggles, there are some you tube videos (a series in 3 parts) of a ride in a Western Maryland F unit. The camera is looking out the windshield. I don't recall seeing wipers. What I'm saying is, maybe the seating is such that you look to the side of the wipers??? Anyhow, they are sort of interesting, and at one point a black bear runs across the tracks. The loco in the video is black with the old "speed" lettering.
Guess you don't drive much in the rain!
Sorry, had to kid you a bit!
Rich