Removing, Replacing, and Quartering Drives
Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2017 11:56 am
.
The latest project on the workbench is the restoration of this water-damaged Hines 2-8-2 chassis:
UGH -- Look at that rust! I have been encouraged to salvage these by rotary wire brush, media blasting, and/or craytex wheel, but I am not a fan of blind drivers when not prototypical, and as such I would have to remove these anyway to replace the tires. The spokes and hubs of the wheel castings are badly rusted away in spots, which raises the question of whether it is a good idea to invest the time to refurbish and upgrade these, which would involve removing all the rust, replacing the blind tires with flanged tires (which I don't have), and then taking a cut on all the drivers to true the diameters. That is a lot of work on a damaged set. As I it, I have a set of replacements:
I have an interest in learning how to remove, replace, and quarter drivers. The original drivers are broached and thus self-quartering, but the replacements will need be quartered. The replacement drivers include new axles, which are smooth all around (no key or flat for quartering, and not knurled). I have two questions:
1. I would imagine that in theory it's OK to press out the old drivers on an arbor press, but with all the drivers on it would be tricky or tedious to get a good purchase to support the frame while pressing. So I am thinking that a puller may be in order. Does anybody have any experience with the NWSL wheel puller? Other ideas? I recall my frugal father removing the flywheel from the lawnmower engine using a puller made from a door hinge.
2. Can the NWSL quartering tool be used when installing drivers straight onto a frame? The tool looks like it was designed for models in which the drivers can be "dropped out" (by removing lower bearing caps). The Hines Mikado has a one-piece frame so the drivers have to be split for removal and installation. Joe Foehrkolb finds the NWSL tool awkward and has an interesting technique of using V-blocks and a surface gauge for quartering and then a lathe for pressing the drivers home. I recently become owner of a full-size lathe so Joe's technique is now an option. However, I am interested in hearing how others do it or what they may think of the NWSL quartering tool.
Any input in these regards will be greatly appreciated.
Jim
The latest project on the workbench is the restoration of this water-damaged Hines 2-8-2 chassis:
UGH -- Look at that rust! I have been encouraged to salvage these by rotary wire brush, media blasting, and/or craytex wheel, but I am not a fan of blind drivers when not prototypical, and as such I would have to remove these anyway to replace the tires. The spokes and hubs of the wheel castings are badly rusted away in spots, which raises the question of whether it is a good idea to invest the time to refurbish and upgrade these, which would involve removing all the rust, replacing the blind tires with flanged tires (which I don't have), and then taking a cut on all the drivers to true the diameters. That is a lot of work on a damaged set. As I it, I have a set of replacements:
I have an interest in learning how to remove, replace, and quarter drivers. The original drivers are broached and thus self-quartering, but the replacements will need be quartered. The replacement drivers include new axles, which are smooth all around (no key or flat for quartering, and not knurled). I have two questions:
1. I would imagine that in theory it's OK to press out the old drivers on an arbor press, but with all the drivers on it would be tricky or tedious to get a good purchase to support the frame while pressing. So I am thinking that a puller may be in order. Does anybody have any experience with the NWSL wheel puller? Other ideas? I recall my frugal father removing the flywheel from the lawnmower engine using a puller made from a door hinge.
2. Can the NWSL quartering tool be used when installing drivers straight onto a frame? The tool looks like it was designed for models in which the drivers can be "dropped out" (by removing lower bearing caps). The Hines Mikado has a one-piece frame so the drivers have to be split for removal and installation. Joe Foehrkolb finds the NWSL tool awkward and has an interesting technique of using V-blocks and a surface gauge for quartering and then a lathe for pressing the drivers home. I recently become owner of a full-size lathe so Joe's technique is now an option. However, I am interested in hearing how others do it or what they may think of the NWSL quartering tool.
Any input in these regards will be greatly appreciated.
Jim