Page 1 of 2
3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 7:25 am
by Seaboard Air Line Fan
When I bought my 3rd Rail E7 I was still doing 3-rail. Now that I've decided to convert to 2-rail track (still using 3-rail wheels) and converting the engines over to BPRC I decided to convert the E7 this past week. There's a short video over on the Club Car Lounge forum.
While removing the center rollers, I noticed a number of tiny screws missing (3 on the rear truck and 1 on the front) from the cross member where they were attached and a bunch of holes where it looks like the assembler didn't drill them in the correct spots:

- rear truck.jpg (275.32 KiB) Viewed 6195 times

- front truck.jpg (284.82 KiB) Viewed 6195 times
My question is, is the cross member even needed? Are they on the 2-rail engines or are they there just to support the center rollers?
I would just as soon remove them if not needed. I would go ahead and take them off, but don't feel like fooling with those tiny screws and finding out I need to put them back if the cross member is a necessity.
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 7:47 am
by Seaboard Air Line Fan
Another question.
There's a bit of "whine" coming from the horizontal motor/belt drive, it actually gives off a nice tone. Do I have something to worry about and is there any belt dressing to help quiet it?
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 11:02 am
by rrjjf
Seaboard,
If you intend to operate this model on scale 2 rail track you will probably have trouble with the hirail flanges the the frogs at any switches on your railroad. Those flanges are too wide and deep.
Joe
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 11:28 am
by Jay Criswell
Don't put anything on the belts. They are toothed timing belts. I may be wrong but I seriously doubt the whine is coming from the belts.
I make replacement axles w/gears, thrust washers and P:48 wheels. They are meant for converting Sunset 3rd Rail diesels to P:48. I may be doing a set of O Scale (Ow5) for a fellow modeler. If so I will use NWSL wheels.
Have you figured out how you're going to do the electrical pickup? The factory 2r models have insulated wheels all around and wipers that mount to the cross braces you asked about removing (by the way, I wouldn't). Speaking of electrical pickup, aren't all the wheels non-insulated? If so you'll have a direct short when placed on the track.
Factory 2R

- 2017-09-13 002.JPG (1.48 MiB) Viewed 6159 times
Converted to P:48

- 2017-09-13 023.JPG (1.52 MiB) Viewed 6159 times
Axle sets being made

- 2017-09-26 002.JPG (2.11 MiB) Viewed 6159 times
Jay
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 11:38 am
by bob turner
I would say keep the lower cross-ties. Unless the upper bolster is substantial, the sideframes would have a tendency to "splay" outward at the bottom.
I note plenty of space to bring those sideframes inboard for a better look, even with the wide gauge wheels.
Bob - get a good screw holder that you can use to start the screws. Some day you will convert to scale wheels, and you will need to deal with those screws.
He is using battery power, so insulation doesn't matter.
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 11:45 am
by Jay Criswell
Bob,
Guess you're not aware. These conversion sets were designed to be direct replacements and we intentionally left them long so the modeler doesn't have to attempt narrowing the bolster. Doing so is not that easy and really can create a problem (the model's warranty is one example). Left as they are, the modeler can re-install their originals if they want to go back to Ow5.
There were write-ups about all of this is OSR & OST. Might not hurt to go read about it before commenting.
Jay
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 11:47 am
by E7
Jay,
Bob runs RC Battery power. He doesn't need pickups.
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 12:10 pm
by Jay Criswell
Yeah, but most don't.
Maybe this project is a total waste of my time. We post the stuff and nobody sees it.
This was posted on this forum and talked about at length.
viewtopic.php?f=10&t=17217Jay
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 12:28 pm
by E7
Jay,
It may be more not remembering than seeing. I am terminal CRS!
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 1:08 pm
by Jay Criswell
So posting it on forums, magazines, and social media (facebook) is a waste of time and money?
Jay
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 1:33 pm
by Seaboard Air Line Fan
rrjjf wrote:Seaboard,
If you intend to operate this model on scale 2 rail track you will probably have trouble with the hirail flanges the the frogs at any switches on your railroad. Those flanges are too wide and deep.
Joe
Joe, I’ve already tried it on ME and Atlas code 148 and Signature Switch #6 switches and they all work fine. Really surprised me but I’m happy, converting rolling stock to 2-rail is one thing but converting engines is something I’ll leave to guys like you.
Thanks Jay, I’ll leave the belt as is.
I’m currently still running on 3-Rail modified to 2-Rail track (pulled up center rail) with 072 curves and think that may be what’s causing the noise I’m hearing. The new layout will have 49.5” radius curves, I’ll find out soon if that’s going to fix it.
BobT, I’ll keep the cross members, but I think I’ll take one off to see why screws are missing. Could be the holes aren’t tapped correctly.
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 2:24 pm
by E7
Jay Criswell wrote:So posting it on forums, magazines, and social media (facebook) is a waste of time and money?
Jay
I wouldn't say that, but in this particular case all my stuff is 2 rail, so no conversions necessary! That said, it looks like a winner to me.
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 2:44 pm
by Jay Criswell
Maybe, but the primary audience never was 3r. Never meant to be for converting 3 to 2. Just worked out that it could be used for a decent starting point.
Jay
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 2:51 pm
by Seaboard Air Line Fan
I only wish all my engines were easy to swap wheels, I’d have to go back to work full time to afford to have Joe convert all mine
IF... I had realized how much I like the old Williams/Samhongsa brass engines I would have stayed away from die cast and most likely even diesel, staying all steam.
One good thing about keeping the hi-rail wheels is my trains will run on just about any track.
Re: 3rd Rail E7???
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2018 3:01 pm
by bob turner
I apologize. I have no desire to harpoon others' opinions. Like boiler bellies, one of my hangups is sideframes that stick out too far. That is why I model in 1 1/8" gauge, and why I am enthusiastic about Proto-48. I meant no slight to those who wish to retain wide sideframes for re-conversion or simplicity.
I have very few converted items around - mostly a couple Williams locomotives and some plastic TMs. The steamers all get their sideframes moved inboard a full 1/16" per side. Makes a difference for me. Some of the really good Lionel scale items have sideframes that exceed the width of the car body! Check out that die cast turbine that I lust after.