Page 1 of 2
Ebay stuff
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 10:20 am
by sarge
Several here find eBay to be humourous and entertaining, whilst others find it eye-rolling clutter.
Before the stereotype snarky retort card, "If you aren't interested, don't read it!" gets thrown, one never knows its yet another commentary on an eBay idiot until one opens it up and reads it, does one?
Oddly, there is a forum here for ebay. Innocent question comes to mind. Why isn't it used for the purpose rather than giggling about eBay here?
Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 12:45 pm
by ScaleCraft
because in that entire sub forum there are what, 58 total replies?
We get more coverage here, and it succeeds in whizzing off the local inhabitants.
Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 1:12 pm
by bob turner
Besides, it is about half of all posts here. Good thing Jon gave it another try and posted some trains, or we would have to rename this forum.
Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 1:36 pm
by Rufus T. Firefly
sarge wrote:Why isn't it used for the purpose rather than giggling about eBay here?
In the past have asked the same question.....
We get more coverage here
..and that is something along the lines of response I got then.
I suspect the real reason is that there are very, very few actual model builders and/or model RR'ers here that are willing to post anything related to their interests and activities, and that skews the numbers of topics in the direction of eBay.
Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 1:53 pm
by bob turner
You have seen all my photos at least twice. Otherwise I would be posting more. I actually subscribe to the idea that if I am not really interested I do not read it - so seeing threads that go on and on about non-train stuff really only bothers me in the sense that I am not getting my daily "train fix".
I rarely visit the 3-rail section. I only visit the Club Lounge when somebody brings it up, and even then ten seconds tells me it is not my chosen way to waste time.
And eBay! I do have searches set up, but am somewhat jaded - same old stuff. Have not seen a good deal doorstop PA in maybe five years, and as you know, I have all the Lobaugh that anybody could ever want, and then some. So when an alert comes up here I go look. Most of the time it is something about which I have little interest. Still, it beats going through pages of overpriced junk just to see if an O Scale item of interest has been posted.
All that said - I use the internet for entertainment mostly - and actually get very little serious stuff out of it. I have to research a case now and then, and the internet has saved me a bunch of trips to the excellent USD Law Library. And it has helped me understand my friend's fixation with "natural law". But by and large, it is for fun. Off to the airport . . .
Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 2:29 pm
by up148
Worst case scenario, we get to learn about different segments of our hobby, that I personally would not pursue. I know more about Lobaugh, Scalecraft, etc. values that I ever dreamed I would. Plus many other fascinating facts about companies and individuals I never knew about.
Best case scenario, we keep the forum active, which seems to propagate other topics and possibly more modeling. I'm too busy with work, my new toy and working in the garden/yard to post almost anything right now, but I love reading everything...good....bad...or ugly. If it gets too silly, I just bypass it.
BH
Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 5:23 pm
by sarge
ScaleCraft wrote:because in that entire sub forum there are what, 58 total replies?
We get more coverage here, and it succeeds in whizzing off the local inhabitants.
bob turner wrote:Besides, it is about half of all posts here. Good thing Jon gave it another try and posted some trains, or we would have to rename this forum.
Fair enough, though to be honest once the eBay mavins get used to actually using the "right" subforum, there is no reason why the count wouldn't take off there, and good for that! Really, its no different then, say, adding a bunch of tinplate threads here just to get the count up rather than going to that forum when one might want to learn or ask something of tinplate.
As far as the count argument, for me its a spurious one. I for one prefer quality over quantity, and one could further argue that other modelers spurn this forum because it seems dominated by eBay, preferring to take their modelling elsewhere.
Of course, if the O Scale world is indeed morphing from a builder's hobby to the shopping hobby, well the eBay commentary is most germane.

Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 6:27 pm
by herronpeter
Hey Sarge,
If you check out the thread below, you will see that it didn't take long to morph from train related to car related. Many of the eBay posts I make do similar things. I see you participated in the automobile portion of it.
_______________
viewtopic.php?f=10&t=17657________________________________
A long while ago I asked if people wanted me to stop posting eBay listings of both the absurd and/or of interest and I received replies to keep it up, they are entertaining.
If I had not posted it would you have brought up your ageless Mercury?
Peter
Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 7:08 pm
by sarge
herronpeter wrote:Hey Sarge,
If you check out the thread below, you will see that it didn't take long to morph from train related to car related. Many of the eBay posts I make do similar things. I see you participated in the automobile portion of it.
_______________
viewtopic.php?f=10&t=17657________________________________
A long while ago I asked if people wanted me to stop posting eBay listings of both the absurd and/or of interest and I received replies to keep it up, they are entertaining.
If I had not posted it would you have brought up your ageless Mercury?
Peter
If I'm honest, it was only after others drifted off from eBay to cars it became remotely interesting to me, but that's me.
If everyone else is entertained by the absurd in eBay listings, though, who am I to say? I just asked why that entertainment was so important to be here rather than on the forum provided. The answer has been given that its because that's what the majority here are interested in, and no-one here builds enough to keep the forum going otherwise.
Nothing pejorative intended, but these recent questions are part of a greater search on my part. You see, this has been a profession for me for decades, and now it is no longer. I'm casting about wondering what it has to offer as a hobby again, since so much is changed since it was last a pastime indulged in for pleasure for me.
So, question asked and answered.
Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 10:11 pm
by herronpeter
Sarge,
I’m relatively new here so I’m interested in what your profession was in the train field.
Thanks,
Peter
Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 10:12 pm
by bob turner
I missed the Mercury. Not sure I want to dig - unless it was a 1950 or maybe a 1941? I do have two ancient Mustang convertibles, as in over a half century old. One took me to the airport today.
I regard this as the best 2-rail source of entertainment. The best. You guys made it that.
Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 12:37 am
by E7
sarge wrote:herronpeter wrote:Hey Sarge,
If you check out the thread below, you will see that it didn't take long to morph from train related to car related. Many of the eBay posts I make do similar things. I see you participated in the automobile portion of it.
_______________
viewtopic.php?f=10&t=17657________________________________
A long while ago I asked if people wanted me to stop posting eBay listings of both the absurd and/or of interest and I received replies to keep it up, they are entertaining.
If I had not posted it would you have brought up your ageless Mercury?
Peter
If I'm honest, it was only after others drifted off from eBay to cars it became remotely interesting to me, but that's me.
If everyone else is entertained by the absurd in eBay listings, though, who am I to say? I just asked why that entertainment was so important to be here rather than on the forum provided. The answer has been given that its because that's what the majority here are interested in, and no-one here builds enough to keep the forum going otherwise.
Nothing pejorative intended, but these recent questions are part of a greater search on my part. You see, this has been a profession for me for decades, and now it is no longer. I'm casting about wondering what it has to offer as a hobby again, since so much is changed since it was last a pastime indulged in for pleasure for me. So, question asked and answered.
The cars and politics are clearly fodder for the "Club Car Lounge" and it doesn't take a MAJOR effort to go over there and post all you like. There are topics that currently exist on both themes.
The posts on ITEMS on Ebay are NOT in my OPINION (yours may differ) about EBAY the entity, but the ITEMS themselves, and thus as long as they are 2 Rail related, proper for the 2 rail forum. One could just as easily go elsewhere (other than Ebay, that is) on the NET and link to an item and it would be essentially the same. My vision of the Ebay sub forum here on MTJ is that it exists for posts regarding discussion of the auction entity itself, and it's workings, and NOT about the items listed there.
May be snarky to you, but when I run across something that I don't like, or that is not of interest, I move on. I don't really care all that much about the old doorstop stuff, but some here do. More power to them, and I'm usually on to another topic. Would be painfully boring if we all liked the same thing, and there would probably be a H*ll of a scuffle with all of us trying to acquire it!
Instead of going on about what you DON'T like, maybe you should start posting more about what you DO like. I can pretty much assure you if you cook up some really GOOD posts, you will get comments, and more things/posts of similar ilk will likely come.
I sincerely wish I could offer a solution or even a suggestion to your quandary detailed in your last paragraph (which I bolded). I have found that when the almighty buck becomes involved, the hobby tends to disappear and a business remains. Maybe now that you have retired you will once again find joy in the hobby.
Rich
Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 1:34 am
by bob turner
Remember, if you want rigid rules and topics not allowed, NK is a mouse click away!
Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 7:34 am
by sarge
Rich and Bob, I consider myself shouted down. Rich, I don't know what your personal weed is lately, but thats fine. You might try reading for comprehension though. I actually spoke out against politics in that one posting, and the car bit was a following of the drift, not causing it. Though it really doesn't matter, but speaking of reading for comprehension go look at the line under the heading for "eBay and other online auctions". That was what the subforum was created for, hence my question posed, no judgements made but question posed. I have enough to make my own judgements now.
That's all fine, and if you care to go look you'll find most of my postings have been about what I do like; model building. Funny that "Paint Shop" is two pages back now. I'm finding the posting of projects doesn't garner interest any more, and that is telling, but its also fine.
Bob, the waving of NK was truly instructive. It has no interest to me as a social community, so I politely decline your invitation to click away.
So at least about forums and their meaning to the hobby today, thanks for the clarity.
Peter, I edited one of the magazines twice, combined over ten years of a fifteen year span, and many years as a brass dealer, repairer, and painter before that.
Re: Ebay stuff
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 9:01 am
by herronpeter
Ah, like Hal Miller, right? He's an O scale 2 railer, isn't he?
Peter