Our club layout has several hundred feet of hand-laid code 148 steel rail. It was salvaged from a layout in the Seattle area and landed in ScaleCraft Dave's garage. He offered to our club for the price of shipping. We love it. I don't find nickel-silver nearly as attractive, and we have never had a problem soldering it, even though it was a bit rusted from age. We use a wire brush wheel on a dremel to clean it up, a nominal amount of flux, and a 60-watt minimum iron with big tip (the thermal mass seems to help).
I guess I should rename this thread "Wrought Iron Rail", as that was what I was thinking. However, the spark test seems to verify that it's just mild steel. Here is the rail compared to standard steel rail:

The soft rail in question is on the right. It looks too old to be Code 125, but it is. The second-hand Code 148 steel rail as used on the club layout is in the middle. The Code 125 rail on the left, which we also use on club layout for secondary tracks, is from RIght-o-Way (Jay Criswell, current proprietor).
The sparks from all of these more or less match the on-line images of mild-steel. Here is the Code 148 regular steel:

Here is the soft steel:

There is some difference, but this was not a controlled test. Although I am told it is important, I did not take steps to make sure that the pressure put on each rail was the same (hard to do when holding your phone in one hand to take a photo). As best I can tell from on-line sources, the straight sparks, long tails, and single "fork" at the end of some of the tails are all signs of mild steel. The more forks, the more carbon, and mild steel does not have much carbon.
Some may find the video link below of interest. The talking head drones on for a while, so maybe skip ahead to the chart at 1:55. Once the tests start, mild steel comes first. Note also wrought iron at 5:00, which is very similar to mild steel. That's not much of a surprise, as mild steel is essentially wrought iron with a small amount of carbon.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D094eBa4S7cThe more I think about this, the more I want to say that the grey soft rail is simply hot-rolled steel, and the shiny rail is cold-rolled or maybe drawn. Cold rolling or drawing work-hardens it and gives it a finish. Jay might be able to tell us if there are other alloys added to the shiny rail to give it that nice finish (and might explain the slight differences in the color of the sparks). Or maybe it's a trade secret.
Jim