Page 1 of 2

Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Sun Jun 28, 2020 11:29 pm
by DaveJfr0
I've had these things since Tuesday, but encountered several issues, like my PSX being set to trigger at like 1.27 amps. Had to bust out the manual to figure out how to reset that thing. Then there was video editing. I guess iMovie 8 can't handle exporting 1080p30 (I guess its from like 2009, so okay) and windows 10 photos app that supposedly does video editing now, can't add but one caption per video and also alters the sound so poorly when converting from .mov (iphone's format) to .mp4, that I had to find something new. Enter OpenShot. After many hours of having to find new video editing software and learning it, I finally have been able to cobble together a review with videos.

Overall these units turned out really well. I'm super happy. Need to fix a few things here and there, maybe investigate that high-pitched noise emanating from the drive-train, but not much is released without needing some work. Hopefully Scott can manage a way to do the SD40-2's.

For your enjoyment.

https://davejfr0.blogspot.com/2020/06/2 ... unset.html

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Mon Jun 29, 2020 7:31 am
by up148
Thanks for sharing Dave. Nice looking locos. Scott does a great job on his models. Please post how you lower the high water pilot. Seems pretty straight forward but always looking for a better way. I've got to do the same with some E-9's I bought 5-6-7 years ago from 3rd Rail. All their diesels come this way and I'm sure the reasoning has to do with 3R operation.

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Mon Jun 29, 2020 9:03 am
by E7
May be me, but the "lobes" of the dark color paint where they surround the number boards look like they vary in shape from side to side and engine to engine. Hard to tell from the pics, but the headlights are supposed to be slightly tilted back toward the windshield, NOT vertical....curious if that got fixed?

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Sat Jul 11, 2020 6:48 pm
by DaveJfr0
Here are photos of the noses of the E7, E8, and F3 I have from Sunset, which is also the order of the age of the tooling with the earliest.

Image

I'm not great with photos and its impossible to put a machinist angle up against the light housing, but looking at them in person I'd say the F3 has a slant back toward the cab and maybe the E8, but definitely not the E7 (which while produced recently, probably did not have its tooling adjusted since the first release).

I don't know the difference, so it doesn't bother me nearly as much as other details. I took a poke around and the fuel tank castings goes all the way up to the frame now, so its gonna be a fun evening with a dremel one of these days. I have too many half-done projects sitting around that I have to finish first.

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2020 10:48 pm
by E7
Hate to be the grinch, but they all look like they are perpendicular (no backward tilt) to me. If you compare their orientation to the edges of your images (which are perpendicular) they appear to be parallel to those edges. This based on the idea that your camera was level and the engines were level

You could prove this definitively by making sure your camera is level and the engine is level and taking a shot. If the side (edge) of the image is parallel to the orientation of the headlight, that will show the tilt or lack thereof. You could also check it with a miniature square, one leg placed across the headlight. If the headlight has any backward tilt, the other leg of the square will dip downward.

Look at pictures/images of the real thing....the tilt is fairly obvious.

If you don't care then, so what!

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2020 11:23 pm
by bob turner
The E8 and E7 appear tilted. You and Butch can have a good time with this one! I am quite happy with inaccurate doorstops.

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Tue Jul 14, 2020 3:17 am
by E7
bob turner wrote:The E8 and E7 appear tilted.


The interesting part is the F3's were the latest run where the "tilt" was to be added. :lol: :lol: :lol:

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Tue Jul 14, 2020 9:09 am
by up148
Tilt doesn't bother me anymore. Roger Lewis had to prove to me EMD's had it, but its not that important as long as the rest of the model is fairly accurate. I've learned there are no perfect models.

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Tue Jul 14, 2020 3:58 pm
by E7
Butch, What "bothers" me is that it was KNOWN to be an error, and supposed to be corrected on this run. Maybe if someone keeps bitching about it they'll get it right one of these times. :mrgreen: The biggest coup would be to get Lionel to correct it! :lol: As for the "perfect" model, it's been said that Henry Bultmann's SP 4-8-2 hit the mark. I'm not so sure, as the dang thing wouldn't run on coal or oil. :mrgreen: I learned a long time ago it pays to see something before you lay out your money. :mrgreen: There is also "Rich's rule": If there are 10 of them available, with 9 being OK and the tenth not so much, it is a virtual certainty you will end up with number 10. :lol: :lol: :lol:

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Tue Jul 14, 2020 6:06 pm
by bob turner
Problem is, if you are the only one complaining, they have zero incentive to fix it.

I ran into the same thing on boiler tapers for the SP Mikes, Decks, and 4-10-2 class. Tapers were obvious to me, but nobody else cared. But I had a cure for the problem - built my own!

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Tue Jul 14, 2020 6:16 pm
by Rufus T. Firefly
bob turner wrote:Problem is, if you are the only one complaining, they have zero incentive to fix it.


Isn't that the same story on shelf couplers? :wink: :wink:

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Tue Jul 14, 2020 8:15 pm
by bob turner
Yeah, but he complained so loudly and so often they thought the market was immense. Love to know how sales are doing? Well, that’s not true; I give not one whit for shelf couplers. Hope they make a profit.

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Tue Jul 14, 2020 10:24 pm
by DaveJfr0
I don't think I ever saw an ad or a webpage for shelf couplers, or any other type of specialty couplers.

I don't know any prototype history on them either, but I'd consider them if they should be on my passenger cars, or any other freight cars in the 66-73 era.

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Tue Jul 14, 2020 10:29 pm
by DaveJfr0
I can't guarantee the loco nor the camera is level, but i tried my best, and probably can't even after my tripod mount for my iphone finally arrives.

If the slant is supposed to be really apparent, then I'd say all of these fail. If its supposed to be slight, I would stand by my statement while looking at them in person and allowing my eyes to use the environment to compare the nose to.

I may or may not have the CAD file for the E8 still to look at. I might have the F3 file too, but alas those would by on my other computer that I have yet to retrieve from a northeastern COVID wasteland, so if I remember at a later date, I may give it a glance and see if I can look at what the tooling files actually show.

Re: Sunset Models SOU Black Tuxedo F3A's

Posted: Tue Jul 14, 2020 10:53 pm
by De Bruin
I think they look great and thank you especially for the excellent overhead views of your new fleet as good prototype photos of these early Southern's passenger F's with that distinctive roof top tank conversion are hard to find and as you might remember we model that road extensively at the RMCA.
I'm considering building up an old KenKraft or All Nation F3 to approximate one of these , and these shots are pure gold.
Once again thanks!

FYI on a not-related note, all this covid stuff has greatly reduced our attendance but we still manage to pull the whole schedule per month albeit it takes three weeks whereas we used to be able to do it in one three+ hour Saturday. Not itching to work on the website until all of this calms down either. It's a big layout so social distancing is pretty easy...

Back to the subject at hand you still need rolling stock for these and also that nice E8 set you have now you know.
Specifically to the issue on the angle of the headlight? Looks good to me, but you know as long as it's not an oval I'm not that picky either.
Pete