Page 1 of 1

Kalmbach subscriber campaign

Posted: Tue Apr 12, 2022 7:21 am
by sarge
I haven't paid any attention to MR, not subscribing since Andy Sperandeo retired and probably not even given it a glance since Tony K's series documenting (at excessive length) what really was a very lacklustre dalliance in O.

For the first time in many years, I received a mailing from Kalmbach Media (apparently some holding company in Texas who now owns them) for Model Railroader. It was on surface a great deal, $30 for a year plus nine free gifts, those being described thus:

Image

OK, pretty aggressive way to get in my door to see if I found MR today to be of use after a long hiatus, so for thirty bucks I can get nine updated guides and flesh out the library of the classics from such luminaries as Chubb, Armstrong, Bill McClanahan, &c., whilst seeing what was so worth my renewed consideration. If nothing else, a bit of a lark after taking this up as a hobby again. Curiosity, if nothing else, caused me to give it a whirl, but caution caused me to write a cheque so no auto-payment info was in their possession.

What arrived was this. This one pamphlet is your "nine guides":
Image

Image

I leave it to you to make your own interpretations as to the integrity or wisdom of an organisation who might consider this an honest let alone positive campaign.

Re: Kalmbach subscriber campaign

Posted: Tue Apr 12, 2022 8:11 am
by Rufus T. Firefly
.

Re: Kalmbach subscriber campaign

Posted: Tue Apr 12, 2022 9:12 am
by sarge
On reflection, perhaps, but I do like to keep flexible, keep an open mind, and give folks the benefit of the doubt initially. Occasionally one is pleasantly surprised.

I haven't commented on my opinion of the magazine itself in the current iteration the company wanted to draw my attention to.

Re: Kalmbach subscriber campaign

Posted: Tue Apr 12, 2022 10:33 am
by Rufus T. Firefly
.

Re: Kalmbach subscriber campaign

Posted: Tue Apr 12, 2022 7:38 pm
by ScaleCraft
There have been so many reports of folks being sent magazines without asking for them, later getting billed for that.

I used to have dealings with them....but they got a hair up their butt and started firing folks. Oh, and same amount of work, just dumped it on those left behind.
Closing magazines, eliminating content, deciding video content was the future, renamed it Klambake Media.....put the property up for sale....doesn't surprise me if they weren't in Wisconsin any more.

There was so much pandering going on. Couldn't tell the truth in a review..oh, no. Some folks lived for review samples for their collections. I know who and I ain't saying.

MR couldn't write an honest review if their life depended on it. I watched...carefully.
When a specific manufacturer published that their newest item has sockets you can plug A, B, C, D, and E into...and MR basically does a cut and paste......it's all bs.

I called their reviewer....had a chat with him. Asked him how all that stuff actually, well, you know, WORKED when he plugged it in.

His comment that they didn't have any of that stuff to plug in was followed by my comment that none of that stuff EXISTS...yet. All in work, none made or tested

One of the biggies in that escapade was that the manufacturer built the chuff triggers (optical) with inverted outputs. There was exactly ONE sound system that you could trigger with it, from Germany.

All to make the manufacturer feel warm and fuzzy and keep the end users in the dark.

The Klambake worker bees had no idea what was actually happening in the model railroading world. Several would get calls from me couple of times a month so they would understand what was happening. Until one of the brass stopped that.

Had nothing to do with them at all for some time now.

Re: Kalmbach subscriber campaign

Posted: Tue Apr 12, 2022 8:46 pm
by E7
[quote="sarge"]I



What arrived was this. This one pamphlet is your "nine guides":
Image

Image

IMaybe if you had sent in 1/9 of the subscription price.... :mrgreen:

Re: Kalmbach subscriber campaign

Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2022 12:43 am
by De Bruin
Maybe they're assuming we're all a bunch of collective of "fecking bloated urinal cakes between the ears."
God, Rufus!-
So friggin' good!
:lol:

Re: Kalmbach subscriber campaign

Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2022 9:18 am
by up148
I got screwed the same way about 2 years ago. 9 gifts.........yeah right.......and all were reprints of previous articles. I thought I read the fine print pretty good, but like you, I was very surprised by what I received.....haven't and won't look back......my bad.

Someone did well in their "creative writing" class. :D :D

The only small saving grace was Tony's O scale article was in my subscription period, but like you, I felt "is that all". So much more could have been done and said.

Re: Kalmbach subscriber campaign

Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2022 12:33 pm
by bob turner
Haven't really taken a serious look fo forty years - but their classifieds always worked!

I sent them a nice photo of an unpainted scratch AC-8. The returned it crumpled stating they never publish unpainted models. That was before I discovered that one never enters unpainted models in contests - they are simply not popular.