sarge wrote: In the interests of full disclosure, though, I'll mention that I'm watching my parents get "treated" by a system they still trust, and have had two good friends driven to suicide after being cleaned out and put in the street by this system, so perhaps I am a bit unfairly cynical...
And, as such your viewpoint just might be a tad skewed hence that yelling so loud.
Happens all the time since there's this societal history of trust the doc and the doc knows best. There's no excuse for that now - you can educate yourself well enough to ask the real questions that need to be asked and then go shop for another doc. People let themselves get led by the nose not knowing that they are also the customer and can ask and frelling well better get the answers or they need to get a new doc.
This sounds very much like your parents' position. This is why I watched over my in-laws and my Father in law when he was diagnosed with prostate. First doc they saw fell right into your above categories - I had to explain to them that he was not treating a patient - he was treating a billable unit. They did not believe me - I sent them to another doc and they then admitted that I was correct. I sent them to the chief of Rad Onc at a major center - friend of mine. He sat them down for a few hours and talked to them and explained everything. 180 degree turn and difference; they were amazed and very grateful. That generation is unwilling to distrust their personal doc and get second opinions - in fact, the 1st doc they saw complained bitterly that they were seeing anyone else. Blind trust is deadly. Your parents sound like they need to get 2nd opinions!
Suicides.....military perhaps? I've had one friend retired Navy that had prostate cancer. Med Onc in Norfolk was going to do chemo and told him not to talk to the Surgeon or Rad Onc. Surgeon was going to cut it out and told him not to talk to the other 2. Rad Onc was going to zap it and you guessed - don't talk to the other 2. I sent him to our prostate clinic where he met with all 3 at the same time and they did a consensus treatment - happy patient at the end that thanks me to this day. BTW, that clinic if free. That's right, your tax dollars supports a free clinic that treats prostate cancer patients. Almost no one knows about it since there's no advertising and doc's on the outside won't refer their billable units.
Moral is that good care is available, but just like any other commodity, it pays to be educated and to shop around. Ask questions and if something doesn't add up, move on. Oh, here's an advocacy group for almost everything - find the one you need and ask questions and get information. In this day and age, there's no excuse not to take care of yourself. No one else is going to....
I've walked away from at least 1 (2?) of my own docs that could not bother to answer questions - run, do not walk when that happens. 1st doc I had in DC never wanted to see me unless I told him I did not know what was wrong - as long as I knew hat was wrong, he'd phone is a prescription for whatever we agreed on. If I called not knowing what was wrong, he found time to see me since I was not wasting his time.
Next doc stopped listening to me in mid-sentence - NEXT! Arrogant git too that just knew everything and generally got it wrong, too. Had he been listening to the patient what the problem was that actually knew what he was talking about......
Put up with a few that were "ok" and did no harm, and then finally got hooked into one that actually listened again. Did get yelled at that one time I did surgery on my own toe....but she admitted in the end that I did the right thing.
That one left and I got yet another that listens - hope to keep her for a good long while
Disclaimer; working for the NIH for 30+ years does put one in a position where contact to the best all over the world resides in the rolodex or and e-mail away. I have oft times stated that if the public would take the time to really understand how all this stuff works, we'd all either be confronted by pitchforks and torches at the gates, or things just might get better.