For your evaluation
-
Tom Dempsey
- Posts: 1002
- Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 10:15 pm
For your evaluation
Every Power Pack I have seems to be a pulsed unit (most are MRC or starter set packs) and they are "messing" with the board I am currently trying to install in a locomotive. What I want is up to 6 amps of straight DC, no ripple, no pulse, a straight line on an oscilloscope at 12 volts. Your evaluation would be gratefully accepted, brutality is allowed/encouraged (if necessary). Thanks, as always, Tom Dempsey
Re: For your evaluation
I have a shit-ton of wall warts, all 6 amp at 12 volts I can send you and then you make your own pot. Back in the day we used car charges and Marnold controller.
I had quite thy set up back in the early 80's...
http://www.glkinst.com/test-equipment/m ... g_1960.pdf
I had quite thy set up back in the early 80's...
http://www.glkinst.com/test-equipment/m ... g_1960.pdf
Regards,
Dan
The Model Railroad Resource LLC
407 East Chippewa St - Dwight, IL 60420
Voice 815.584.1577 / FAX 800.783.0127
daniel@modelrailroadresource.com / http://modelrailroadresource.com
http://oscaleresource.com/ and http://sscaleresource.com/
Dan
The Model Railroad Resource LLC
407 East Chippewa St - Dwight, IL 60420
Voice 815.584.1577 / FAX 800.783.0127
daniel@modelrailroadresource.com / http://modelrailroadresource.com
http://oscaleresource.com/ and http://sscaleresource.com/
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: For your evaluation
Condensors. Capacitors. I see none in your drawing. Often (provable with an o-scope) a big, whacking capacitor across the output of your noisy supply will quiet it right down (electrically).
Dave....gone by invitation
-
Tom Dempsey
- Posts: 1002
- Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 10:15 pm
Re: For your evaluation
Scalecraft, all the filters in the world won't re-engineer pulsed DC, that's why I have to build something different. Dan, if I was smart enough to use old school technology, I'd just rebuild this.
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: For your evaluation
Most of the "pulsed" old packs I have are simply half-wave filtered. In fact, the old Aristo Train Engineer trackside unit has a "pulsed" and "linear" setting, all the "linear" does is throw a cap into the mix.
Square waves, no, but if it's sine wave pulse, yes.
BTW, my old MRC packs have a "pulse" setting...or not. I think. Have to check...I have an old H0 pack with alligators on leads for testing of H0, 0 and 1 locos.
In smaller scales, "pulsed" power was for slow speed and starting....you never ran in mainline with it as the motors could and possibly would melt down.
" The classic GOlden Throttlepack 501 though, will nto work well on modern low current motors. The key giveaway to what works and what doesn't - if it specifies HO or N scale, it is likely a rheostat speed control and this will NOT work well on modern locos. Simplyt put, the low current draw on many modern motors does not cause enough voltage drop across the rheostat to allow for much of a slow speed control. The diffrence between scales is that the N scale ones used a different rheostat than the HO ones, because the N scale motors drew less current. AN N scale pack might work for modern low current HO motors, but it would have the reverse problem if you run any older locos - they would never go very fast. Transistor packs like the Tech II and Tech 4 series don;t have this problem because the load current is not what controls the voltage drop to the rails and can work with any DC motor in any scale up to the rated current limit."
"I have a MRC Throttlepack 501 and a MRC ControlmasterX. Both have pulse power which give excellent slow speed running for the older open frame motors. You can just creep with these they run so slow.
Running the newer locomotives turn off the pulse power otherwise you can harm the motors."
"I still have one gold case MRC pack, and a Tenshodo pack of similar vintage (1960s.) I made two modifications that improved them for control of more modern motors:
Replaced the original selenium stack rectifier with a silicon bridge rectifier.
Rewired the rheostat as a potentiometer, so I get voltage control, not current control.
That second mod adds about ,4 amps to the draw from the transformer, but still leaves plenty of power, even for old open-frame motors."
Square waves, no, but if it's sine wave pulse, yes.
BTW, my old MRC packs have a "pulse" setting...or not. I think. Have to check...I have an old H0 pack with alligators on leads for testing of H0, 0 and 1 locos.
In smaller scales, "pulsed" power was for slow speed and starting....you never ran in mainline with it as the motors could and possibly would melt down.
" The classic GOlden Throttlepack 501 though, will nto work well on modern low current motors. The key giveaway to what works and what doesn't - if it specifies HO or N scale, it is likely a rheostat speed control and this will NOT work well on modern locos. Simplyt put, the low current draw on many modern motors does not cause enough voltage drop across the rheostat to allow for much of a slow speed control. The diffrence between scales is that the N scale ones used a different rheostat than the HO ones, because the N scale motors drew less current. AN N scale pack might work for modern low current HO motors, but it would have the reverse problem if you run any older locos - they would never go very fast. Transistor packs like the Tech II and Tech 4 series don;t have this problem because the load current is not what controls the voltage drop to the rails and can work with any DC motor in any scale up to the rated current limit."
"I have a MRC Throttlepack 501 and a MRC ControlmasterX. Both have pulse power which give excellent slow speed running for the older open frame motors. You can just creep with these they run so slow.
Running the newer locomotives turn off the pulse power otherwise you can harm the motors."
"I still have one gold case MRC pack, and a Tenshodo pack of similar vintage (1960s.) I made two modifications that improved them for control of more modern motors:
Replaced the original selenium stack rectifier with a silicon bridge rectifier.
Rewired the rheostat as a potentiometer, so I get voltage control, not current control.
That second mod adds about ,4 amps to the draw from the transformer, but still leaves plenty of power, even for old open-frame motors."
Dave....gone by invitation
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: For your evaluation
So, we need to ask what you mean by "pulse". Old days, half-wave AC was "pulsed". Old packs didn't even have filters.
Full or half wave is all pulsed...full wave less...half wave more.
Full or half wave is all pulsed...full wave less...half wave more.
Dave....gone by invitation
-
Tom Dempsey
- Posts: 1002
- Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 10:15 pm
Re: For your evaluation
That is what it has been called by others talking to me about it, it shows up on the oscilloscope as groups of triangular shaped ripples (very jagged) that seem to reduce to zero then repeat, filters don't seem to fix it. Most of my MRC packs are Tech III's left over from the NTRAK days. They wreak havoc on the BlueRail boards I'm trying to work with. If I'm going to be breaking out the soldering iron and modifying, I'd just prefer to do a whole new build. That way I'm sure of what I'm starting with. If I have to put a filter across the output, so be it, do you think I would need a filter for the schematic above? My thought was the bridge rectifier would straighten it out. Any help is always welcome. Thanks, Tom Dempsey
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: For your evaluation
https://elmassian.com/images/stories/electronics/misc/full_wave_rectification.jpg
https://elmassian.com/images/stories/electronics/misc/rectification-3.gif
On old packs, you just need to filter the output before the reverse switch.
https://elmassian.com/images/stories/electronics/misc/rectification-3.gif
On old packs, you just need to filter the output before the reverse switch.
Dave....gone by invitation
-
Tom Dempsey
- Posts: 1002
- Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 10:15 pm
Re: For your evaluation
Okay, thanks ScaleCraft. It's been a couple decades since BEEP school in the Navy and working on full size locomotives I never really had to deal with this. A filter it shall be. I'll probably crack open one of the Tech III's and see about fixing it also. Any suggestion on capacitor rating?
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: For your evaluation
Tom Dempsey wrote:That is what it has been called by others talking to me about it, it shows up on the oscilloscope as groups of triangular shaped ripples (very jagged) that seem to reduce to zero then repeat, filters don't seem to fix it. Most of my MRC packs are Tech III's left over from the NTRAK days. They wreak havoc on the BlueRail boards I'm trying to work with. If I'm going to be breaking out the soldering iron and modifying, I'd just prefer to do a whole new build. That way I'm sure of what I'm starting with. If I have to put a filter across the output, so be it, do you think I would need a filter for the schematic above? My thought was the bridge rectifier would straighten it out. Any help is always welcome. Thanks, Tom Dempsey
Ah, more information. Tech III's use SCR's and give a triangular shape output. Like you describe. SCR's were cheaper, did not require a full wave bridge.

SCR's only work in one direction, so you get the sawtooth form.
The Tech III is NOT and "old" MRC pack. It's middle aged.
Theoretically if you put a full wave bridge before the SCR you could smooth that out.
Me?
I'd be using a big power transformer, a Selenium Rectumfrier, Ohmmite rheostat, couple of BIG electolytics.....
Dave....gone by invitation
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: For your evaluation
2N3055 at 25C handles 7 amps (115 watts max at 25C) Burn your finger at 160F, right? In C that's 71C That's 3X max, max 80W. 16V handles max 5A with a fan.
BEEP...did that..and ETA, ETC, SINS, LORAN, SPS6 Radar.
BEEP...did that..and ETA, ETC, SINS, LORAN, SPS6 Radar.
Dave....gone by invitation
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
-
Tom Dempsey
- Posts: 1002
- Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 10:15 pm
Re: For your evaluation
ScaleCraft wrote:$500 or so gets you a Bridgeworks.
Saw one for sale at Sunset Junction in Spokane. Thing looked scary to me. I want to drive the trains, not melt them down.
-
Tom Dempsey
- Posts: 1002
- Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 10:15 pm
Re: For your evaluation
ScaleCraft wrote:2N3055 at 25C handles 7 amps (115 watts max at 25C) Burn your finger at 160F, right? In C that's 71C That's 3X max, max 80W. 16V handles max 5A with a fan.
BEEP...did that..and ETA, ETC, SINS, LORAN, SPS6 Radar.
I know I've got to effectively heatsink the power transistor and I planned on putting a 12vdc computer cooling fan on the box, just didn't put it on the schematic. Anything else you see need a dedicated heatsink?
BEEP in 1974, then the Seabees, injured falling off a telephone pole, transferred to fleet on crutches during the Vietnam stand-down that year when Construction Electrician went from undermanned to 200% manning overnight. Back to BEEP in 1979, then the GS pipeline at Great Lakes and ended up GSE1, all that school and the only thing they'd let us do on the ship was pull the card with the red light lit on it and replace it.
Re: For your evaluation
What I don't understand is if this fancy card can handle DCC which is says it can he has an AC/DC converter on board. Since most all power packs these days have pulse or whatever they call it, why would not the board have a DC to DC converter to take care of that issue... if it is a real issue. Just what exactly does this manufacture recommend people use with his product? If it's as popular as he says I have a real hard time thinking all his customers are reinventing a power supply.
Regards,
Dan
The Model Railroad Resource LLC
407 East Chippewa St - Dwight, IL 60420
Voice 815.584.1577 / FAX 800.783.0127
daniel@modelrailroadresource.com / http://modelrailroadresource.com
http://oscaleresource.com/ and http://sscaleresource.com/
Dan
The Model Railroad Resource LLC
407 East Chippewa St - Dwight, IL 60420
Voice 815.584.1577 / FAX 800.783.0127
daniel@modelrailroadresource.com / http://modelrailroadresource.com
http://oscaleresource.com/ and http://sscaleresource.com/
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 66 guests