My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
-
milepost57
- Posts: 63
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2009 10:04 am
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
You did an excellent job building this CLW kit. as far as the Kadee coupler trip pin goes, I agree that the trip pin is a distraction and a protocraft is more realistic. but if you want "hands off" automatic coupling and uncoupling, you just have to live with the kadee. I have kadee's on all my equipment and it never bothered me. ask yourself this question: what is more of a distraction? a kadee trip pin or a protocraft coupler that requires a giant human hand to enter the model scene to operate it?
Dave Eisinger
Dave Eisinger
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
I have Monarch, ScaleModels, and some Kadee. The Kadees came about when one place I went "required" them...then I found out about 1/4 of his stuff didn't have them.
So I quit.
Monarch and ScaleModels couple perfectly with Kadees. I think they were designed to do so for initial interchangeability.
I think you should find a Monarch or ScaleModel coupler at least for the nose.
Just my Turner.
So I quit.
Monarch and ScaleModels couple perfectly with Kadees. I think they were designed to do so for initial interchangeability.
I think you should find a Monarch or ScaleModel coupler at least for the nose.
Just my Turner.
Dave....gone by invitation
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
I appreciate the coupler comments. I'm a lot more comfortable with Kadees than some of you are. They are my standard and I would go as far as to clip off the trip pin since I operate them manually with home made gizmo...but that's all.
Robert
Robert
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
Robert,
The Kadee O Scale coupler came into existence about the time I was getting into O scale model trains (circa 1970). As far as I am concerned it was a very great improvement for O scale modelers. Years ago I was a member of the Baltimore Society of Model Engineers, primarily on their HO division. I remember the O "scale outside 3rd rail layout and the freight cars that all had dummy knuckle couplers mounted at various heights. Instead of the O Division setting a coupler height standard, many of the cars had rubber bands around the mismatched couplers to keep them together in a consist. Today it seems some folks in their quest for perfect prototype appearance are not satisfied with the Kadee couplers anymore but all of my equipment is equipped with them and they are sufficiently scale enough in appearance for me. On some steam loco models that I have built that I do not ever intend to couple much to the front of, I will often install a scale non working coupler in the pilot for a better appearance. However, the real PRR H-8, H-9 and H-10 locomotives that were used in most terminals where steam was still in service in 1957 as switching locos and "maids of all work" would have a need for constant coupling to the loco pilot. So I think a working Kadee on the front of your H-10 is fine from a model railroad operational standpoint. Clipping off the trip pin is an option as long as you don't mind using an uncoupling tool when you have to uncouple the pilot from a car.
Joe
The Kadee O Scale coupler came into existence about the time I was getting into O scale model trains (circa 1970). As far as I am concerned it was a very great improvement for O scale modelers. Years ago I was a member of the Baltimore Society of Model Engineers, primarily on their HO division. I remember the O "scale outside 3rd rail layout and the freight cars that all had dummy knuckle couplers mounted at various heights. Instead of the O Division setting a coupler height standard, many of the cars had rubber bands around the mismatched couplers to keep them together in a consist. Today it seems some folks in their quest for perfect prototype appearance are not satisfied with the Kadee couplers anymore but all of my equipment is equipped with them and they are sufficiently scale enough in appearance for me. On some steam loco models that I have built that I do not ever intend to couple much to the front of, I will often install a scale non working coupler in the pilot for a better appearance. However, the real PRR H-8, H-9 and H-10 locomotives that were used in most terminals where steam was still in service in 1957 as switching locos and "maids of all work" would have a need for constant coupling to the loco pilot. So I think a working Kadee on the front of your H-10 is fine from a model railroad operational standpoint. Clipping off the trip pin is an option as long as you don't mind using an uncoupling tool when you have to uncouple the pilot from a car.
Joe
Joe Foehrkolb
- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42220
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
Robert wrote:I appreciate the coupler comments. I'm a lot more comfortable with Kadees than some of you are. They are my standard...............
Same standard here, except with most of my traction freight cars that are equipped with radial couplers that are also dummy couplers. I have made radial Kadee coupler fusions in the past and no doubt will again in the future.
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
Joe your spot on about the service Pennsy's H class saw in the waning years of steam service. My H10 will be used in way freight service. That involves poking its pilot into assorted sidings to grab a load or spot one. Thus I value my fine operating loco, and it's equally worthy Kadee coupler. If this was a roundy round engine then a more detailed dummy would be fine.
Robert
Robert
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
An observation for what it isn't worth...
So much depends on what the intent of the model is. If its for display or collection, I'm all for one of the scale couplings, and even the dummies that Max and USH used to include make sense. If it is intended to go to work on an operating model railroad, I am also in the Kadee camp. Solid, dependable, and easy to maintain. Quietly watching the discussion tells me much about the hobby aims of each person who comments, much like the headlight discussion.
Speaking of the latter, Rich's comment that an MV makes the headlight look lit frankly doesn't match my eye. It does make for an excellent look of a loco with the light off, and MVs or a nice turned aluminium insert does wonders for a collector/display loco.
If I build one to display (railroad modelling) I like scale sized or dummy couplings, fresh paint, headlight off. If it's intended for a working environment (model railroading) I like Kadees, standard wheels, a nice drive if a loco, weather, and proper lighting. Horses for courses; different purpose speaks to different presentation.
So much depends on what the intent of the model is. If its for display or collection, I'm all for one of the scale couplings, and even the dummies that Max and USH used to include make sense. If it is intended to go to work on an operating model railroad, I am also in the Kadee camp. Solid, dependable, and easy to maintain. Quietly watching the discussion tells me much about the hobby aims of each person who comments, much like the headlight discussion.
Speaking of the latter, Rich's comment that an MV makes the headlight look lit frankly doesn't match my eye. It does make for an excellent look of a loco with the light off, and MVs or a nice turned aluminium insert does wonders for a collector/display loco.
If I build one to display (railroad modelling) I like scale sized or dummy couplings, fresh paint, headlight off. If it's intended for a working environment (model railroading) I like Kadees, standard wheels, a nice drive if a loco, weather, and proper lighting. Horses for courses; different purpose speaks to different presentation.
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
Easy to sort of generalize those remarks.
Some want to make a religion out of model trains - set up conversion therapy. I take the liberal view - approach all things so as to maximize your own happiness and minimize negative impacts on others. Model trains is a very small subset of that.
Some want to make a religion out of model trains - set up conversion therapy. I take the liberal view - approach all things so as to maximize your own happiness and minimize negative impacts on others. Model trains is a very small subset of that.
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
I agree that the trip pins on the Kadees are not the most attractive, they do fill in as air hoses on older cars without the detail.
the most important thing is that the Kadees WORK. Over the years I have tried various couplers and I have found the Kadees the most reliable and consistent or operations. If you are just building models for display, then the more prototypical couplers are fine. But if you are going to operate your stuff and do switching involving coupling and uncoupling, I think Kadees cannot be beat. I have an operating layout and op-sessions involve switchlists working individual cars with coupling and uncoupling. I have a couple hundred cars, and Kadees are my standard and they work.
the most important thing is that the Kadees WORK. Over the years I have tried various couplers and I have found the Kadees the most reliable and consistent or operations. If you are just building models for display, then the more prototypical couplers are fine. But if you are going to operate your stuff and do switching involving coupling and uncoupling, I think Kadees cannot be beat. I have an operating layout and op-sessions involve switchlists working individual cars with coupling and uncoupling. I have a couple hundred cars, and Kadees are my standard and they work.
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
Those trip pins still suck! 
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
E7 wrote:Those trip pins still suck!
Rich...have you equipped your locomotive(s) with the Protocraft couplers? If so I'd like to see photos of them. I promise no wise cracks...just want to see how yours look.
Robert
-
Chris Rock
- Posts: 1480
- Joined: Fri Sep 23, 2005 6:08 pm
- Location: United States
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
Robert,
That is quite a gem. The craftmanship looks equal to your layout which is superb.
That is quite a gem. The craftmanship looks equal to your layout which is superb.
- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42220
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
I like it! Best bit I've seen here in a long time.
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
bob turner wrote:Easy to sort of generalize those remarks.
Some want to make a religion out of model trains - set up conversion therapy. I take the liberal view - approach all things so as to maximize your own happiness and minimize negative impacts on others. Model trains is a very small subset of that.
Absolutely correct. In basically all scales. Starts with the KD Witness folks, ends with the church of enemaray of dcc only.
The number of times I have seen a magazine shoot or contest in just about any scale, see that "hose" and just walk away.
Like hot rods and Chevrolet motors. Belly Button cars..everybody has one....I just turn and walk away.
There are some really well done models and trackwork that mimic the real thing so well....then it's ruined with that silly hose.
Dave....gone by invitation
Re: My CLW PRR H10-B Completed... with additional info.
Chris Rock wrote:Robert,
That is quite a gem. The craftsmanship looks equal to your layout which is superb.
Chris...your way to kind. But thank you for being so!
Rufus T. Firefly wrote:I like it! Best bit I've seen here in a long time.
Marty, I appreciate your generous words as well.
Robert
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 30 guests