.
The latest project on the workbench is the restoration of this water-damaged Hines 2-8-2 chassis:
UGH -- Look at that rust! I have been encouraged to salvage these by rotary wire brush, media blasting, and/or craytex wheel, but I am not a fan of blind drivers when not prototypical, and as such I would have to remove these anyway to replace the tires. The spokes and hubs of the wheel castings are badly rusted away in spots, which raises the question of whether it is a good idea to invest the time to refurbish and upgrade these, which would involve removing all the rust, replacing the blind tires with flanged tires (which I don't have), and then taking a cut on all the drivers to true the diameters. That is a lot of work on a damaged set. As I it, I have a set of replacements:
I have an interest in learning how to remove, replace, and quarter drivers. The original drivers are broached and thus self-quartering, but the replacements will need be quartered. The replacement drivers include new axles, which are smooth all around (no key or flat for quartering, and not knurled). I have two questions:
1. I would imagine that in theory it's OK to press out the old drivers on an arbor press, but with all the drivers on it would be tricky or tedious to get a good purchase to support the frame while pressing. So I am thinking that a puller may be in order. Does anybody have any experience with the NWSL wheel puller? Other ideas? I recall my frugal father removing the flywheel from the lawnmower engine using a puller made from a door hinge.
2. Can the NWSL quartering tool be used when installing drivers straight onto a frame? The tool looks like it was designed for models in which the drivers can be "dropped out" (by removing lower bearing caps). The Hines Mikado has a one-piece frame so the drivers have to be split for removal and installation. Joe Foehrkolb finds the NWSL tool awkward and has an interesting technique of using V-blocks and a surface gauge for quartering and then a lathe for pressing the drivers home. I recently become owner of a full-size lathe so Joe's technique is now an option. However, I am interested in hearing how others do it or what they may think of the NWSL quartering tool.
Any input in these regards will be greatly appreciated.
Jim
Removing, Replacing, and Quartering Drives
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Removing, Replacing, and Quartering Drives
The link below any photo will display the image full size
Re: Removing, Replacing, and Quartering Drives
Jim,
I found the NWSL quartering jig particularly cumbersome when trying to quarter drivers that were captured in the loco frame as most 3 rail scale mechanisms are made as is the Hines Lines Mikado mechanism.
No matter which way you decide to quarter the drivers you will still need to press the drivers back on the axles in gauge without creating wobble. My PPT presentation that I emailed to you shows the setup I use in my lathe to press the drivers on perpendicular to their axles.
This method has worked for me on many hundreds of steam loco conversions. If you machine a "cup" for your lathe chuck that the driver fits up against while doing the pressing, make sure the rim of the cup contacts the outer rim of the driver center as well as the driver tire or it is possible to push the tire off of the driver center casting in the process. Been there done that!
Good luck!
Joe
I found the NWSL quartering jig particularly cumbersome when trying to quarter drivers that were captured in the loco frame as most 3 rail scale mechanisms are made as is the Hines Lines Mikado mechanism.
No matter which way you decide to quarter the drivers you will still need to press the drivers back on the axles in gauge without creating wobble. My PPT presentation that I emailed to you shows the setup I use in my lathe to press the drivers on perpendicular to their axles.
This method has worked for me on many hundreds of steam loco conversions. If you machine a "cup" for your lathe chuck that the driver fits up against while doing the pressing, make sure the rim of the cup contacts the outer rim of the driver center as well as the driver tire or it is possible to push the tire off of the driver center casting in the process. Been there done that!
Good luck!
Joe
Joe Foehrkolb
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Removing, Replacing, and Quartering Drives
Right up my alley. Support the frame by the three drivers you are not removing, then press. Try to keep drivers and axles together. Send to me and I will bead blast for evaluation. If you bead blast, cover axles and mating holes with masking tape.
In back issues of OGR and OSN I describe my method of quartering. You need to center-drill all axles. You then press one half of the wheels, lock them at TDC or BDC, with an aluminum plate keyed to the axle centers and crankpins, in the frame.
Then the mating drivers are pressed on with aid of another aluminum plate keyed to FDC or BDC. This plate has axle and crankpin holes in a single line, whereas the plate on the bottom is drilled with crankpins at 90 degrees from the axle centers.
The pins in the axle centers can be glued in place with Pliobond, and cleaned up later with acetone.
When I am not pressing into a drilled frame, I use the lathe and two tool posts. I can get them closer than .001" doing that. My press- fits can move a bit for precise adjustments, and a drop of shaft Loctite makes them permanent.
I do follow Joe's recommendation for cups on smaller wheels and axles, but shouldered driver axles eliminate wobble when using a reasonably parallel drill press or arbor press. I apply force as close to the hub as possible.
In back issues of OGR and OSN I describe my method of quartering. You need to center-drill all axles. You then press one half of the wheels, lock them at TDC or BDC, with an aluminum plate keyed to the axle centers and crankpins, in the frame.
Then the mating drivers are pressed on with aid of another aluminum plate keyed to FDC or BDC. This plate has axle and crankpin holes in a single line, whereas the plate on the bottom is drilled with crankpins at 90 degrees from the axle centers.
The pins in the axle centers can be glued in place with Pliobond, and cleaned up later with acetone.
When I am not pressing into a drilled frame, I use the lathe and two tool posts. I can get them closer than .001" doing that. My press- fits can move a bit for precise adjustments, and a drop of shaft Loctite makes them permanent.
I do follow Joe's recommendation for cups on smaller wheels and axles, but shouldered driver axles eliminate wobble when using a reasonably parallel drill press or arbor press. I apply force as close to the hub as possible.
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Re: Removing, Replacing, and Quartering Drives
Thanks to both Joe and Bob for their responses. There is obviously a lot to learn here, but I am willing to give it a go. I will start by pressing out the old drivers, and will report back on how that goes.
Jim
Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Removing, Replacing, and Quartering Drives
Jim and I managed th re-unite some tender castings. I have no idea how many SP 160 C tender casting sets Adams cast, but with sand casting it would not be more than dozens. So the chances of parts getting separated, then found again? Remote! But I got a piece from an eBay purchase, and Jim got the rest from Joe.
As you can see, this means another set of sides, and it is time to fire up the propane torch.
As you can see, this means another set of sides, and it is time to fire up the propane torch.
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Re: Removing, Replacing, and Quartering Drivers
Glad to see those castings fit that frame you had, Bob. What are the odds that the one piece I was missing was the one piece you had?
Here is the latest report on the drivers. I set up the chassis on my small but stout arbor press last night. I followed Bob's advice about setting it up to press on the drivers. This only works on inside drivers, of course, as you have to have a support on both sides. So I started with one of the two middle drivers:
I machined an adapter piece (I will call it an "anvil" for lack of the proper name) to fit between the arbor and the axle I am pressing on. The arbor has 1/4" diameter, 1/2" deep hole in one end, which is great, as it constrains the anvil from slipping sideways during pressing operations. The anvil needed to be about 0.150" at the axle to clear the broached flat in the driver. In the old days I would have kluged something for this, but having a small lathe at hand (and a stock of various sizes of brass rod) means I could spin up the correct piece in just minutes. And sure enough, bingo, the driver pressed right out:
I slipped the bottom driver with its axle back into the chassis and to press out the other middle driver. To press the end drivers out I supported the chassis with parallel flats to the frame casting. No problems there either. By the end of the evening I had a bare chassis:
I am thinking of trying the NWSL quartering tool to insert the new drivers. I know Joe said he found it awkward in these types of installations but there is a lot of room around the chassis on this one and no gearbox sticking up. I thought about changing the gearbox to a Mod 0.6 (I have one) but the original gears appear to be in good shape and I don't plan on running this much (if only because, without a layout, I don't run anything much).
The next challenge though will be to drill a hole in the new axle for pin that constrains the drive gear to the axle. I will have to do some research on how to get that hole centered. I have a mill though so I should be able to get 'er done. A v-block may be in my future. Maybe I can mount the old axle in the v-block, align it so the drill bit or end mill is aligned with the existing hole in that old axle, replace the old axle with the new axle, and bore away. Sounds good. Other options?
Jim
Here is the latest report on the drivers. I set up the chassis on my small but stout arbor press last night. I followed Bob's advice about setting it up to press on the drivers. This only works on inside drivers, of course, as you have to have a support on both sides. So I started with one of the two middle drivers:
I machined an adapter piece (I will call it an "anvil" for lack of the proper name) to fit between the arbor and the axle I am pressing on. The arbor has 1/4" diameter, 1/2" deep hole in one end, which is great, as it constrains the anvil from slipping sideways during pressing operations. The anvil needed to be about 0.150" at the axle to clear the broached flat in the driver. In the old days I would have kluged something for this, but having a small lathe at hand (and a stock of various sizes of brass rod) means I could spin up the correct piece in just minutes. And sure enough, bingo, the driver pressed right out:
I slipped the bottom driver with its axle back into the chassis and to press out the other middle driver. To press the end drivers out I supported the chassis with parallel flats to the frame casting. No problems there either. By the end of the evening I had a bare chassis:
I am thinking of trying the NWSL quartering tool to insert the new drivers. I know Joe said he found it awkward in these types of installations but there is a lot of room around the chassis on this one and no gearbox sticking up. I thought about changing the gearbox to a Mod 0.6 (I have one) but the original gears appear to be in good shape and I don't plan on running this much (if only because, without a layout, I don't run anything much).
The next challenge though will be to drill a hole in the new axle for pin that constrains the drive gear to the axle. I will have to do some research on how to get that hole centered. I have a mill though so I should be able to get 'er done. A v-block may be in my future. Maybe I can mount the old axle in the v-block, align it so the drill bit or end mill is aligned with the existing hole in that old axle, replace the old axle with the new axle, and bore away. Sounds good. Other options?
Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Re: Removing, Replacing, and Quartering Drives
The holidays and the January train show really slowed down work on the driver replacement effort, but I am back at it now. I decided per Bob's advice to media blast the old drivers before making a decision on replacing them. They cleaned up reasonably well:
Not surprisingly, there was a good amount of corrosion damage to the wheel tread:
In a bit of good luck, the damage is far worse on the insulated drivers than on the uninsulated drivers (which I will admit is not perfectly clear in this photo):
That makes me think I might be all right as far as electrical pickup goes, especially when you add in the pilot and trailing trucks wheels to the four drivers.
So, one question: press the drivers back in and then paint, or paint (while it's easy) and then press? These pressed out pretty easily so I am thinking of painting first, protecting the hubs with some tape during pressing, and then touching up as needed. They are pre-quartered so I think pressing them will be a one-shot affair. Good plan or fool's errand?
Jim
Not surprisingly, there was a good amount of corrosion damage to the wheel tread:
In a bit of good luck, the damage is far worse on the insulated drivers than on the uninsulated drivers (which I will admit is not perfectly clear in this photo):
That makes me think I might be all right as far as electrical pickup goes, especially when you add in the pilot and trailing trucks wheels to the four drivers.
So, one question: press the drivers back in and then paint, or paint (while it's easy) and then press? These pressed out pretty easily so I am thinking of painting first, protecting the hubs with some tape during pressing, and then touching up as needed. They are pre-quartered so I think pressing them will be a one-shot affair. Good plan or fool's errand?
Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size
Re: Removing, Replacing, and Quartering Drives
More importantly, opportunity says restore the frame and paint it before pressing.
As far as the drivers, as the backs would be partially obscurred after assembly, paint them now.
Mask the axle holes, perhaps with styrene tube, and the axles themselves.
With care, the only damage to paint would be on the outside of the drivers, so an easy touchup.
As far as the drivers, as the backs would be partially obscurred after assembly, paint them now.
Mask the axle holes, perhaps with styrene tube, and the axles themselves.
With care, the only damage to paint would be on the outside of the drivers, so an easy touchup.
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 53 guests