ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
A friend recently sent me this very nice model of a 50' panel-side double-door ATSF automobile car:
The car is dated 1968. It is of unusual construction. The roof and floors are wood. The sides are wood with what looks like a very thin resin overlay. The doors and ends are cast resin. I know that Zimmer and Suncoast both offered 40' ATSF panel-side boxcars, but I am unaware of a kit like this. As far as I know, the Cooch kits were all resin, and I don't recall them offering this car. Any clues? The car is darker than it looks, but I have lightened it up in the photo to show the detail better. The car needs a little TLC but is otherwise serviceable and will provide a nice complement to all those Athearn ATSF auto cars currently on the local club's roster.
Jim
The car is dated 1968. It is of unusual construction. The roof and floors are wood. The sides are wood with what looks like a very thin resin overlay. The doors and ends are cast resin. I know that Zimmer and Suncoast both offered 40' ATSF panel-side boxcars, but I am unaware of a kit like this. As far as I know, the Cooch kits were all resin, and I don't recall them offering this car. Any clues? The car is darker than it looks, but I have lightened it up in the photo to show the detail better. The car needs a little TLC but is otherwise serviceable and will provide a nice complement to all those Athearn ATSF auto cars currently on the local club's roster.
Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
FWIW, Zimmer did a 50" also. Not saying that's what you have just correcting the record.
How about a photo of the bottom?
Jay
How about a photo of the bottom?
Jay
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
Thanks, Jay -- I did not know about the 50' Zimmer. Here is a shot of the bottom.
Nothing fancy: Athearn metal trucks, fixed couplers.
Nothing fancy: Athearn metal trucks, fixed couplers.
The link below any photo will display the image full size
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
Hot digs! I have one. Lobaugh. Photos manana.
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
Bob,
I was going to mention the Lobaugh but Jim says this model has resin doors and ends. Don't think Rollin was big on resin.
Jay
I was going to mention the Lobaugh but Jim says this model has resin doors and ends. Don't think Rollin was big on resin.
Jay
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
You guys are good -- Lobaugh did indeed make this car:
Note the rivets in the spaces between the panels, missing on my model. Other details don't quite match either, like door hardware. Here's the description:
No pressed metal on mine. Also note that if you were to have bought the car factory-built from Lobaugh it would have arrived hand-lettered. The decals were only available to the lesser rich guys that could only afford kit. That seems preposterous now but what goes around comes around. Hand-lettered was apparently prized more than decals then, and if you listed one each from the era on eBay now, the hand-lettered one would again bring a higher price. The value holds in another way too -- I would say from my limited experience that a high percentage of hand-lettered cars from that era still have lettering that looks good today, but only a low percentage of decaled cars from the same era still have the decals intact. No, I don't have data to back that up.
Jim
Note the rivets in the spaces between the panels, missing on my model. Other details don't quite match either, like door hardware. Here's the description:
No pressed metal on mine. Also note that if you were to have bought the car factory-built from Lobaugh it would have arrived hand-lettered. The decals were only available to the lesser rich guys that could only afford kit. That seems preposterous now but what goes around comes around. Hand-lettered was apparently prized more than decals then, and if you listed one each from the era on eBay now, the hand-lettered one would again bring a higher price. The value holds in another way too -- I would say from my limited experience that a high percentage of hand-lettered cars from that era still have lettering that looks good today, but only a low percentage of decaled cars from the same era still have the decals intact. No, I don't have data to back that up.
Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size
-
J. S. Bach
- Posts: 5820
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 9:30 pm
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
R.K. Maroon wrote: ...snip... I would say from my limited experience that a high percentage of hand-lettered cars from that era still have lettering that looks good today, but only a low percentage of decaled cars from the same era still have the decals intact. No, I don't have data to back that up. Jim
Paint vs decal film. Plus, the shellac (or whatever) that was sometimes applied to "seal" the decal has degenerated over the years.
- Erik C Lindgren
- Posts: 1307
- Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2010 11:37 pm
- Contact:
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
The markings are absolutely identical to the DSMR marked cars I’ve had many encounters with over the last 15 years. It looks like either Calahan’s (50’s later into 80’s) hand writing or maybe even Kennedy (wayback to 1940’s). They used to mark them on each inspection that included “lub” or “gaged”... 6/68, 4/54, 3/39 etc. Lovey specimen man!! If in fact it’s an ex-Denver Society car that’s a neat bunch of history dating to the 1930’s.
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
Here is mine - genuine Lobaugh with stamped brass doors and ends. A nice model. Cannot find the matching ice car.
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
Interesting. The prototype doesn't have rivets down the center of the channel separating the panels. Somebody's imagination or just artistic license?
Jay
Jay
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
1936 Model Craftsman had plans and instructions on building this car (the 50 footer). Same copy had the ad from Lobaugh showing their kit.
Here are photos of a A-N (Zimmer actually) and a Suncoast version of the 40' cars. A-N made them way too tall and used the wrong ends but, hey, that's what was available.







Jay
Here are photos of a A-N (Zimmer actually) and a Suncoast version of the 40' cars. A-N made them way too tall and used the wrong ends but, hey, that's what was available.







Jay
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
Thanks for posting the photos, Jay. I was aware of both versions but don't know enough about the prototypes to know that the A-N car was not correctly proportioned. It is tall, though -- that's for sure:

I believe I have one of the Suncoast models, but I also have one or two scratchbuilt versions -- I will dig them out and post photos as I can.
Jim

I believe I have one of the Suncoast models, but I also have one or two scratchbuilt versions -- I will dig them out and post photos as I can.
Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
I stumbled onto this photo hiding in my files today:
I think I have the actual model too. With luck I will stumble on that as well.
I think I have the actual model too. With luck I will stumble on that as well.
The link below any photo will display the image full size
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
Jim
They are nice kits; I've done several over the years. At one time if memory serves, Woody Grosdof owned Suncoast and made those kits, still available in the 90s. They came in two versions, one as built with K-brakes and the earlier reporting mark on the decals and a modernised version without the periods on the reporting mark and different brakegear.
Jay, a question for you. Were there not several different classes of panelside boxcar? I seem to remember (wrongly probably, since my memory has been pretty faulty lately) there was a car done by ATSF to either the '32 or '37 AAR design but with panel sides rather than steel (perhaps even wartime?) much in the same manner GN did with their own style of wooden cladding, and the Zimmer was at least close as a 10' 6" IH version. I could easily be 'way wrong, but I did run a Zimmer on my old layout for years under those (suspect) premises, one that Ted Stepek originally built.
They are nice kits; I've done several over the years. At one time if memory serves, Woody Grosdof owned Suncoast and made those kits, still available in the 90s. They came in two versions, one as built with K-brakes and the earlier reporting mark on the decals and a modernised version without the periods on the reporting mark and different brakegear.
Jay, a question for you. Were there not several different classes of panelside boxcar? I seem to remember (wrongly probably, since my memory has been pretty faulty lately) there was a car done by ATSF to either the '32 or '37 AAR design but with panel sides rather than steel (perhaps even wartime?) much in the same manner GN did with their own style of wooden cladding, and the Zimmer was at least close as a 10' 6" IH version. I could easily be 'way wrong, but I did run a Zimmer on my old layout for years under those (suspect) premises, one that Ted Stepek originally built.
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: ATSF Panel-Side Automobile Boxcar
Sarge,
I have a book here somewhere that provides most, if not all, of the data. Truthfully, I don't recall the specifics.
Yeah, I have a bunch of the Sun Coast kits. Some started, some still in kit form. Four or five Zimmers too. A couple of those were started but need to be taken back apart because some of the pieces were installed poorly. Maybe some ambitious soul will take up the challenge.....I don't seem to have the time.
Jay
I have a book here somewhere that provides most, if not all, of the data. Truthfully, I don't recall the specifics.
Yeah, I have a bunch of the Sun Coast kits. Some started, some still in kit form. Four or five Zimmers too. A couple of those were started but need to be taken back apart because some of the pieces were installed poorly. Maybe some ambitious soul will take up the challenge.....I don't seem to have the time.
Jay
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 44 guests