Another interesting item...........
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Another interesting item...........
John,
Adding what many think are barriers in order to sabotage success is also irrelevant.
The springs add no major roadblocks and I already have the rods.
The original Walther's drive was pretty much a piece of crap but my intention is show it can be done using today's parts.
I've spent the last thirty years doing things "experts" say can't be done.
Jay
Adding what many think are barriers in order to sabotage success is also irrelevant.
The springs add no major roadblocks and I already have the rods.
The original Walther's drive was pretty much a piece of crap but my intention is show it can be done using today's parts.
I've spent the last thirty years doing things "experts" say can't be done.
Jay
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Another interesting item...........
This would be the beginning.
One more point (of probably many), if I'm going to do this I don't plan on building an entire model, just a mechanism.
Gear boxes still need final machining and the frame will need slight modification to clear input output shafts.
Jay
One more point (of probably many), if I'm going to do this I don't plan on building an entire model, just a mechanism.
Gear boxes still need final machining and the frame will need slight modification to clear input output shafts.
Jay
- Attachments
-
- 2017-12-17 004.JPG (1.25 MiB) Viewed 6269 times
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Another interesting item...........
Nice looking frame. What size drivers?
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Another interesting item...........
Bob,
SP MK-4 had 57" drivers.
Jay
SP MK-4 had 57" drivers.
Jay
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: Another interesting item...........
Jay Criswell wrote:John,
Adding what many think are barriers in order to sabotage success is also irrelevant.
The springs add no major roadblocks and I already have the rods.
The original Walther's drive was pretty much a piece of crap but my intention is show it can be done using today's parts.
I've spent the last thirty years doing things "experts" say can't be done.
Jay
Maybe it's just when I read your original entries on this subject it seemed to me prety clear you were defending the Walthers Polydrive.
Evey other poster seems to indicate the original Polydrive was garbage.
Yes, you can do a good job with modern parts and good machining.
I don't see anybody picking on you.
First post sent us to some hairball diseasemal switcher, then Rufus sent us to Polydrive in second post.
"The original Walther's drive was pretty much a piece of crap but my intention is show it can be done using today's parts."
Must be I missed that in the first two pages on this thread.
"Some feel these drives would/will never operate well but I think it could be done. The secret would be better drive components and getting the drivers lined up properly (like the timing of a DOHC engine)."
Now that is confusing. Most folks throughout history probably feel that way, if the number I have discussed this with over the past 50 years is any indicator, that the original will never operate well.
This is getting to be George Washington's Axe.
Shows up on evilbait....head has been changed twice, handle three times, but it is still George Washington's axe.
Exactly how much original Walthers Polydrive is in that chassis again?
Dave....gone by invitation
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Another interesting item...........
Dave,
I'll try to make it simple for you. I'm not defending, promoting, or in any way trying to make the Polydrive more than it ever was. I'm trying to defend the concept.
If my articulation is lacking, sorry about that.
Jay
I'll try to make it simple for you. I'm not defending, promoting, or in any way trying to make the Polydrive more than it ever was. I'm trying to defend the concept.
If my articulation is lacking, sorry about that.
Jay
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Another interesting item...........
No, I think Jay's experiment is noble. I have no doubt that his gear reduction will work smoother and slower than my NWSL/Pittman, which would be my entry. And my fifty bucks would be more of a contribution than a bet.
A more equal contest might be just one Jay C gearbox in the same frame with all the rest of the components identical. But that is putting the entire onus on Jay. I will prepare a 62" drivered frame/motor for the contest. It is most likely an unfair contest, because we are not using Jay's gears. Nevertheless, fifty bucks. If you bet with me, be prepared to lose. NWSL is a good product, but it is a lot like comparing Sunset to MMW.
Also do appreciate the coupling and torque considerations Jay will have to engineer his way through. They may be irrelevant to him, but they would give me serious heartburn. The only way I see is individual traction masters. If unsprung, you just attach the boxes to the frame.
Cost, complexity, and appearance may be irrelevant to Jay, and we can allow him to make the rules on this, but none of these are irrelevant to a commercial endeavor. Jay may have won the contest before it starts, but I would indeed bet a grand that this never becomes commercially viable, defined by 200 delivered eight-coupled steam models.
A more equal contest might be just one Jay C gearbox in the same frame with all the rest of the components identical. But that is putting the entire onus on Jay. I will prepare a 62" drivered frame/motor for the contest. It is most likely an unfair contest, because we are not using Jay's gears. Nevertheless, fifty bucks. If you bet with me, be prepared to lose. NWSL is a good product, but it is a lot like comparing Sunset to MMW.
Also do appreciate the coupling and torque considerations Jay will have to engineer his way through. They may be irrelevant to him, but they would give me serious heartburn. The only way I see is individual traction masters. If unsprung, you just attach the boxes to the frame.
Cost, complexity, and appearance may be irrelevant to Jay, and we can allow him to make the rules on this, but none of these are irrelevant to a commercial endeavor. Jay may have won the contest before it starts, but I would indeed bet a grand that this never becomes commercially viable, defined by 200 delivered eight-coupled steam models.
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Another interesting item...........
Bob,
Agreed, unless we could cut the cost of the gear boxes considerably it would never be a viable commercial offering. I don't believe I ever said it would. I thought about using NWSL gearboxes but the dimensions don't allow for it (too long). We could always use OMI diesel gear boxes but, other than the 3 or 4 dozen in my possession, they're not readily available.
To me, the biggest issue isn't the drivers, frame, gear box, etc., it's the timing. Maybe that's not a good way to describe what I'm getting at. The bottom line, all the drivers have to be in sync. and sure quartered but the quartering can be off a degree, or two, maybe three. As long as the drivers and rods don't bind.
Please keep in mind, I'm in the middle of trying to ressurect Right-O'-Way along with folding some of Protocraft, American Switch & Signal, Red Cliffs Miniatures, the old Chooch Brass truck kits, the majority of the old Clouser castings and I can't remember what else, into ROW. Also building 8 to 10 drives for others so this little experiment will be a "work on it when I can" project.
Jay
Agreed, unless we could cut the cost of the gear boxes considerably it would never be a viable commercial offering. I don't believe I ever said it would. I thought about using NWSL gearboxes but the dimensions don't allow for it (too long). We could always use OMI diesel gear boxes but, other than the 3 or 4 dozen in my possession, they're not readily available.
To me, the biggest issue isn't the drivers, frame, gear box, etc., it's the timing. Maybe that's not a good way to describe what I'm getting at. The bottom line, all the drivers have to be in sync. and sure quartered but the quartering can be off a degree, or two, maybe three. As long as the drivers and rods don't bind.
Please keep in mind, I'm in the middle of trying to ressurect Right-O'-Way along with folding some of Protocraft, American Switch & Signal, Red Cliffs Miniatures, the old Chooch Brass truck kits, the majority of the old Clouser castings and I can't remember what else, into ROW. Also building 8 to 10 drives for others so this little experiment will be a "work on it when I can" project.
Jay
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Another interesting item...........
Quartering and indexing should not be difficult so long as you have zero lash in your gearboxes. A set- screw arrangement will let you quarter all four drivers before slipping the rods on.
I would assume you will quarter each driver individually to within .001 at the crankpin, just like normal. They do not have to be 90 degrees; just matched.
This is of interest to the rest of us just because you are interested. Nobody would actually want something like this on a model. So, no time limit. At least not from me.
I would assume you will quarter each driver individually to within .001 at the crankpin, just like normal. They do not have to be 90 degrees; just matched.
This is of interest to the rest of us just because you are interested. Nobody would actually want something like this on a model. So, no time limit. At least not from me.
- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42226
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: Another interesting item...........
bob turner wrote: Nobody would actually want something like this on a model.
Don't know about that -- take it over to OGR and declare it to be the best O scale model of all time and you'd probably get a line of folks screaming "Take my money!"
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: Another interesting item...........
Yeah...I think it is noble. I think with proper modern technology it will work.
My issues are several, and not at all with regards to Jay's endeavor.
What I gleaned over the decades on Polydrive..and then much, much more recent.
In another scale, another gauge...there was (past tense) this outfit that decided to build a new power block.
All wheel drive.
Started with SD-45's....trucks released first..and we saw a problem right away.
Tapered axles, coned drivers, screw holding them tight...no keys.
Morons who had them argued, so I challenged them to put the loco on the track, put a Sharpie mark at the dead bottom of each of the 12 drivers, couple on a train and run it for 15-20 minutes and tell me if they could see the marks on the drivers of each individual truck aligning. And they could not...but "not a problem", right?
Next, they moved into steam. 4-6-2, modified later into another loco at 2-8-2, then expanded that to 2-8-8-2...and you see where I am going....the drivers crept or literally spun on the axles, and snapped siderod or hopefully low speed and just locked up.
To maintain gearboxes, the drivers had to come off to access the horizontal screws holding the gearbox together. The "Factory Fix" was to mix LockTite with Super Glue and bond the drivers to the axles.
Then you could not maintain the gearboxes.
Early units had six sided knobs on the worm shafts that spun.
Later, metal pressed on.
The concept was laudable, in that you did not have to be 100% certain the gears all were aligned to have the drivers in quarter when it was all together.
Add to that the PRC worker bees...one worker running the taper on the axle ends (and the axles were "thumbtacks" with a big flat round plate on one end with three holes to screw them to the very wide wormgear...since the axles were designed to move side to side) and another coring the cone into the drivers...and they had zero QC...so the axle ends sometimes stuck through the wheel..and no amount of washers would allow you to tighten to jam the wheel on the axle.
Always the problem.....if you set up the gears, press the drivers on, quartered, you can be certain any disassembly of the gearboxes will cause you heartburn to get everything lined up exactly right.
Oh...and they tried to patent their all-wheel-drive steam boxes....until somebody (guess who) mentioned...Polydrive.
They did end up patenting them, but it was a "cosmetic" patent, not on the design at all.
The diseasmals used small cans on the wormshafts between each gearbox..the steam put a motor at the end.
Since the company folded several years ago, there are a whole bunch of folks with mantlepieces that they can't get parts for.
Several various "attempts" over the decades to get all wheel drive on steam, it seems.
Yours looks like it will work if for no other reason that you A) think, B) plan, and C) no bean counters nipping at your heels to ship production to PRC.
Oh...gauge. Back-to-back is 1.575" (G1MRA) and the half axles...and the PRC non-QC workers on the taper machines.....the gauge was ALWAYS narrow, often VERY narrow....and on a six wheel diseasemal brick took 2.5 HOURS each truck to measure, fully disassemble, cut round shims, drill for screws, assemble and re-check (if you've ever done valve adjustment on an XK Jag you know it is never done the first try).
Getting the Super Glue/LockTite drivers off was a trip.
One of the neat things about all-wheel-drive steam is you do not have to be "quartered. You can even be 180 to help high speed balance. They still have to match, but not quartered.
My issues are several, and not at all with regards to Jay's endeavor.
What I gleaned over the decades on Polydrive..and then much, much more recent.
In another scale, another gauge...there was (past tense) this outfit that decided to build a new power block.
All wheel drive.
Started with SD-45's....trucks released first..and we saw a problem right away.
Tapered axles, coned drivers, screw holding them tight...no keys.
Morons who had them argued, so I challenged them to put the loco on the track, put a Sharpie mark at the dead bottom of each of the 12 drivers, couple on a train and run it for 15-20 minutes and tell me if they could see the marks on the drivers of each individual truck aligning. And they could not...but "not a problem", right?
Next, they moved into steam. 4-6-2, modified later into another loco at 2-8-2, then expanded that to 2-8-8-2...and you see where I am going....the drivers crept or literally spun on the axles, and snapped siderod or hopefully low speed and just locked up.
To maintain gearboxes, the drivers had to come off to access the horizontal screws holding the gearbox together. The "Factory Fix" was to mix LockTite with Super Glue and bond the drivers to the axles.
Then you could not maintain the gearboxes.
Early units had six sided knobs on the worm shafts that spun.
Later, metal pressed on.
The concept was laudable, in that you did not have to be 100% certain the gears all were aligned to have the drivers in quarter when it was all together.
Add to that the PRC worker bees...one worker running the taper on the axle ends (and the axles were "thumbtacks" with a big flat round plate on one end with three holes to screw them to the very wide wormgear...since the axles were designed to move side to side) and another coring the cone into the drivers...and they had zero QC...so the axle ends sometimes stuck through the wheel..and no amount of washers would allow you to tighten to jam the wheel on the axle.
Always the problem.....if you set up the gears, press the drivers on, quartered, you can be certain any disassembly of the gearboxes will cause you heartburn to get everything lined up exactly right.
Oh...and they tried to patent their all-wheel-drive steam boxes....until somebody (guess who) mentioned...Polydrive.
They did end up patenting them, but it was a "cosmetic" patent, not on the design at all.
The diseasmals used small cans on the wormshafts between each gearbox..the steam put a motor at the end.
Since the company folded several years ago, there are a whole bunch of folks with mantlepieces that they can't get parts for.
Several various "attempts" over the decades to get all wheel drive on steam, it seems.
Yours looks like it will work if for no other reason that you A) think, B) plan, and C) no bean counters nipping at your heels to ship production to PRC.
Oh...gauge. Back-to-back is 1.575" (G1MRA) and the half axles...and the PRC non-QC workers on the taper machines.....the gauge was ALWAYS narrow, often VERY narrow....and on a six wheel diseasemal brick took 2.5 HOURS each truck to measure, fully disassemble, cut round shims, drill for screws, assemble and re-check (if you've ever done valve adjustment on an XK Jag you know it is never done the first try).
Getting the Super Glue/LockTite drivers off was a trip.
One of the neat things about all-wheel-drive steam is you do not have to be "quartered. You can even be 180 to help high speed balance. They still have to match, but not quartered.
Dave....gone by invitation
-
herronpeter
- Posts: 748
- Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2014 9:13 pm
- Location: Clifton Park, NY
Re: Another interesting item...........
I still want to know more about that goofball switcher!! Jeez................
Peter
Peter
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Another interesting item...........
Peter,
How about this, the switcher is a piece-o-cra*
Okay, I'm going to edit this to say, your piece-o-cra* is nicer than mine. There is that better?
Jay
How about this, the switcher is a piece-o-cra*
Okay, I'm going to edit this to say, your piece-o-cra* is nicer than mine. There is that better?
Jay
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: Another interesting item...........
Jay Criswell wrote:Peter,
How about this, the switcher is a piece-o-cra*![]()
Okay, I'm going to edit this to say, your piece-o-cra* is nicer than mine. There is that better?
Jay
What I can't believe is the switcher went for 105 plus shipping.
And the Walther chassis went for 51.
If you look close...the Walthers chassis had some real problems. Two (at least) crankpins gone, valve gear hanging out of the cylinders, and the siderod with missing crankpins bent to hades.
Rode hard and put away wet.
Dave....gone by invitation
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Another interesting item...........
So let's take a poll: Assuming Jay's nice gearbox and dropdown, and his favorire Faulhaber, and also assuming only $100 more for his version of Polydrive, and assuming it runs better than a Sunset mike by a bunch, and finally assuming you cannot discern much difference performance- wise between four "Jay" gearboxes and only one, how many would opt for modern bulletproof polydrive?
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 41 guests