Lost wax brass casting questions
- big bad jim
- Posts: 446
- Joined: Wed Oct 06, 2010 1:38 pm
Lost wax brass casting questions
I'm trying to wrap up preparations to have my EMD Flexicoil switcher truck sideframes cast. I'm trying to figure out the best way to approach the smaller details like the brake cylinders and rigging. I'm fairly comfortable with the big chunks, like the sideframe itself.
I'm currently planning on having parts cast via direct burnout, with no current plans for molds or "mass" production. So I'm not as concerned with undercuts or de-molding like I would be if I was casting multiple iterations in molds. The other caveat is that I'm not attempting to spring these trucks. The intent is that this sideframe will attach to the existing Atlas gearbox, in the same manner as their sw8/9 locos. So with that in mind, I have a couple of questions.
1) What is the general opinion on the percentage of shrink for direct burnout? I know it isn't anything like for molds. Is it even something I need to adjust for? The journals will be cast as part of the sideframes, and will not bear axle ends, so center to center doesn't have to be dead nuts. But it should be close.
2) If I'm planning for direct burnout, is it feasible to include some of the parts, that might otherwise be separately applied, all in the same casting? All the journal detail is already planned to be cast with the frames, so I'm talking primarily about the cylinder, it's piston, and the lever that connects to the piston and passes through the sideframe. All the rest of the brake rigging is currently intended to be a separate part that attaches with a tab and slot to the side of the bolster and a pin to the ear at the end of the sideframe. One way or another the brake rigging has to be isolated at the brake shoes and the slack adjusters.
I know that I could do everything separately, but I can cut down on the cost of printing the masters if I can consolidate things and print fewer pieces. There are per piece charges and the cost of machine space would be significantly reduced as well.
Thanks,
Jim
I'm currently planning on having parts cast via direct burnout, with no current plans for molds or "mass" production. So I'm not as concerned with undercuts or de-molding like I would be if I was casting multiple iterations in molds. The other caveat is that I'm not attempting to spring these trucks. The intent is that this sideframe will attach to the existing Atlas gearbox, in the same manner as their sw8/9 locos. So with that in mind, I have a couple of questions.
1) What is the general opinion on the percentage of shrink for direct burnout? I know it isn't anything like for molds. Is it even something I need to adjust for? The journals will be cast as part of the sideframes, and will not bear axle ends, so center to center doesn't have to be dead nuts. But it should be close.
2) If I'm planning for direct burnout, is it feasible to include some of the parts, that might otherwise be separately applied, all in the same casting? All the journal detail is already planned to be cast with the frames, so I'm talking primarily about the cylinder, it's piston, and the lever that connects to the piston and passes through the sideframe. All the rest of the brake rigging is currently intended to be a separate part that attaches with a tab and slot to the side of the bolster and a pin to the ear at the end of the sideframe. One way or another the brake rigging has to be isolated at the brake shoes and the slack adjusters.
I know that I could do everything separately, but I can cut down on the cost of printing the masters if I can consolidate things and print fewer pieces. There are per piece charges and the cost of machine space would be significantly reduced as well.
Thanks,
Jim
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
Jim,
You know how to contact me.
Jay
You know how to contact me.
Jay
- big bad jim
- Posts: 446
- Joined: Wed Oct 06, 2010 1:38 pm
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
Yeah...sometimes I feel like I'm bugging you with this stuff...tugging on your sleeve. This way I can feel like I'm bugging everybody!
Plus I know you've got a lot of irons in the fire lately. I'll send you an email.
Jim
Plus I know you've got a lot of irons in the fire lately. I'll send you an email.
Jim
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
Jim,
I'd help you get it right. Not bringing in people like Terry and David might prove to be regrettable. Besides, I always try to make room for my friends. When that stops, the fun is over.
Jay
I'd help you get it right. Not bringing in people like Terry and David might prove to be regrettable. Besides, I always try to make room for my friends. When that stops, the fun is over.
Jay
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
How does 1/2 of 1% shrinkage sound? And if it was me, my master would be as detailed as possible, so all I would have to do is bolt it on.
- big bad jim
- Posts: 446
- Joined: Wed Oct 06, 2010 1:38 pm
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
Bob,
A half percent doesn't sound like something that I'm going to worry about. For a 2" wheelbase, that would be .010". My understanding was that shrink with direct burnout was negligible, which your figure confirms.
I would cast everything together if it was feasible. It would add strength to the smaller parts to have them supported at both ends, and obviously it would be simpler to assemble the trucks. I'm not worrying about undercuts and de-molding, so my main concern as I see it is making sure I can clean out all the plaster from the mold.
The end beams will be separate because it's the only way to be able to slide the sideframes over the tabs on the gear box cover. Plus I can make longer ones for Ow5 if anybody wants a set that way. And lastly some photos show that the beams have been torched off somewhere along the way.
So the trucks could be modeled that way if desired. The back of the sideframe where the bolster terminates is a separate piece so that I can get hollow cavities and depth like the prototype and an actual wall thickness for the various openings. This should also facilitate casting from molds if I ever have reason to do so.
My chief concern is about electrical isolation with the brake shoes and the slack adjusters, as I've modeled the shoes much closer to the wheels, and I want slack adjuster bars on both front and back of the wheels. There is some side to side play in the wheelsets, although it is a pretty small amount. And springy pickup wipers will tend to keep the wheelsets centered. I can cast everything together, and insulate the shoes and bars with kapton tape or tissue paper laminated with CA. I can cast everything except the shoes and bars, and use miniature bolts from Scale Hardware to attach resin or styrene parts. I can get hex head threaded bolts, washers, and nuts down to .5mm across flats, which is about 15/16" in O scale. I need 1-5/16" to 1-1/2" bolts, which are available. I can 3d print the brake parts in whole and use that instead of the same parts cast in brass. The key with that method is the quality of the print coupled with any sort of durability for delicate parts. Remember my comment over on OGR about structurally usable 3d prints for sideframes? Many high-res plastics are quite brittle, and I think even minor mishandling would break some of these parts. I'm going to check into printing the brake parts via a Carbon CLIP printer, as they are supposed to produce exceptional resolution but also superior mechanical characteristics in all three axes. I need to get a quote though because the machines and raw material are expensive, so I would expect some added expense for the parts. I'm hoping that the price will be limited because the parts are so small.
Anyhoo, I'll run everything past Jay and Terry and Dave, get things sorted and adjusted, and get something cast. I'd like to have something to show by the March meet in Chicago, whether anyone else actually sees it or not. It's a sort of artificial deadline I'm using to motivate myself to forward progress. Plus once I finish the trucks I can get back to working on the other parts of the model.
Jim
A half percent doesn't sound like something that I'm going to worry about. For a 2" wheelbase, that would be .010". My understanding was that shrink with direct burnout was negligible, which your figure confirms.
I would cast everything together if it was feasible. It would add strength to the smaller parts to have them supported at both ends, and obviously it would be simpler to assemble the trucks. I'm not worrying about undercuts and de-molding, so my main concern as I see it is making sure I can clean out all the plaster from the mold.
The end beams will be separate because it's the only way to be able to slide the sideframes over the tabs on the gear box cover. Plus I can make longer ones for Ow5 if anybody wants a set that way. And lastly some photos show that the beams have been torched off somewhere along the way.
So the trucks could be modeled that way if desired. The back of the sideframe where the bolster terminates is a separate piece so that I can get hollow cavities and depth like the prototype and an actual wall thickness for the various openings. This should also facilitate casting from molds if I ever have reason to do so.
My chief concern is about electrical isolation with the brake shoes and the slack adjusters, as I've modeled the shoes much closer to the wheels, and I want slack adjuster bars on both front and back of the wheels. There is some side to side play in the wheelsets, although it is a pretty small amount. And springy pickup wipers will tend to keep the wheelsets centered. I can cast everything together, and insulate the shoes and bars with kapton tape or tissue paper laminated with CA. I can cast everything except the shoes and bars, and use miniature bolts from Scale Hardware to attach resin or styrene parts. I can get hex head threaded bolts, washers, and nuts down to .5mm across flats, which is about 15/16" in O scale. I need 1-5/16" to 1-1/2" bolts, which are available. I can 3d print the brake parts in whole and use that instead of the same parts cast in brass. The key with that method is the quality of the print coupled with any sort of durability for delicate parts. Remember my comment over on OGR about structurally usable 3d prints for sideframes? Many high-res plastics are quite brittle, and I think even minor mishandling would break some of these parts. I'm going to check into printing the brake parts via a Carbon CLIP printer, as they are supposed to produce exceptional resolution but also superior mechanical characteristics in all three axes. I need to get a quote though because the machines and raw material are expensive, so I would expect some added expense for the parts. I'm hoping that the price will be limited because the parts are so small.
Anyhoo, I'll run everything past Jay and Terry and Dave, get things sorted and adjusted, and get something cast. I'd like to have something to show by the March meet in Chicago, whether anyone else actually sees it or not. It's a sort of artificial deadline I'm using to motivate myself to forward progress. Plus once I finish the trucks I can get back to working on the other parts of the model.
Jim
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
Jim,
The shrinkage isn't linear but it's close enough for our purposes.
Adding as much of the detail, prior to casting, is one of the biggest advantages to direct burnout casting. One of the critical items to think about is final assembly. Just think it through. The cool thing here is, you're smart enough to visualize what your doing and how you want the end product to work.
There are many other issues to deal with but you'll get there. As an example, trapping air. When placing the parts in the investment (think Plaster of Paris for us laymen) if it's positioned in such a way as to create an air pocket said air pocket will become part of the casting. I'm sure everyone has seen little round nodules on the surface of lost wax castings. These are nothing more than air bubbles that didn't float off.
As far as attaching the small details, simple AC/CA will work just fine.....it burns out without expanding.
Oh yeah, I still prefer printing in wax. Terry can offer the best advice on this subject.
Jay
The shrinkage isn't linear but it's close enough for our purposes.
Adding as much of the detail, prior to casting, is one of the biggest advantages to direct burnout casting. One of the critical items to think about is final assembly. Just think it through. The cool thing here is, you're smart enough to visualize what your doing and how you want the end product to work.
There are many other issues to deal with but you'll get there. As an example, trapping air. When placing the parts in the investment (think Plaster of Paris for us laymen) if it's positioned in such a way as to create an air pocket said air pocket will become part of the casting. I'm sure everyone has seen little round nodules on the surface of lost wax castings. These are nothing more than air bubbles that didn't float off.
As far as attaching the small details, simple AC/CA will work just fine.....it burns out without expanding.
Oh yeah, I still prefer printing in wax. Terry can offer the best advice on this subject.
Jay
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
A very satisfying endeavor.
You might consider electrically isolating the sideframes. A plastic bolster, or a gasket and plastic screw would do it.
Brake shoes can and do short out on even the high end models. And they can be almost impossible to find/fix. You are wise to worry.
I have done sideframes, domes, and side rods, both as metal masters and as one shot burnouts. I was lousy at it at first, but got better. My side rods are as good as CLW, and fully clevised. Stevenson has them. You have seen my PA truck. A first attempt, and while not great, it gives me satisfaction.
You might consider electrically isolating the sideframes. A plastic bolster, or a gasket and plastic screw would do it.
Brake shoes can and do short out on even the high end models. And they can be almost impossible to find/fix. You are wise to worry.
I have done sideframes, domes, and side rods, both as metal masters and as one shot burnouts. I was lousy at it at first, but got better. My side rods are as good as CLW, and fully clevised. Stevenson has them. You have seen my PA truck. A first attempt, and while not great, it gives me satisfaction.
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
Jim,
Far more crude than what you're doing but I thought I'd ask, ever see these before?
Jay
Far more crude than what you're doing but I thought I'd ask, ever see these before?
Jay
- big bad jim
- Posts: 446
- Joined: Wed Oct 06, 2010 1:38 pm
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
Jay,
I knew Keil Line had made Flexicoil sideframes, but I'd never seen the kit up close. I presume Scale City has them now? Either way, based on your photos, I'll stick with mine. The Keil Line aren't bad, but I can spot a few little things that aren't quite right. Hopefully I can get a good rendition in brass.
I've made a few final tweaks in the engineering since the other day. I'll have an email on the way to you in the next day or two. Thanks again for the help.
Jim
I knew Keil Line had made Flexicoil sideframes, but I'd never seen the kit up close. I presume Scale City has them now? Either way, based on your photos, I'll stick with mine. The Keil Line aren't bad, but I can spot a few little things that aren't quite right. Hopefully I can get a good rendition in brass.
I've made a few final tweaks in the engineering since the other day. I'll have an email on the way to you in the next day or two. Thanks again for the help.
Jim
- big bad jim
- Posts: 446
- Joined: Wed Oct 06, 2010 1:38 pm
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
Bob,
These sideframes will be attached to a stock Atlas diecast gearbox from their sw8/9 switcher. Specifcally screwed to the brass p48 gearbox cover, so there won't be an opportunity to isolate the sideframes with a plastic bolster. That's why I was considering the brake rigging in plastic. I'm now leaning toward just casting everything in brass, brakes included, if the pros say it's feasible. I'll test fit everything, check everything against the side play in the wheelsets, and make adjustments as necessary.
Jim
These sideframes will be attached to a stock Atlas diecast gearbox from their sw8/9 switcher. Specifcally screwed to the brass p48 gearbox cover, so there won't be an opportunity to isolate the sideframes with a plastic bolster. That's why I was considering the brake rigging in plastic. I'm now leaning toward just casting everything in brass, brakes included, if the pros say it's feasible. I'll test fit everything, check everything against the side play in the wheelsets, and make adjustments as necessary.
Jim
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
Consider gluing Mylar on the brake shoe face. The normal approach is to keep them way far away from the wheels. Ask Wasatch how much trouble truly accurate trucks can give a 2-railer.
I actually can't wait to see your results. This has the potential to revolutionize the scratch building hobby.
I actually can't wait to see your results. This has the potential to revolutionize the scratch building hobby.
- big bad jim
- Posts: 446
- Joined: Wed Oct 06, 2010 1:38 pm
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
Lol, I can't wait to see the results either. The project has certainly been in the works for long enough. As far as revolutions go, this sort of thing has been going on for a while now. I'm by no means the first person to utilize this process. I bring a cad skill set and a compulsive streak to the proceedings, The real revolution is the 3d printing. Without that capability to output the 3d cad model, this stuff can't get done with the ease and precision to make it worth while.
If I continue on the path of casting the brakes in brass and insulating afterward, I have several options. I will consider Kapton tape, presuming it will take paint. They have a 1 mil (.001") thick version available in various widths. It includes adhesive. The Brits on Western Thunder have suggested tissue paper lamented to parts by saturating with CA. I will consider stuff like the mylar, presuming it is thin enough, will take paint, and will adhere and stay adhered to the brass parts. Thanks for the suggestion.
Would fish paper work in a situation like this, having to adhere it to parts as opposed to trapping it between driver centers and tires?
Jim
If I continue on the path of casting the brakes in brass and insulating afterward, I have several options. I will consider Kapton tape, presuming it will take paint. They have a 1 mil (.001") thick version available in various widths. It includes adhesive. The Brits on Western Thunder have suggested tissue paper lamented to parts by saturating with CA. I will consider stuff like the mylar, presuming it is thin enough, will take paint, and will adhere and stay adhered to the brass parts. Thanks for the suggestion.
Would fish paper work in a situation like this, having to adhere it to parts as opposed to trapping it between driver centers and tires?
Jim
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
Jim,
I wouldn't overthink it. It works on the stock SW just fine and it does on the P:48 conversion also. Diesels are a lot easier than steam.
Jay
I wouldn't overthink it. It works on the stock SW just fine and it does on the P:48 conversion also. Diesels are a lot easier than steam.
Jay
Re: Lost wax brass casting questions
Just installed a pair of Jay's P-48 conversion retainer plates for the Atlas SW-9 trucks and NWSL P-48 wheelsets. What a great conversion. Jay's castings are dead on, so the alignment pins on the stock Atlas side frames align perfectly before you screw it together. Moving the side frames in just that little bit is an incredible visual improvement.
Nice job Jay!
BH
Nice job Jay!
BH
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 60 guests