First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Discuss All Facets of 2-Rail, 1/48 Scale, Model Railroading
User avatar
Tramp
Posts: 4735
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2004 1:21 pm
Location: Down East
Contact:

First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby Tramp » Sat Feb 10, 2018 2:21 pm

Lee Turner was my verbal and e-mail guide on this. Without him, it would look even worse. Thoughts?

Figures are by my pal High-rail-low-rail-7-rail Jon.



Image



Image



Image
That a life will be spent gaining inches,
When this distance is read in miles.

User avatar
2railjon
Posts: 15906
Joined: Fri Apr 02, 2004 2:33 pm

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby 2railjon » Sat Feb 10, 2018 3:28 pm

Looks damn good on that J3a!
Running that red block Charlie.

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby ScaleCraft » Sat Feb 10, 2018 6:47 pm

So....not being too familiar with that version of NYC Hudson...what is the link hanging down just aft of the red handled valve?
Dave....gone by invitation

bob turner
Posts: 13675
Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby bob turner » Sat Feb 10, 2018 7:32 pm

Baker revers lever.

I think you did pretty good. Not sure I am wild about the block lettering, but I am sure it is prototypical.

I think you could make it even better with some very light chalk and a sable brush. Washout plugs and other boiler fittings often have dribble, which can be simulated with a white streak - even a hint of orange or brown for rust. And lettering often washes down in the rain, leaving faint white streaks.

But it is great as-is!

User avatar
De Bruin
Posts: 991
Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2017 8:24 pm

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby De Bruin » Sat Feb 10, 2018 9:39 pm

Can I send you some more large steam models like your J here, so you can weather it accordingly?
Very Nice, thanks for posting it.
Pete
Political Consultant- Tap into the hidden powers of your public office, insure your future is jail free, well funded. Visit shock and awe upon your adversaries, dominate the media, thrill your followers. contact morbo@happydaysrhereagain.com

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby sarge » Sun Feb 11, 2018 12:34 pm

bob turner wrote:
Not sure I am wild about the block lettering, but I am sure it is prototypical.



I can pretty comfortably say it isn't, and definitely say it isn't remotely typical. I've never seen a photo using that font on a black PT tank, even on a destreamlined Hudson. The usual Gothic lettering used on the cab is called for throughout on these locos after de-streamlining, not mixing the font with that from their streamlined days. It was an error on Sunset's part to use that lettering style, one never owned up to of course but easily fixed with a lick of paint and a decal or two.

That of course has no bearing on the weathering. Weathering is subjective. Lee is not really germane to any credence; he's one of many guys on the scale side of the house who is quite good at weathering, but in my eye there is a consistent heavy hand at his work so you don't get the variety of stock you see in life, that range from just a hint to the couple real mingers. I think a constant heavy weather across all the models in a freightyard for example is just as jarring as everything looking new out of the box.

That said, I think the technique is good. You asked, so areas of improvement (remembering this is all subjective, unlike painting and lettering diagrams) I can see are perhaps more of an eye to blending, what nature and physics does naturally. An example would be the brake hangers. My eye would have all the undercarriage below the running boards blended; dust mingling with oiled bits, mud, all rising up, so an eye to shadowing as the grunge rises from the ground helps believability. An airbrush helps with directional blending. Nothing should starkly stand out except by good reason. Ashpans often do because of the heat and the ash, and trailer trucks under the pans often take a different shade because the ash affect them differently from the rest of the running gear.

Soot from above does the same, but only as its dry. Once condensate from steam wets the soot, it often streaks on a boiler. In photos of the gray streamlined Hudsons, they look awful because of this effect, not because they were being neglected. They were just dirtied by black soot and water. Dark greys are your friend weathering/blending from above.

Some other odd tips;

Some great washes can be made with shoe-dye cut with alcohol, and have much better staying properties than chalks.

Don't forget the effects of humans. I often glase locos after I weather them because glass tends to shed particulates and humans tend to wipe windows to see out. Shop guys often wiped at least road numbers with an oily rag so you could see it, especially important on those routes operating trains by train-order as that train would be identified by the lead loco number. Its a cool effect to take a cotton bud just moistened with the solvent for the paints or washes you just used, very soon after you applied it, and "clean off" the lettering.

Some people weather a loco and it looks like its about to fall to pieces. Remember they are usually just dirty, still in excellent mechanical shape or at least able to pass their next inspection. An engineman could refuse a POS as a danger or not meeting working conditions (like the watercooler not filled in my day). These were very closely scrutinised pieces of machinery. Filthy? Sure. Scrap? Rarely. Freightcars have to pass the eye of the carknockers too. Modelers forget that.

Photos photos photos. Others have said it, and prototype photos are really important. I'm not convinced I'm a big believer in the notion weathering even can be duplicated effectively by copying a photo, because the blending that your eye perceives doesn't scale, and all the detailed copying doesn't replicate that blending. The result can be accurate and bloody awful. The photos do give you intensities, important effects, generalities. It sounds like art rather than replication because to be effective it often crosses that line into art; perception, not replication.

Another photo that's really important is one taken of a model after you think you're done. Great tool because they are absolutely merciless. Your eyes get all misty and love your work for you, but the camera doesn't care about your feelings.

Weathering looks different in different lighting. What looks great on the bench or in the paintbooth can look like shit on the layout or the display shelf. Usually thats colour and intensity, so a reblend saves that. Sometimes a piece jumps out at you, so blend it back into submission.

I practice a lot, both painting and weathering, using junk HO bodies and knackered freightcars. They cost next to nothing and are great to try new techniques on or hone the old ones. I also use scraps of styrene sheet/plasticard glued to handles. Cheap canvas upon which to play.

Lastly, I'll say I do like it very much. More blending than detail-painting would be my council, but again weathering is subjective. Watch the tendency to weather to the same intensity each time (like Lee and many others do, I'm afraid).

Best part is the model is now your's, not Sunset's.

bob turner
Posts: 13675
Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby bob turner » Sun Feb 11, 2018 1:29 pm

Just to add to that:

My first contest model was my first scratchbuilt - MM-2 #4207, for those who can find my Cab Forward thread. It was not weathered; just flat black with transfer lettering and Floquil graphite in appropriate places. It is still one of my favorite models. It lost to Max Gray models. My third attempt - AC-8 # 4189 - lost to a factory-painted Overland model owned by a dealer.

Then I discovered that the key to winning a model contest - at least the popular vote types - was heavy weathering. It did not have to be good; just heavy! Color seemed to help. After that, I rarely failed to take home a first prize.

Would I rather be judged on my modeling skills? You bet! Do I have unweathered models? Only all the models that will not be going to contests.

Again, very nice work on that Hudson.

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby sarge » Sun Feb 11, 2018 2:20 pm

Someday you have to let that one go, Bob. :lol: :lol:

It does prove the point about art. It's a very important point about your Hudson, and why it will, no matter what you do, evoke different reactions from different people. You can't take it personally, or you won't ever come away having learned anything and probably just get more bitter by the day. Peer review is like that, as you know in art. So, are you building or painting a model for you, or for "them".

What you like isn't germane in a contest model. It has to have the bits (using Bob's personal preferences as an example) brakeshoes, lots of detail (right or wrong), weather to their tastes, a sparvarnished plinth, whatever it takes.

You aren't being judged on your skills or otherwise because you aren't what is getting judged. A model contest is all about the model, not the skills required or whose skills they might be, but the result. It isn't a construction contest or even a modelling contest, its a model contest.

The important thing that actually applies here, though, is for whom are you weathering or building or detailing or whatever. If it's you, than please you. If its for NMRA judges, then that's the meaningful criteria, not yours. If its popular choice, that's the meaningful criteria, not yours.

If you choose to play in the band, you choose to play to the crowd. They didn't come to hear what you like.
Last edited by sarge on Sun Feb 11, 2018 4:56 pm, edited 1 time in total.

bob turner
Posts: 13675
Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby bob turner » Sun Feb 11, 2018 3:45 pm

I agree 100% with Sarge, except that part where I have to let go. I believe my tale has value for those wishing to compete.

Once I learned the secret, I won most contests I entered, even without brake shoes. Finally I realized I was smothering the contests, and stopped. I have way more ribbons than my fair share, given my level of skill.

I also agree with Sarge's preceding post - over half of my models are not weathered at all, unless you call flat black "weather". I only go "heavy" for contests, which means not at all these days.

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby sarge » Sun Feb 11, 2018 4:48 pm

bob turner wrote:... except that part where I have to let go.


Fair enough! Grin!

I'm not a contest modeler, though I did manage a blue once at one of the New England SONCs with a Berk a good friend of mine conned me into entering. I have to say I've built too many models for other people and (more recently) for the magazine. Lately I've been having fun building stuff for myself, over on the Paint Shop thread. I rather like that trend.

Back to point, knowing your audience and your purpose; that's a good thing.

Just keep building!

J. S. Bach
Posts: 5820
Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 9:30 pm

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby J. S. Bach » Sun Feb 11, 2018 5:37 pm

Well, sometimes equipment is not "weathered":
100_1943.jpg

I found out later that this motor had only been out of the paint shop for less that a week when I took the photo.

User avatar
Rufus T. Firefly
Posts: 42220
Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
Location: To be Determined

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby Rufus T. Firefly » Sun Feb 11, 2018 6:35 pm

sarge wrote:I'm not a contest modeler..........


I build 3-4 models every year for NMRA conventions, bu they are not far off from what I would be building anyway just trying to meet my own standards of adequate

I have to say I've built too many models for other people and (more recently) for the magazine.


I can't claim very many for others, a few here & there, but I've managed to build several that existed at the intersection of for me (or someone) and the magazine both.

Lately I've been having fun building stuff for myself, over on the Paint Shop thread. I rather like that trend.


I've sort of set everything aside and am deliberately plodding through clearing all projects lingering and languishing from by shop and off the benches regardless of their nature or my real interest anymore. After I get that done, I get to empty the debris field that masquerades as my layout room into my shop and then I'm going to work on my layout pretty close to exclusively just for me.

Back to point, knowing your audience and your purpose; that's a good thing.


Indeed. Very true for the NMRA thing; then again, I'm also the one that teaches the judges so I have a slight grasp of that audience.

Just keep building!


Yes. I would that we could return to the days of when sharing projects from start to end here was the norm. Look at my shiny thing is for OGR
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.

DaveJfr0
Posts: 401
Joined: Mon May 12, 2008 5:22 pm
Location: MD
Contact:

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby DaveJfr0 » Sun Feb 11, 2018 6:41 pm

Looks good to me, but I don't know much on weathering steam.

Weathering doesn't have to be heavy, especially with pan pastels existence today. There definitely are some heavy-handed weathering guys out there; I try not to be one of them unless I have a photo that justifies it. I consult photo's for most of what I do. And I agree with the above, the lighting changes the look of everything, so IMHO its best to do the weathering in the lighting it will mostly be in after its done, if possible. Taking photo's outside that lighting will usually most definitely change the look of the work, but oh well.

I model a range of years, '66-72, but if I can't find specific unit/car photos to work with, I will do an overall blend of similar cars in years close enough. The stuff that has an older repack/built date will certainly get something more than something that has a build date of 1972...at that point it will be more or less couplers, wheels, and maybe the trucks. It's easier to vary technique when you take years off between weathering parts of your roster, lol.

Btw, even that freshly painted G&W unit has weathered wheels and couplers that can be modeled. Maybe something light on the fuel tank (hard to see from the photo angle), but that's all I would do if trying to match that photo.
Focus: 2R O-Scale, SOU/SCL 1967-1972
Blog: http://davejfr0.blogspot.com/

User avatar
2railjon
Posts: 15906
Joined: Fri Apr 02, 2004 2:33 pm

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby 2railjon » Sun Feb 11, 2018 7:30 pm

Look at my shiny thing is for OGR


Oh, hell no! :lol:
Like Sarge said, (especially concerning passenger locomotives),they were well maintained and regularly cleaned. Sure, as with age, paint tends to fade and stain but they were still washed unlike backwoods logging Shays or hard working Docksiders.
Image

Image
Running that red block Charlie.

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: First Attempt at Weathering a Hudson, or any other O scale engine

Postby sarge » Sun Feb 11, 2018 7:55 pm

Not quite so fast, my Young Apprentice, for now we need to talk era.

The era of a model makes a serious difference, if you care about modelling what was vs. how things should have been.

Take a Sunset L3 Mohawk. Its configuration is as they were at the very end of life in the 1950s. So, they can pass inspections or be whitelined, but won't see another shopping. The weathering would be probably pretty manky compared to, say, a J1b in serif lettering as it would have appeared before the war needing weathered with a much lighter hand.

NYC diesels in the early sixties were usually pretty nice, PC ones in the 70s could be pretty ugly (ask me how I know. Grin!).

Timeperiod matters, and the ammount of weather can evoke period.

The same can be the case by railroad. In the sixties, NYC stuff was not horrid, and PRR stuff at the same time could be a rolling shitstorm (sorry, Pennsy guys). Santa Fe in the seventies was most often much cleaner than SP in the same era. Southern in that era was most often really pretty; Coast line, not so much.

Locale makes a difference, too. The dust and sun of Cali faded older enamels badly (reds and blues especially), long before the warmth of the Southeast. Northeastern stuff suffered from the concentrated industrial pollution and the brutalities of winter.

So, careful choices evoke locale, era, and company policy. Back to photos you go, and mind those dates!

...if this sort of thing is important to you, of course.


Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 48 guests