Were there 2 Car and Locomotive shops? What is 1/19.2 scale, certainly not O as the seller says. Very odd........also says battery powered. Pretty cute little critter, though.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/C-LS-Car-Locom ... SwOrBa7NZw
Peter
A new one on me.............?
-
herronpeter
- Posts: 748
- Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2014 9:13 pm
- Location: Clifton Park, NY
Re: A new one on me.............?
NO! There was only one C&LS. I don't recall Henry ever saying exactly why he had them built or what he thought the audience for the models would be, but they were (opinion) one of the last of many poor business decisions.
I think the scale was derived so they would run on O gauge track. Pretty sure the engine was a German industrial diesel.
I think the scale was derived so they would run on O gauge track. Pretty sure the engine was a German industrial diesel.
Re: A new one on me.............?
It's just a seller that is so ignorant as to not know the difference (or realise there is a difference) between "scale" and "gauge".
My simplistic math tells me 1.25" gauge used to represent 2' narrow gauge comes out to 1/19.2 scale. Henry's did too.
These were actually really cool; he did mineral tippers to go with them. Marvelous drives, with little whiskers out the cab to drive them. One was a reverser and the other a regulator/throttle. They could easily be adapted to battery R/C.
He and I had a long talk or two about this stuff. The target audience in the US was the large scale people, the F scale people doing 3' gauge at 1/20-ish, adding two-foot mine equipment on O gauge track. Henry also knew there was a reasonable following in the UK and Europe called 16mm scale, two-foot gauge on 32mm (MOROP and G0G O-gauge) track, and he intended to crack into the UK and European market.
So, he had a bunch made but CLS went up before he could get the majority across the Atlantic. They were the real target and I bet he would have done well. It wasn't a bad business decision at all, just one not able to be seen to completion before CLS went tits up. Thus a ton of it languished here, and he asked me to announce/review it in an attempt to get some sold. I took some well deserved shit for it, since it wasn't 1/48 though it was O Gauge, but worth it for a good friend.
To be honest, Henry was not the business buffoon people make him out to be unfairly. He was very imaginative and pushed the envelope, but he was no starry-eyed fool. He tried several things that were pretty radical, and luck deserted him from time to time. He had a plan for these too. It was a very imaginative one, typical Henry, but not one he didn't put a lot of thought into.
My simplistic math tells me 1.25" gauge used to represent 2' narrow gauge comes out to 1/19.2 scale. Henry's did too.
These were actually really cool; he did mineral tippers to go with them. Marvelous drives, with little whiskers out the cab to drive them. One was a reverser and the other a regulator/throttle. They could easily be adapted to battery R/C.
He and I had a long talk or two about this stuff. The target audience in the US was the large scale people, the F scale people doing 3' gauge at 1/20-ish, adding two-foot mine equipment on O gauge track. Henry also knew there was a reasonable following in the UK and Europe called 16mm scale, two-foot gauge on 32mm (MOROP and G0G O-gauge) track, and he intended to crack into the UK and European market.
So, he had a bunch made but CLS went up before he could get the majority across the Atlantic. They were the real target and I bet he would have done well. It wasn't a bad business decision at all, just one not able to be seen to completion before CLS went tits up. Thus a ton of it languished here, and he asked me to announce/review it in an attempt to get some sold. I took some well deserved shit for it, since it wasn't 1/48 though it was O Gauge, but worth it for a good friend.
To be honest, Henry was not the business buffoon people make him out to be unfairly. He was very imaginative and pushed the envelope, but he was no starry-eyed fool. He tried several things that were pretty radical, and luck deserted him from time to time. He had a plan for these too. It was a very imaginative one, typical Henry, but not one he didn't put a lot of thought into.
Re: A new one on me.............?
There were at least 4 or more of those in the auction along with over 100 "ore jennys" from the same builder, they went high more than half to a UK buyer.
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: A new one on me.............?
For that 4-10-2 alone Henry should be in the O Scale hall of fame. That was arguably the best . . .
Re: A new one on me.............?
hibar wrote:There were at least 4 or more of those in the auction along with over 100 "ore jennys" from the same builder, they went high more than half to a UK buyer.
Not a surprise, and I bet he will do well with them.
16mm is popular, since some of the most revered railways in the UK are two-foot gauge. Some famous preservation efforts such as the Welsh two-footers like Welsh Highlands and the Ffestiniog, the Isle of Man is famous as well, and a host of others.
I remember a number of other offerings in the scale and gauge, not the least of which was a Double-Fairlie done by the same builder as RYM used for years; Peco make 32mm narrow gauge spaced trackage commercially, and there is a pretty fair range of kits available too, some twenty to twenty-five manufacturers.
That little diesel and the tippers seem such odd men out in America, but very viable once you factor in the rest of the world.
- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42220
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: A new one on me.............?
sarge wrote:It's just a seller that is so ignorant as to not know the difference (or realise there is a difference) between "scale" and "gauge".
I actually know the seller on this; lives a couple of miles from me and when I've bought from him I pick the item up to reduce shipping to 0.
It's not ignorance as much as simply not caring and wanting to move as much as possible in sales as he can and letting a knowledgeable market set value. More accuracy in the listings might prove to result in better sales results, but it's his retirement business to move stuff from in the door to right back out the door. He makes his money and that meets his objective.
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 35 guests