John Webster wrote:The theory of the seeding of the earth from space after the origin of life sounds like a secular version of creationism. The parsimonious interpretation of the commonality of AGTC is that life established itself on earth one time only.
I will change my opinion when someone cracks open a meteorite and finds a fossil of an organism with ....
I have allowed myself to consider that perhaps the story of life's origin on Earth is a complicated one, including Creationism as well as the happenstance of arrivals later. I don't know that one idea has to cancel out or surrender to the other.
For example , viruses seem so alien to life and indestructible that I have long wondered if they were brought here, by happenstance , within the zillions of meteors that have made their way to Earth over the millennia . Perhaps such an organism could have made it through the physics and chemistry of such a journey, but I would doubt something fleshy like a proto-octopus etc could have made it thru.
Just some thoughts (ironically , on a Sunday morning, no less, before I leave the house for Church .) Life is complicated .
Murph