Are you going to post New Projects
Are you going to post New Projects
With What happened with my Dome car entry at OSW 2018 this year. I have been asked if I will post
new projects that I am working on to the MTJ form as they progress. That is a tough call to make.
I am really reluctant to do that given the Attitudes of a few that will make comments of a negative nature.
this does nothing but ruing for everyone else to see what is going on.
This has also led to a my attitude of possibly not doing any more articles for O scale resource Online, or any thing else
like this. Even thought the comments were positive, it just takes a lot of work to write them for Dan. case in point the Baggage
Dorm article which was a 4 part took 8 months to do. I may do in time some short type how to things articles.
I will just simply say the current project I am doing is 2 models for the MP Pullman 6 6 4 plan 4099. These were the pool car sleepers for the Colorado Eagle use on the St Louis to Denver. I will not post progressive poto's
Respecfully
Bill Basden Delta Dodels http://www.deltamodelsusa.com
new projects that I am working on to the MTJ form as they progress. That is a tough call to make.
I am really reluctant to do that given the Attitudes of a few that will make comments of a negative nature.
this does nothing but ruing for everyone else to see what is going on.
This has also led to a my attitude of possibly not doing any more articles for O scale resource Online, or any thing else
like this. Even thought the comments were positive, it just takes a lot of work to write them for Dan. case in point the Baggage
Dorm article which was a 4 part took 8 months to do. I may do in time some short type how to things articles.
I will just simply say the current project I am doing is 2 models for the MP Pullman 6 6 4 plan 4099. These were the pool car sleepers for the Colorado Eagle use on the St Louis to Denver. I will not post progressive poto's
Respecfully
Bill Basden Delta Dodels http://www.deltamodelsusa.com
- Attachments
-
- MP 6 6 4 Eagle River Denver col 1963.JPG (62.11 KiB) Viewed 6182 times
-
Chris Rock
- Posts: 1480
- Joined: Fri Sep 23, 2005 6:08 pm
- Location: United States
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
I don't know about OSW but I thought the threads on your past builds were all good, content and reaction. At least I always thought they were.
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
Yeah. Plus one. I have not seen any negative comments about your work.
Remember, this is the internet, where it is easy to get one's feelings hurt, and twice as easy to say something that will piss others off, without meaning to do so.
Remember, this is the internet, where it is easy to get one's feelings hurt, and twice as easy to say something that will piss others off, without meaning to do so.
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
Yeah Bill, really I don't know what anyone can say bad about your ACF MP cars; they're at the far edge of precision, what I aspire for but practically cannot do, and I like to see them a lot. Moreso because I like MP-T&P a lot and plan on building a train myself; I envy your patience and skills as much as your owning your final product.
But I actually put time into the meager projects I post here too, often with minimal responses if not basically a cricket-fest except from a few. Its always been this way here as everyone knows. Fact is most folks here are pretty busy, but nevertheless the initial message I get when that happens is its not worth commenting on so you know I understand you're sentiment, for me its discouraging.
So I would say if you're not getting what you consider appropriate feed-back here, then don't post. Spare yourself the disappointment. Its not like you have anything compelling to prove here. This forum runs at about 15% or less of the response rate compared to the buy-a-thon over at NK. Also the timing dynamic of forums often means things get buried quickly with subsequent posts and folks just never see yours, hence the unexpected "bumps" we all enjoy. Then also the hobby is changing, people who actually build models are way in the minority now, opinion but it is what's happened, people who build fines scale brass? Ya'll from outer-space.
I post here, because I like it better than other forums or FB, as the specific audience here counts far more to me personally than on those sites.
You're gonna win in the passenger car category in any model contest so maybe you should accept that and move on, when you win the contest, something I've never done btw, we'll likely see it one way or another anyway. Just please don't stop building those cars.
8^)
But I actually put time into the meager projects I post here too, often with minimal responses if not basically a cricket-fest except from a few. Its always been this way here as everyone knows. Fact is most folks here are pretty busy, but nevertheless the initial message I get when that happens is its not worth commenting on so you know I understand you're sentiment, for me its discouraging.
So I would say if you're not getting what you consider appropriate feed-back here, then don't post. Spare yourself the disappointment. Its not like you have anything compelling to prove here. This forum runs at about 15% or less of the response rate compared to the buy-a-thon over at NK. Also the timing dynamic of forums often means things get buried quickly with subsequent posts and folks just never see yours, hence the unexpected "bumps" we all enjoy. Then also the hobby is changing, people who actually build models are way in the minority now, opinion but it is what's happened, people who build fines scale brass? Ya'll from outer-space.
I post here, because I like it better than other forums or FB, as the specific audience here counts far more to me personally than on those sites.
You're gonna win in the passenger car category in any model contest so maybe you should accept that and move on, when you win the contest, something I've never done btw, we'll likely see it one way or another anyway. Just please don't stop building those cars.
8^)
Political Consultant- Tap into the hidden powers of your public office, insure your future is jail free, well funded. Visit shock and awe upon your adversaries, dominate the media, thrill your followers. contact morbo@happydaysrhereagain.com
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
I study everything your kind enough to post Bill. Passenger equipment is not my main interest but high quality workmanship like yours is VERY interesting. I'd rather see and read about the projects someone is actually doing than filtering through all the useless dribble that clogs the forums these days. Good luck Bill.
Robert
Robert
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
I enjoyed your posts. But I also empathize with your feelings.
Running that red block Charlie.
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
Yep, please keep up the good work and please show us the results of your labor, at least. Not sure what happened at OSW, but mostly likely ignorant voters who liked a stock RTR model, better than your hand built custom creation. I think that happened to Bob one year when a weathered SS model beat out his scratch built loco. If I'm wrong, I apologize now.
We have a country full of ignorant, clueless people....but it stills hurts.
BH
We have a country full of ignorant, clueless people....but it stills hurts.
BH
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
Yes it was the contest. 18 months on the Dome car and a 70 page binder to back it up. Insulted with
3 rd place. beat out with a PSC Harriman poorly pained and 60 unpainted chairs in side gets 1 st place.
OSW needs to drop the favorite contest format and go to a judged point system.
Bill
3 rd place. beat out with a PSC Harriman poorly pained and 60 unpainted chairs in side gets 1 st place.
OSW needs to drop the favorite contest format and go to a judged point system.
Bill
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
This O 3R person has until recently read everything posted on MTJ. I have recently stopped reading the purely political posts.
In my much younger days, @70 years ago, I did scratch build and kit bash in O and HO.The condition of my fingers and eyes
led me to RTR 3R. The only model railroad mag to which I still subscribe is OST. I enjoy reading how modelers build what they
build and I find those articles in OST and on the 2R forum of MTJ.
I understand that not getting any response to an article can be frustrating but my comments would be limited to saying that
the article was enjoyable. IMHO there are many that read the articles and like them but have nothing useful to say about it.
But that should not discourage an experienced modeler or writer.
I am only one but I will contnue to read all (except for pure politics) on MTJ.
In my much younger days, @70 years ago, I did scratch build and kit bash in O and HO.The condition of my fingers and eyes
led me to RTR 3R. The only model railroad mag to which I still subscribe is OST. I enjoy reading how modelers build what they
build and I find those articles in OST and on the 2R forum of MTJ.
I understand that not getting any response to an article can be frustrating but my comments would be limited to saying that
the article was enjoyable. IMHO there are many that read the articles and like them but have nothing useful to say about it.
But that should not discourage an experienced modeler or writer.
I am only one but I will contnue to read all (except for pure politics) on MTJ.
roger
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
Well, since you brought it up, "pure politics" is quite possibly the most important thing in all our lives today. Paying attention to what those we appoint to run the show are doing is practically a duty. Makes trains, airplanes, even career choices subordinate.
Opinion, of course.
Opinion, of course.
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
bob turner wrote:Well, since you brought it up, "pure politics" is quite possibly the most important thing in all our lives today. Paying attention to what those we appoint to run the show are doing is practically a duty. Makes trains, airplanes, even career choices subordinate.
Opinion, of course.
Bob,
Do you read all of the political stuff on MTJ? If you do, why don't you join the discussions? Maybe you have but I don't remember that.
roger
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42220
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
You make great models; you know it and we know it.
Why do you care what people think and do in a popular vote contest? Why do you let it influence your actions at all?
Why do you care what people think and do in a popular vote contest? Why do you let it influence your actions at all?
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
I think Roger summed it up quite well. I enjoy trying my hand on different projects but I would have no desire to do an entire run of freight cars or whatever as I’d burn myself out. I enjoy running trains and there’s definitely a place for RTR on my layout. Different strokes for different folks.


Running that red block Charlie.
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
Isn't that a gorgeous model? Jon, your scenery takes a back seat to no one.
Roger - I am paying attention. Maybe too much- I just finished Peter Irons' excellent (but out of date) book on the Supreme Court, and am re-reading a couple of Constitutional law texts.
I am following what our leaders are doing with more than a little interest. I believe that actually discussing issues is critically important, and when appropriate I engage in such discussions with respect for opinions of those with whom I disagree.
One can make an excellent case for not subverting a train forum, but I submit that we often diverge in other non-train directions.
All that said, I would much rather see shots like Jon's above than engage here in politics, humor, or even philosophy, unless it is gauge philosophy.
Roger - I am paying attention. Maybe too much- I just finished Peter Irons' excellent (but out of date) book on the Supreme Court, and am re-reading a couple of Constitutional law texts.
I am following what our leaders are doing with more than a little interest. I believe that actually discussing issues is critically important, and when appropriate I engage in such discussions with respect for opinions of those with whom I disagree.
One can make an excellent case for not subverting a train forum, but I submit that we often diverge in other non-train directions.
All that said, I would much rather see shots like Jon's above than engage here in politics, humor, or even philosophy, unless it is gauge philosophy.
Re: Are you going to post New Projects
Bob,
I do agree with you.
I do agree with you.
roger
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 38 guests
