Re-motoring assistance
Re-motoring assistance
I'm re-powering a Wolfer drive on an E44 engine. Replacing the older open frame motors with can motors.
I intend to re-use the worms, as they mesh well with the axle worm gear. Something my spare worms do not.
The motor shaft is .124", which is 3.146mm. Most motors I've researched have a 3mm shaft (.1181"). I think once the worms are re-soldered to the shafts (which is how they were attached) the .0059" difference will be irrelevant.
I'm looking for advice on a motor choice. Pittman shafts are too thick. The max motor body length cannot exceed 1.75"
Thank you for any comments.
I intend to re-use the worms, as they mesh well with the axle worm gear. Something my spare worms do not.
The motor shaft is .124", which is 3.146mm. Most motors I've researched have a 3mm shaft (.1181"). I think once the worms are re-soldered to the shafts (which is how they were attached) the .0059" difference will be irrelevant.
I'm looking for advice on a motor choice. Pittman shafts are too thick. The max motor body length cannot exceed 1.75"
Thank you for any comments.
I am John Galt.
Chris
Chris
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Re: Re-motoring assistance
Chris --
I would want the worm dead-nuts concentric to the shaft. I would think that any wobble would be death to the gearset. A Wolfer GG1 came through my shop a couple of years ago and it had Pittman 9000 series motors, as I recall. It may be that the worm was bored out to fit. I would think that would be a better way to go if you can't find a motor with the correct size shaft. Boring out the worm and finishing with a ream would be a straightforward operation on a lathe, though I have not (yet) had the need to do it myself. Perhaps Joe F., Jay C., or Bob T. will comment further. Inquiring minds want to know.
Jim
I would want the worm dead-nuts concentric to the shaft. I would think that any wobble would be death to the gearset. A Wolfer GG1 came through my shop a couple of years ago and it had Pittman 9000 series motors, as I recall. It may be that the worm was bored out to fit. I would think that would be a better way to go if you can't find a motor with the correct size shaft. Boring out the worm and finishing with a ream would be a straightforward operation on a lathe, though I have not (yet) had the need to do it myself. Perhaps Joe F., Jay C., or Bob T. will comment further. Inquiring minds want to know.
Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Re-motoring assistance
I agree - tricky stuff. You want to bore it with a collet and a crankshaft drill - a little short stubby, but new and high quality drill. Or a reamer. If you can get a light press fit, then blue or green Loctite will make it permanent. That's what the Chinese do.
What is wrong with the Wolfer motors? Worn out?
What is wrong with the Wolfer motors? Worn out?
Re: Re-motoring assistance
Thank you guys.
Bob, the original motors are small and do not provide adequate torque. Particularly for a prototype engine that had high tractive effort.
The other item is properly isolating the motors from the trucks for DCC operation. The current mounts make that difficult.
The worms are brass, or a brass/bronze alloy. Drilling them out should doable. I do have a pair of Pittman 8524 motors. They are a bit large and I haven't tested the fitment in the body yet.
Bob, the original motors are small and do not provide adequate torque. Particularly for a prototype engine that had high tractive effort.
The other item is properly isolating the motors from the trucks for DCC operation. The current mounts make that difficult.
The worms are brass, or a brass/bronze alloy. Drilling them out should doable. I do have a pair of Pittman 8524 motors. They are a bit large and I haven't tested the fitment in the body yet.
I am John Galt.
Chris
Chris
-
J. S. Bach
- Posts: 5820
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 9:30 pm
Re: Re-motoring assistance
PRR Man wrote:I'm re-powering a Wolfer drive on an E44 engine.
Mine appears to have an All-Nation drive. I have not taken the lid off yet to see what kind of motor is in there.
I just noticed (the camera never lies!) that the builder put a different road number (4440) on one side and 4400 on the other side and the number boards.
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Re-motoring assistance
I've been somewhat hesitant to comment but the statement on isolating the motor for DCC operation just forced my hand. I'll address that issue first. There is a common misconception, or myth, about what is meant by isolating the motor for DCC. The truth is, you need to isolate the leads (+ and -), not the motor itself. The motor has no polarity. If it does, it's shorted out. This myth comes from the old days when we shorted one lead the frame of our models to use the right (non-insulated) side for pickup. I've seen modelers spend hours trying to isolate the motor housing and it's all a waste of time.
Back to the primary question. If I was going to re-motor this model, the first thing I would do is find motors that fit, will provide the power required, and with enough RPMs to give me the performance I want. The Pittman motors you mention should be adequate. Make sure they will fit the space and can be mounted properly. After that I would adapt the worms to the motor shafts. Most Pittman motors, used by us, have 5/32" shafts, made from low carbon steel (think 12L14 or Ledloy). To me this would mean boring out the worm. NOT DRILLING! Bob is correct, a collet or very accurate chuck is required (many 3 or 4 jaw chucks have too much run out). For a press fit I would use a chucking reamer that's slightly undersized or a small boring bar. If you can't obtain a press fit then go with a slip fit and use the proper formula LocTite. You could always solder it to but I like the LocTite. I use #680. If you don't have the equipment to bore the worm accurately, it might be wise to pay someone who does to do it for you. If it isn't balls on it will never run properly.
From what I've observed, Mr. Wolfer didn't use premium motors and his drives were a little on the cheaper side of the line. What I'm really referring to are the Pittman can motors he used later on. All had Alnico magnets and bronze bearings. Cheapest offered by Pittman. I can't really speak to the open frame versions because I don't think there were many options. As an example, from the factory, a DC-95 is a DC-95...one version and that's it.
Okay, I should probably proof this but it's time for a cup of coffee.
Jay
Back to the primary question. If I was going to re-motor this model, the first thing I would do is find motors that fit, will provide the power required, and with enough RPMs to give me the performance I want. The Pittman motors you mention should be adequate. Make sure they will fit the space and can be mounted properly. After that I would adapt the worms to the motor shafts. Most Pittman motors, used by us, have 5/32" shafts, made from low carbon steel (think 12L14 or Ledloy). To me this would mean boring out the worm. NOT DRILLING! Bob is correct, a collet or very accurate chuck is required (many 3 or 4 jaw chucks have too much run out). For a press fit I would use a chucking reamer that's slightly undersized or a small boring bar. If you can't obtain a press fit then go with a slip fit and use the proper formula LocTite. You could always solder it to but I like the LocTite. I use #680. If you don't have the equipment to bore the worm accurately, it might be wise to pay someone who does to do it for you. If it isn't balls on it will never run properly.
From what I've observed, Mr. Wolfer didn't use premium motors and his drives were a little on the cheaper side of the line. What I'm really referring to are the Pittman can motors he used later on. All had Alnico magnets and bronze bearings. Cheapest offered by Pittman. I can't really speak to the open frame versions because I don't think there were many options. As an example, from the factory, a DC-95 is a DC-95...one version and that's it.
Okay, I should probably proof this but it's time for a cup of coffee.
Jay
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Re-motoring assistance
If the 8524 doesn't fit, the 8523 is shorter. The 8522 is shorter still!
I agree with Jay - you want rare earth magnets and ball bearing shafts. The "2" in the part # means rare earth, so you are partway there.
Charlie Pittman told me never load a bronze bearing motor radially - always choose ball bearings.
I agree with Jay - you want rare earth magnets and ball bearing shafts. The "2" in the part # means rare earth, so you are partway there.
Charlie Pittman told me never load a bronze bearing motor radially - always choose ball bearings.
Re: Re-motoring assistance
compared to the photos posted, the driveline on my unit is the typical center axle worm gear driving chain and sprockets to the outer axles.
I went back to re-examine the construction of the motor housing, prior to Jay's comments, and found since the top end brushes are (somewhat) isolated from the body. Confirming his assessment. Previous owner (or perhaps Wolfer) had placed tape below the brush mounts as they are perilously close to the motor body. Not a situation I wish to have.
though I do have an accurate drill press, I do not have the capability to BORE out the worms properly. I'll look for a source to do so.
Bob, thanks for the Pitman #'s.
Thank you for your comments.
I went back to re-examine the construction of the motor housing, prior to Jay's comments, and found since the top end brushes are (somewhat) isolated from the body. Confirming his assessment. Previous owner (or perhaps Wolfer) had placed tape below the brush mounts as they are perilously close to the motor body. Not a situation I wish to have.
though I do have an accurate drill press, I do not have the capability to BORE out the worms properly. I'll look for a source to do so.
Bob, thanks for the Pitman #'s.
Thank you for your comments.
I am John Galt.
Chris
Chris
Re: Re-motoring assistance
revisiting the discussion.
regarding isolating the original Pittman open frame motor for DCC use. one commutator brush mount has a nylon insulating bushing over the mounting post. the other pole does not. the mounting post goes straight through the motor body. the brush without the bushing has continuity with the motor body through it's mounting post. both motors are like this. they may at one time had both brushes bushed with nylon, but I suspect not. unless a previous owner intended to draw current through the motor body.
this is why I had concern about isolating the motor if I kept the originals.
I'd post a photo but have no imaging account to do so.
regarding isolating the original Pittman open frame motor for DCC use. one commutator brush mount has a nylon insulating bushing over the mounting post. the other pole does not. the mounting post goes straight through the motor body. the brush without the bushing has continuity with the motor body through it's mounting post. both motors are like this. they may at one time had both brushes bushed with nylon, but I suspect not. unless a previous owner intended to draw current through the motor body.
this is why I had concern about isolating the motor if I kept the originals.
I'd post a photo but have no imaging account to do so.
I am John Galt.
Chris
Chris
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Re-motoring assistance
Actually you're saying the same thing I said but in a slightly different way. The motor doesn't have to be isolated but the brushes do. If you copy the insulated side and insulate/isolate both the brushes, it will work just fine. Shoot, a small piece of tubing will work. The best is to use something that can handle a little heat. What you're seeing is the way we did it for years...easy and cheap. Eliminates wiring to the frame.
Jay
Jay
-
J. S. Bach
- Posts: 5820
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 9:30 pm
Re: Re-motoring assistance
PRR Man wrote:revisiting the discussion. ...snip... I'd post a photo but have no imaging account to do so.
You do not need an account anywhere, just upload them from your computer directly to the forum. There is a tab called "Attachments", click on that and there is a radio button that says "Add files", click on that and select the photos that you wish to upload. That is what I did for the E-44 photos. Once it completes the loading process, click on "Place inline". That is what I did for this PRR N8 cabin car truck just so I could follow alone with the steps (and get them right!
Re: Re-motoring assistance
here's a photo of the motor's top. thanks to Johan for the tip
the Pittman 8524 are too tall to fit. I found pair of 8322 and arranged to have the worms bored.
the Pittman 8524 are too tall to fit. I found pair of 8322 and arranged to have the worms bored.
I am John Galt.
Chris
Chris
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: Re-motoring assistance
If you install a non-conductive sleeve/bushing/whatever on the left had side the motor would qualify as being "Isolated". In other words, make the left look just like the right.
Jay
Jay
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 51 guests