ProtoThrottle
Re: ProtoThrottle
Just so everyone knows, I am a three railer. I watched the video in the first post. For me it looks too much like work. I just like to play trains.
I have no problem with what the gentlemen in the videos are doing and I am sure they enjoy it. A lot of the model railroad hobby is concerned
about its future and I wonder if seeing a video like this could be off-putting (?) to some younger modelers?
We sometimes forget how many started with that circle of track under the tree before moving on.
I have no problem with what the gentlemen in the videos are doing and I am sure they enjoy it. A lot of the model railroad hobby is concerned
about its future and I wonder if seeing a video like this could be off-putting (?) to some younger modelers?
We sometimes forget how many started with that circle of track under the tree before moving on.
roger
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: ProtoThrottle
Ah! But it's NEW! Sparkly! Innovative! All that carp (sp).
Seen several "apps" to use your stupidphone 3.0....and why? What about those of us that steadfastly refuse to own a stupidphone 3.0?
DCC. Nope. Not since my run in with Ames. I have dedicated radio battery, straight track power, and my tethered, memory walkarounds (three) for my 3-rail AC. Haven't been able to buy them in what, almost 30 years, but they work.
Like through-hole versus surface mount. One you can fix, the other...well, maybe.
Last dcc I ran was an Sn3 layout....Brian Ellerbee..guy who started Evergreen Plastics.
Thumb wheels to set loco number, knob and switch...tethered, memory, in-freaking-tuitive.
I do NOT do technology for technologies sake. Flathead Fords, vacuum tube radios, land lines, 1911 (not A-1), 90-year-old farmhouse, if it works, I use it. XP.
Seen several "apps" to use your stupidphone 3.0....and why? What about those of us that steadfastly refuse to own a stupidphone 3.0?
DCC. Nope. Not since my run in with Ames. I have dedicated radio battery, straight track power, and my tethered, memory walkarounds (three) for my 3-rail AC. Haven't been able to buy them in what, almost 30 years, but they work.
Like through-hole versus surface mount. One you can fix, the other...well, maybe.
Last dcc I ran was an Sn3 layout....Brian Ellerbee..guy who started Evergreen Plastics.
Thumb wheels to set loco number, knob and switch...tethered, memory, in-freaking-tuitive.
I do NOT do technology for technologies sake. Flathead Fords, vacuum tube radios, land lines, 1911 (not A-1), 90-year-old farmhouse, if it works, I use it. XP.
Dave....gone by invitation
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: ProtoThrottle
Dave,
But Roger asked about the future. You, I, and the rest of us old farts ain't the future. Young people play with their phones, game controllers, you name it. These throttles may be exactly what they'll like.
Jay
But Roger asked about the future. You, I, and the rest of us old farts ain't the future. Young people play with their phones, game controllers, you name it. These throttles may be exactly what they'll like.
Jay
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: ProtoThrottle
Jay Criswell wrote:Dave,
But Roger asked about the future. You, I, and the rest of us old farts ain't the future. Young people play with their phones, game controllers, you name it. These throttles may be exactly what they'll like.
Jay
Doesn't have enough flashing lights, and I cannot find a "reset game" button anywhere.
How do you select Godzilla to eat the trains on that handpiece?
Dave....gone by invitation
Re: ProtoThrottle
I agree that they may like all of the technology involved but don't think they will be dedicated enough to run trains in a prototype manner as seen
in the above videos. Now if you can find a way to crash or blow up trains or to pit CSX against BNSF they may find an interest if they can make
them go fast.
in the above videos. Now if you can find a way to crash or blow up trains or to pit CSX against BNSF they may find an interest if they can make
them go fast.
roger
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: ProtoThrottle
rogruth wrote:I agree that they may like all of the technology involved but don't think they will be dedicated enough to run trains in a prototype manner as seen
in the above videos. Now if you can find a way to crash or blow up trains or to pit CSX against BNSF they may find an interest if they can make
them go fast.
How do you select Godzilla to eat the trains on that handpiece?
Dave....gone by invitation
Re: ProtoThrottle
No wonder the go-to response from that generation to us today is, “OK boomer.”
l think you guys are selling a generation you don’t see or know rather short.
The point of that throttle is actually pretty plain, a miniaturised control stand to replicate as nearly as possible the controls of the locomotive. It follows logically the quest for that “feel” arguably starting with the Marnold Marn-o-stat as a lever in a world of Ohmite rotary rheostats, through momentum circuits, then transistor throttles, walk-arounds, Astrak, Zero-1, DCC, sound, all intended to improve the sensory experience of running. How is this different than, say, Chick Siebert who built a prototype trolley control stand into his traction layout in the 1940s, or indeed the miniaturised ones several of the East Penn Traction guys (if memory serves) caused to be commercially made in the 70s?
Regarding the coming generations, they are here in the hobby. Just because they don’t go to conventions and trainshows doesn’t mean they don’t exist. It just means you don’t see them. They grew up with a computer in the house, while we lived in a pre-computer world when even a tv was a luxury, not a required feature. Their convention is the social media and their trainshow is eBay. No, most don’t solder or glue up sticks but create controls. They are of the Information Age while we are of the Machine Age. That explains why there is such a disconnect between us, because it isn’t a disparity between generations, but the disparity between children of different social ages the like unseen since the beginnings of the Machine Age.
It doesn’t mean they are idiots any more than we are. Theirs is a very different world than we knew, neither world makes any effort to even try to get the differences, and for every ha-ha comment on either side, ignorance and truculence is proven and that disparity becomes just a little bit wider.
l think you guys are selling a generation you don’t see or know rather short.
The point of that throttle is actually pretty plain, a miniaturised control stand to replicate as nearly as possible the controls of the locomotive. It follows logically the quest for that “feel” arguably starting with the Marnold Marn-o-stat as a lever in a world of Ohmite rotary rheostats, through momentum circuits, then transistor throttles, walk-arounds, Astrak, Zero-1, DCC, sound, all intended to improve the sensory experience of running. How is this different than, say, Chick Siebert who built a prototype trolley control stand into his traction layout in the 1940s, or indeed the miniaturised ones several of the East Penn Traction guys (if memory serves) caused to be commercially made in the 70s?
Regarding the coming generations, they are here in the hobby. Just because they don’t go to conventions and trainshows doesn’t mean they don’t exist. It just means you don’t see them. They grew up with a computer in the house, while we lived in a pre-computer world when even a tv was a luxury, not a required feature. Their convention is the social media and their trainshow is eBay. No, most don’t solder or glue up sticks but create controls. They are of the Information Age while we are of the Machine Age. That explains why there is such a disconnect between us, because it isn’t a disparity between generations, but the disparity between children of different social ages the like unseen since the beginnings of the Machine Age.
It doesn’t mean they are idiots any more than we are. Theirs is a very different world than we knew, neither world makes any effort to even try to get the differences, and for every ha-ha comment on either side, ignorance and truculence is proven and that disparity becomes just a little bit wider.
Re: ProtoThrottle
I don't think they are idiots, I just think they have little interest in model trains.
roger
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
Re: ProtoThrottle
Maybe, but why would one think for a moment these generations would be nostalgic for stuff we grew up with rather than what they grew up with, then ridicule because they don’t share and revere our nostalgia?
Sorry, it makes no sense to me, if I’m honest.
Sorry, it makes no sense to me, if I’m honest.
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: ProtoThrottle
I probably have a little different perspective than most. Because of all the dealings I have with friends, clients, customers, whatever, worldwide I can pretty much track my sales and get to know the people. As Lou told me many years ago, these people become your friends more than customers.
Where am I going with this? A very large part of my sales are to people younger than many of us. Most prefer more modern prototypes. That's what they see. Many are really outstanding modelers and strive for as much realism as they can get. I like them. They want to learn more, to a point.
It is surprising how many want to get into P:48 and are happy with shelf layouts. When told P:48 is not the way to go, they seem to react with, "Okay Boomer". Many just don't have room for large layouts. hence the shelf. Shoot, who does?
I think many of you would be surprised with their perception of the ProtoThrottle. From what I've seen, many like them.
Jay
Where am I going with this? A very large part of my sales are to people younger than many of us. Most prefer more modern prototypes. That's what they see. Many are really outstanding modelers and strive for as much realism as they can get. I like them. They want to learn more, to a point.
It is surprising how many want to get into P:48 and are happy with shelf layouts. When told P:48 is not the way to go, they seem to react with, "Okay Boomer". Many just don't have room for large layouts. hence the shelf. Shoot, who does?
I think many of you would be surprised with their perception of the ProtoThrottle. From what I've seen, many like them.
Jay
Re: ProtoThrottle
My point is that I see little interest from y0unger people. Shen I was a kid there was no Thomas but all the kids in the neighborhood had a train or wanted a train. I don't see that today. You may be right that it will take electronic gizmos to get them interested in trains.
roger
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
Re: ProtoThrottle
Roger, you might be surprised when I say this, but that universal interest was pretty dead already when I was a kid.
Sure there were a couple of us who liked trains too, but it was aircraft, cars, and the space programme that captured our imagination by then. Trains were already far from having a universal appeal. Lionel took its first corporate prang in, what, 1966? Every boy was no longer a countable member of their marketplace by any means.
These sorts of things like this throttle aren’t aimed at the nostalgia crowd or the Luddites. It doesn’t make those for whom they do appeal a group ripe for ridicule. These “kids” are the hobby’s future. Nostalgia certainly isn’t.
Sure there were a couple of us who liked trains too, but it was aircraft, cars, and the space programme that captured our imagination by then. Trains were already far from having a universal appeal. Lionel took its first corporate prang in, what, 1966? Every boy was no longer a countable member of their marketplace by any means.
These sorts of things like this throttle aren’t aimed at the nostalgia crowd or the Luddites. It doesn’t make those for whom they do appeal a group ripe for ridicule. These “kids” are the hobby’s future. Nostalgia certainly isn’t.
Re: ProtoThrottle
True. My kid time was the 1940s. Graduated high school in 1952.
Couldn't avoid playing war in the '40s but trains were always there.
Couldn't avoid playing war in the '40s but trains were always there.
roger
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
-
Chris Webster
- Posts: 957
- Joined: Mon May 25, 2015 8:25 pm
Re: ProtoThrottle
rogruth wrote:Just so everyone knows, I am a three railer.
I think it's amazing that, in 2019, we can go buy brand-new trains from Menards, Bachmann, Lionel & MTH that are fully compatible with Lionel trains made as far back as (I think) 1946. If you don't try to couple them together, those brand new trains will reven un fine Lionel track from the 1930s (or maybe earlier?) I presume that some of the brand-new engines could even be run using transformers from the 1930s (or maybe earlier, I'm not sure.)
Re: ProtoThrottle
Chris,
I think the old transformers will work.
Post war trains could be run with those from the 1930s.
I know because I did.
3 R trains will run on Lionel pre-war T-rail track but the
Lionel scale 700 stuff from the late '30s and early '40s
will not run on tubular track. I think they will on other
T rail shaped track. But you probably know all of this.
I think the old transformers will work.
Post war trains could be run with those from the 1930s.
I know because I did.
3 R trains will run on Lionel pre-war T-rail track but the
Lionel scale 700 stuff from the late '30s and early '40s
will not run on tubular track. I think they will on other
T rail shaped track. But you probably know all of this.
roger
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
I support thread drift.
If God didn't want women to be looked at, He would have made 'em ugly. RAH
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 49 guests