Drifting along; RTR quality, Couplers, EMD cabs...

Discuss All Facets of 2-Rail, 1/48 Scale, Model Railroading
bob turner
Posts: 13676
Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby bob turner » Thu Dec 23, 2021 1:54 am

This has taken a turn for the strange. The old Kadees, while not totally faithful to the Janney, were the right general size and worked a lot better than Monarch. I have not seen the newer design, but it is apparently closer.

We have Protocraft (Clouser/High Sierra?) and they work just like the real thing. Scale Craft made a version in good Zamac. Some (not me) have coaxed the Monarchs into realistic operation (South Shasta is a famous example). And a few have standardized on Roundhouse, a pretty darn good scale coupler when the "hose" is cut off.

And Kadee mates with all of them - usually "automatically!"

And now, by golly, we have shelf couplers!

I for one will not be complaining about O Scale couplers. I still remember those hideous Mantua loops. Have you seen what the 3-railers have? Yuk!

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby ScaleCraft » Thu Dec 23, 2021 2:30 am

bob turner wrote:This has taken a turn for the strange. The old Kadees, while not totally faithful to the Janney, were the right general size and worked a lot better than Monarch. I have not seen the newer design, but it is apparently closer.

We have Protocraft (Clouser/High Sierra?) and they work just like the real thing. Scale Craft made a version in good Zamac. Some (not me) have coaxed the Monarchs into realistic operation (South Shasta is a famous example). And a few have standardized on Roundhouse, a pretty darn good scale coupler when the "hose" is cut off.

And Kadee mates with all of them - usually "automatically!"

And now, by golly, we have shelf couplers!

I for one will not be complaining about O Scale couplers. I still remember those hideous Mantua loops. Have you seen what the 3-railers have? Yuk!

I have a whole string of H0 freight cars with Mantuas on them. Did it on purpose, just to be ornery.
Even made a coupler gauge to set them up.
THE most widely used H0 coupler until KD's came along.

Learned how to mill out (by hand) floors of cars to get correct height without resorting to the KD trick of bolster shim washers which certainly did not factor in Prototype Height of carbody.
Dave....gone by invitation

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby sarge » Thu Dec 23, 2021 10:11 am

To be clear this turn wasn't meant to be "complaining about O Scale couplers". We have quite the array, though the original point was the opinion of stupidity on Atlas' part and the wisdom of Weaver Models to make their individual coupler boxes with a defacto standard screw spacing so you could standardise on a coupler across multiple manufacturers of stock, everything from old Weaver through Intermountain and Red Caboose kits up to the most expensive of brass imports, all except Atlas whose manager thought by making the boxes impossible and the mounting spacing in the stock and locos bespoke, someone would buy and run only Atlas products in the same manner the three railers tout Lionel or MTH or whatever side they take in their brand loyalty wars. It shows a piss-poor understanding of the drivers in the scale model railway hobby.

From there, we've just moved off to a general discussion on couplers. Me? I'm standardised on the 80X Kadee. No mixing. They are robust, reliable, and my choice for proto-ops. During an ops session they are transparent. If my focus was solely on the individual model, I'd probably be using the Protocraft or Jim Harper's design for appearance and fidelity. If I'm honest, I never was very interested in what the HO people used to use, though.

User avatar
Rufus T. Firefly
Posts: 42237
Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
Location: To be Determined

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby Rufus T. Firefly » Thu Dec 23, 2021 11:21 am

.
Last edited by Rufus T. Firefly on Tue Apr 26, 2022 8:18 pm, edited 1 time in total.
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby ScaleCraft » Thu Dec 23, 2021 12:23 pm

Rufus T. Firefly wrote:
I never was very interested in what the HO people used to use, though.


Not being an HO modeler...........why would there be any interest? I may have built 3-4 HO (or even On30) models in the last 20 years only to use that to build the unavailable O scale analog. I may have put HO trucks under 1 just to make it depart from here more rapidly, :wink: :wink:



odd. Used to be, products developed for 0, later downsized for H0 or even 00.
Nowadays almost seems products developed for H0, later maybe upsized for 0.

Read some of the comments in this thread.

Sometimes looking outside of your garden can give you an insight on your town.

If a person screws his blinders on REAL tight, he may not see what is happening right outside his direct field of vision.

You can come to a real fast understanding of some important principles if you don't ignore that stuff just outside your field of view.
Dave....gone by invitation

E7
Posts: 8404
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 1:35 am

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby E7 » Thu Dec 23, 2021 3:30 pm

ScaleCraft wrote:odd. Used to be, products developed for 0, later downsized for H0 or even 00.
Nowadays almost seems products developed for H0, later maybe upsized for 0.

Read some of the comments in this thread.

Sometimes looking outside of your garden can give you an insight on your town.

If a person screws his blinders on REAL tight, he may not see what is happening right outside his direct field of vision.

You can come to a real fast understanding of some important principles if you don't ignore that stuff just outside your field of view.


Makes sense to me Dave. I don't see that innovation has to be scale sensitive. HO is the majority in this hobby and likely sees the most innovation (more money there). If something "good" can be borrowed from the HO'ers, I'm all for it.

And I'll borrow from our late friend Roger: "I support thread drift." If we can't deviate/comment a bit from the "Atlas coupler mounting hole setup is a piece of crap." theme, then there's really NO point to be made here. Better to just send them (Atlas) a nastygram telling them your beef and see if they do anything about it or stop buying their stuff. It sounds to me like we're putting one piece of CRAP on another. Just as easily could be: Why doesn't Kadee make their crap to fit on Atlas cars.

Rich

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby ScaleCraft » Thu Dec 23, 2021 4:31 pm

E7 wrote:
Makes sense to me Dave. I don't see that innovation has to be scale sensitive. HO is the majority in this hobby and likely sees the most innovation (more money there). If something "good" can be borrowed from the HO'ers, I'm all for it.

And I'll borrow from our late friend Roger: "I support thread drift." If we can't deviate/comment a bit from the "Atlas coupler mounting hole setup is a piece of crap." theme, then there's really NO point to be made here. Better to just send them (Atlas) a nastygram telling them your beef and see if they do anything about it or stop buying their stuff. It sounds to me like we're putting one piece of CRAP on another. Just as easily could be: Why doesn't Kadee make their crap to fit on Atlas cars.

Rich


I suppose I have an attitudinal deficiency WRT Atlas. I was a reluctant fan of Snap-Track back in the 50's, probably because the options were fibre flex and TruScale (which I REALLY liked). Once they did the Rivarossi BS in 0, I gave up.
I mean, here you have yet another Atlas 0 coupler screwup....remember the clawhook talgos the early stuff had?
Push in kingpins?
Couldn't just screw another truck on...oh, no...had to fill the sinkhole first.
The power blocks made IMP look like Kohs drives.
My buddy Joe ended up with all I had come through here, probably a dozen, used the parts to keep two running for a while, then they all went into the trash.
Was it Einstein who said something about doing the same stuff over and over expecting different results?

How many times does a company get a free pass to enter a market, screw it up, go away, then re-enter the market, screw it up, go away....then what?

Sometimes they do it right...like their double track 48" truss bridge...but remember, even a blind squirrel occasionally finds an acorn.
Dave....gone by invitation

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby sarge » Thu Dec 23, 2021 5:38 pm

E7 wrote: ...just as easily could be: Why doesn't Kadee make their crap to fit on Atlas cars.

Rich


Because then it wouldn't fit on any of a dozen or more other manufacturers' and importers'. GRIN!

Kadee understand the value of standards, which rather is the point.

I'm with you on the blinders sentiment. Watching what the 7mm people are using, or the paints and materials and techniques the IPMS folk have, so much out there you can carry back to O. I guess my one comment is a bit misconstrued though; my interest in old HO couplers is pretty minimal simply because there aren't any lessons to bring into my modelling there.

Dave, I think you are mixing some of AHMs clangers in with the 70s Atlas. Rivarossi built for AHM, not Atlas, and those power block things were theirs. The claws were theirs, too; Atlas was at least smart enough make their stuff easily converted to scale wheels and couplers then.

Talking of HO, its interesting how the HO industry, including Atlas oddly enough, embrace without question the holy trinity of fidelity, compatibility, and performance. Even N product today is amazing to me.

Anyway, just a conversation and aimless drifting thread...

User avatar
Rufus T. Firefly
Posts: 42237
Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
Location: To be Determined

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby Rufus T. Firefly » Thu Dec 23, 2021 5:43 pm

.
Last edited by Rufus T. Firefly on Tue Apr 26, 2022 8:18 pm, edited 1 time in total.
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.

bob turner
Posts: 13676
Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby bob turner » Thu Dec 23, 2021 7:19 pm

You guys need a Shutterfly account. More photos, please.

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby sarge » Thu Dec 23, 2021 7:35 pm

bob turner wrote:You guys need a Shutterfly account. More photos, please.


Gotta finish a project first. Grin!

E7
Posts: 8404
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 1:35 am

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby E7 » Sun Dec 26, 2021 12:21 pm

This may seem over simplistic, and I'm not being a smart aleck, but there are only a couple ways to deal with the issue of Atlas' funky mounting system. As to why they persist in doing things the way they do there is only one answer that I can think of....they want to. Just like what the Brit said about one of the manufacturers in the video on passenger car couplings, they do it because they want to. It's their choice.

There are only 2 ways I know of to deal with that issue. Send them a letter, E-Mail, telegram, talk with them at a show, whatever, telling them of your displeasure with their product, or STOP buying their stuff.

I buy almost ALL my equipment on the secondary market. I have never had an issue with Atlas' coupler mounting setup. You can infer from that what you please.

I really dislike the Kadee coupler and it's stupid whisker, and I refuse to buy/use it. They make them as they do for the same reason Atlas makes their coupler mounting, they choose to, and my choice is to NOT use either of their products. It might be different if they were the only option, but thankfully they are not!

Rich

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby sarge » Sun Dec 26, 2021 1:42 pm

I'm not taking it as you being a smart aleck in the slightest.

I assume you don't use their mounting system simply because you don't use their coupler with its equally stupid whisker, or Weaver's or the old Monarch or any of the choices using magnetic uncoupling. Not hard to have no personal problem with it when you don't use it.

Its my experience Atlas is pretty immune to direct individual customer input, indeed finding it an annoyance. They aren't alone but, because they tout themselves a scale model railroad company, its been a bit of a letdown when they repeatedly "do what they want" such as your bête noir, the F-unit headlight, or making roadswitchers with twin-motor drives, the oversized RS-3, the too-narrow RS-1 cab and steel rebuild USRA car, the fantasy handrails on the RSD-15, and on and on. Its not an exception, its not even a trend. Its a tradition.

Direct input unwelcome as it is (and a thread on a forum is certainly a legitimate form of input), the other alternative as you say is to "not buy". Forums then become a venue to discuss such things and, perhaps more importantly, increase awareness in the marketplace so others can make their decision to buy or not based on what might be learned during that discussion. That being the case, one person merely being quiet and individually not buying a product means nothing in sales figures. Consumer power is only effective when it is collective; honest and civil discussion, awareness, and education are the hallmarks of collective market opinion.

When freightcars are crossing the $100 a pop mark, and plastic RTR locos are headed north of a grand, its just as cost effective to embrace fidelity, performance, and compatibility as it is to cavalierly ignore them. Indeed, embracing those things can lead to a sales improvement in the scale model railway marketplace in O, if HO and N are any indication. So, if we collectively discuss and speak, something might improve (I'm not holding my breath, but there would then be a chance). We silently endure (thereby tacitly accepting) the same turds polished with new paint schemes and new pricepoints, the answer to any progress is an automatic "no".

That really is the point of all this and the value of it, so long as it remains as civil, factual, and non-personal between us as this discussion has been.

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby ScaleCraft » Sun Dec 26, 2021 7:58 pm

So this started out with a photo of a crumbled pair of couplers.

I followed up with a comment on PRC lack of QC, mentioned plastics.

Here in the good old, we sort of got a handle on Zamac Rot by the mid-60's. But then Sol Kramer started LikeLike in the PRC and we saw it start all over again. I know what his company was (Sanda Kahn), and I know who bought them out....and the issues with THAT company that have continued.


If you just remember there is no QC in China, you will be pleasantly surprised when you have no issues.

The plastic regrind is basically a plastic version of Zamac Rot. Takes a while to show up, results are fatal, can't tell there is an issue until the parts fail.

As far as mounting pads....oh, my. In LS (#1) we have so many non-standard things...but when TWO manufacturers bow to consumer demand and include KD mounting pads on the underside of the floor.....and you cannot mount on one and clear truck wheels and axles, the other, the holes for the screws have no basis in the reality of a KD box.
Dave....gone by invitation

E7
Posts: 8404
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 1:35 am

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby E7 » Sun Dec 26, 2021 9:57 pm

sarge wrote:I assume you don't use their mounting system simply because you don't use their coupler with its equally stupid whisker, or Weaver's or the old Monarch or any of the choices using magnetic uncoupling. Not hard to have no personal problem with it when you don't use it.


I don't own ANY Atlas freight cars, so by default, I don't deal with their mounting system. That said, my choice of coupler IS magnetic....Protocraft.

sarge wrote:Its my experience Atlas is pretty immune to direct individual customer input, indeed finding it an annoyance. They aren't alone but, because they tout themselves a scale model railroad company, its been a bit of a letdown when they repeatedly "do what they want" such as your bête noir, the F-unit headlight, or making roadswitchers with twin-motor drives, the oversized RS-3, the too-narrow RS-1 cab and steel rebuild USRA car, the fantasy handrails on the RSD-15, and on and on. Its not an exception, its not even a trend. Its a tradition.


I don't know about most the stuff in the above paragraph, but in the case of the F unit headlight, the blame (maybe) goes to the person/persons that conjured up the old Roco F9. If you break out your back issues of "O Scale News 48/ft", there is an article about the late Pate Mucci and his designer, Mal Harvey, who predeceased Pat. It is in regard to the P&D Hobby Shop F unit, which was ultimately to become Atlas' F unit. Mr. Harvey designed of the project to be "compatible with the old Roco F9's. Thus the P&D F's received the erroneous Roco F9 vertical (single or upper) headlight. The reason I say "maybe" up above is the orientation of the headlight on Lionel F's has been vertical from the git go. Did Roco copy the headlight from Lionel? Beats me!

Just a footnote: I am not aware of any correct plastic F unit in O scale.

sarge wrote: Direct input unwelcome as it is (and a thread on a forum is certainly a legitimate form of input), the other alternative as you say is to "not buy". Forums then become a venue to discuss such things and, perhaps more importantly, increase awareness in the marketplace so others can make their decision to buy or not based on what might be learned during that discussion. That being the case, one person merely being quiet and individually not buying a product means nothing in sales figures. Consumer power is only effective when it is collective; honest and civil discussion, awareness, and education are the hallmarks of collective market opinion.

When freightcars are crossing the $100 a pop mark, and plastic RTR locos are headed north of a grand, its just as cost effective to embrace fidelity, performance, and compatibility as it is to cavalierly ignore them. Indeed, embracing those things can lead to a sales improvement in the scale model railway marketplace in O, if HO and N are any indication. So, if we collectively discuss and speak, something might improve (I'm not holding my breath, but there would then be a chance). We silently endure (thereby tacitly accepting) the same turds polished with new paint schemes and new pricepoints, the answer to any progress is an automatic "no".


I think the biggest factor working against us is that the three rail contingent is always going to make us 2nd class citizens in the buying arena to the extent that it doesn't matter what we do or don't buy. That doesn't mean I'll cease my one man war, not that it really matters.

Rich

edited to restore a quote
Last edited by E7 on Fri Jan 07, 2022 9:32 pm, edited 1 time in total.


Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 69 guests