Postby sarge » Tue Dec 28, 2021 3:36 pm
Some thoughts:
They are machines being used in an industry. From Day 1 there will be changes, modification, liberties taken as damage repaired, faded paint, shifted colours. What there won't be is an interest in maintaining these things in showroom condition for our enjoyment.
That said, if you're modelling something and you are being neurotic about it, dates of your source photos matter, and it probably won't at all look like it did new. You get to decide if you care.
Drawings? I'll completely disagree with the notion they will be definitive. The only time you'll up your chances is if you have and use the entire book of detail drawings and the builder actually documented the production mods (of which there will be many). Then the result can only be a model in as-built condition. What everyone swears by is the "general arrangement", sometimes known as an erection drawing. All they need to accurately reflect are the labelling of each component to either its detail drawing or the assembly drawing that is itself keyed with the detail drawings in the book. Accuracy of overall form isn't required and often isn't there. Alco general arrangement drawings were pretty notorious and EMD's in the forties and fifties were barely better than sketches. Unless you have the entire several hundred pages of a manufacturer's set for a particular locomotive, you can't call it definitive and, if you do have them and actually are so neurotic you've used them, you're still making it "as-built".
Photos are more definitive than drawings, but builder photos still only show the one polished example as built. If they were definitive, we'd be arguing which side of a steam locomotive model gets the white tires and edging on the running boards, and we'd be modelling the Eddystone plant or Alco's complex in Schenectady or the pickup line at LaGrange, not a railroad.
I'm for the dated in-service photo as the breaker of stalemates. Dated photos tell you what it looked like in the timeperiod you care about. Alco drawings of a Hudson, for example, will be nearly useless if I'm serious about modelling the NYC in 1950. Its probably on its fourth tender by then, the check has been moved to the top of the boiler from the side, the sandbox exchanged for something larger and shop-hammered so matching no drawing at all, then moved to a new position to make room for the checkvalve. The booster is pulled, a new casting for the trailer, &c &c. Thats why we can always find exceptions to anything that starts, "All the GP-whatevers had <insert identifiable feature here>".
Exceptions, though, are exceptions. Unless you're modelling that particular unique locomotive or whatever, you're probably better off avoiding exceptions and modelling the typical appearance of that period if the overall presentation of your layout is "1972 Lehigh Valley in Geneva" or whatever. If you are modelling that particular piece of equipment, though, photos hold more definitive wisdom as to its appearance than drawings.
That should start the discussion off in a new direction! GRIN!