The Tridaily Doorstop -- Bob's Mexicano Electric
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13676
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #9 Alexander NYC 4-4-0
Yes. I remember somebody calling it that:

- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42229
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #9 Alexander NYC 4-4-0
.
Last edited by Rufus T. Firefly on Tue Apr 26, 2022 5:09 pm, edited 1 time in total.
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #9 Alexander NYC 4-4-0
Bob pointed out that the tender has rivets, implying that the original model did not. He is correct, as this tender from a similar model, not owned by me, shows:

Not surprisingly, this is a tender drive locomotive:

The Pittman open-frame PM motor is not original. Like most (or all?) pre-war models, these came with a wound-field motor.
Here is an underside shot of engine and tender:

That massive chassis frame around the drivers is not likely to be original. Here is a similar shot from the other model:

I don't know Jerry White's work well enough to know whether this has his fingerprints on the NYC model or not. It does run well though. I will look to see if I have any video of it on the layout.
Jim

Not surprisingly, this is a tender drive locomotive:
The Pittman open-frame PM motor is not original. Like most (or all?) pre-war models, these came with a wound-field motor.
Here is an underside shot of engine and tender:
That massive chassis frame around the drivers is not likely to be original. Here is a similar shot from the other model:

I don't know Jerry White's work well enough to know whether this has his fingerprints on the NYC model or not. It does run well though. I will look to see if I have any video of it on the layout.
Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #9 Alexander NYC 4-4-0
Boy, flipping back and forth between those two chassis shots, not a lot is the same. Drawbar mount, firebox/ashpan, cylinders totally different, of course the frame, lead truck, lack of dummy Stephenson's on one, different crosshead supports. Almost not an Alexander, especially with rivetted tender. Odd. Nice, but odd.
Dave....gone by invitation
- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42229
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #9 Alexander NYC 4-4-0
.
Last edited by Rufus T. Firefly on Tue Apr 26, 2022 5:09 pm, edited 1 time in total.
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #9 Alexander NYC 4-4-0
It is nice to see smaller steam, yet bigger than Thomas 0-4-0's!
I would really like to see some more shots of the unmolested one. The nice NYC appears to be basically all new, can't tell on boiler shape as I have no comparison photos, but the small bit of the unmolested cab shows what I would expect, sand cast bronze. The NYC appears to be straight, smooth, sharp corners, like build up.
There must have been prototype concerns for builder to machine out a chunk of something solid for his new chassis, instead of using the see-through framework. Even the main rod details have been removed.
One of those things you wake up in the middle of the night and say "Huh?"
I would really like to see some more shots of the unmolested one. The nice NYC appears to be basically all new, can't tell on boiler shape as I have no comparison photos, but the small bit of the unmolested cab shows what I would expect, sand cast bronze. The NYC appears to be straight, smooth, sharp corners, like build up.
There must have been prototype concerns for builder to machine out a chunk of something solid for his new chassis, instead of using the see-through framework. Even the main rod details have been removed.
One of those things you wake up in the middle of the night and say "Huh?"
Dave....gone by invitation
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #9 Alexander NYC 4-4-0
ScaleCraft wrote:It is nice to see smaller steam, yet bigger than Thomas 0-4-0's!
I would really like to see some more shots of the unmolested one. The nice NYC appears to be basically all new, can't tell on boiler shape as I have no comparison photos, but the small bit of the unmolested cab shows what I would expect, sand cast bronze. The NYC appears to be straight, smooth, sharp corners, like build up.
There must have been prototype concerns for builder to machine out a chunk of something solid for his new chassis, instead of using the see-through framework. Even the main rod details have been removed.
One of those things you wake up in the middle of the night and say "Huh?"
A little research and speculation.
Mayhaps Mister Alexander made multiple versions of the 4-4-0. Here is an alleged NYC 4-4-0 by Alexander. Let's say, under speculation mode, for early units, bronze boilers and cabs for weight...later, built up brass boilers and cabs, no weight, design that big block chassis.

Of course, without and clarification as to WHAT he is showing, here is Ed holding a 4-4-0:

Dave....gone by invitation
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13676
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #9 Alexander NYC 4-4-0
Lobaugh, mostly:

- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #9 Alexander NYC 4-4-0
Nice model, Bob. I had one of the Lobaughs once, but a friend valued it more as a collectible than I did as an operating model, so it went to him.
I appreciate Dave's comments and the time he spent to study the photos I posted carefully. The NYC 4-4-0 was sold to me a long time ago as an Alexander. I never questioned it as, at a quick glance, it looked about right. Now I am beginning to question how much, if any, of the NYC 4-4-O is Alexander. Here are some photos to make things easier to compare. First, the model as shown in the 1937 AMRACO catalog:

Now, the NYC version (sorry, no direct side photo in hand):

Next, the other known model (sorry, no shot of the engineer's side):

Here is a photo of a magazine ad showing the fireman's side and indicating that boiler is cast and the prototype is M&StL:

Note as an aside that Alexander cataloged two 4-4-0s in 1937. The other was listed as an "old timey" PRR "P" (D13c):

I have never seen one that I know of.
Jim
I appreciate Dave's comments and the time he spent to study the photos I posted carefully. The NYC 4-4-0 was sold to me a long time ago as an Alexander. I never questioned it as, at a quick glance, it looked about right. Now I am beginning to question how much, if any, of the NYC 4-4-O is Alexander. Here are some photos to make things easier to compare. First, the model as shown in the 1937 AMRACO catalog:
Now, the NYC version (sorry, no direct side photo in hand):

Next, the other known model (sorry, no shot of the engineer's side):

Here is a photo of a magazine ad showing the fireman's side and indicating that boiler is cast and the prototype is M&StL:

Note as an aside that Alexander cataloged two 4-4-0s in 1937. The other was listed as an "old timey" PRR "P" (D13c):

I have never seen one that I know of.
Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #9 Alexander NYC 4-4-0
Gets worse, doesn't it? Domes are different, cowcatcher different, taper of the boiler at bell LOOKS to be WAY off, stack and headlight different, length of the side sheets for coal totally different in length, length of pilot beam from smokebox front, firebox side sheets, looks like smokebox support rods, original cab is cast, your NYC version looks thinner brass sheet...add to the HUGE differences in chassis, probably a Jim Fitzhugh model from 1939.
Dave....gone by invitation
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13676
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #9 Alexander NYC 4-4-0
"Probably" is a strong word to use without some slight evidence. There are quite a few modelers capable of most of that work. I would have to study that tender a bit more closely - Rod Miller has Gerry's rivet machine, and that may be the absolute best rivet embosser anywhere.
My rivets get done one at a time, and I often miss a beat or get a raised area around an end rivet. I see none of that on the tender above.
My rivets get done one at a time, and I often miss a beat or get a raised area around an end rivet. I see none of that on the tender above.
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #9 Alexander NYC 4-4-0
bob turner wrote:"Probably" is a strong word to use without some slight evidence. There are quite a few modelers capable of most of that work. I would have to study that tender a bit more closely - Rod Miller has Gerry's rivet machine, and that may be the absolute best rivet embosser anywhere.
My rivets get done one at a time, and I often miss a beat or get a raised area around an end rivet. I see none of that on the tender above.
*snicker*.
I HOPE you're referring to my "probably Jim Fitzhugh" comment.
You know, the guy born on Oklahoma....moved to an island in the Okefenokee Swamp. Had to transport all supplies in and product out by an airboat or a fan boat, plane boat, swamp boat, bayou boat, you know.
Inducted into the RMR Hall of Shame?
But maybe it's Tyson McGillicudy out of West Skookum, Virginia.
Dave....gone by invitation
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
The Tridaily Doorstop -- #10 Scale-Craft SFRD (Santa Fe) Reefer
#10 -- Scale-Craft SFRD (Santa Fe) Reefer
This Scale-Craft reefer is one of the first doorstop freight cars I ever bought:


This was May of 2012, and my interest in old models had just started. My records indicate I paid $4.13 plus $10 shipping for this reefer. My notes in the record state, "maybe the best deal ever". I don't know about that, but I'd take them all day at that price now, if they were in the same condition.
This Scale-Craft reefer is one of the first doorstop freight cars I ever bought:
This was May of 2012, and my interest in old models had just started. My records indicate I paid $4.13 plus $10 shipping for this reefer. My notes in the record state, "maybe the best deal ever". I don't know about that, but I'd take them all day at that price now, if they were in the same condition.
The link below any photo will display the image full size
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #10 Scale-Craft SFRD (Santa Fe) Reefer
Don't tell Martin! He'll lump you in with me on my "never spent more than ten bucks" category!
Dave....gone by invitation
-
Dennis Holler
- Posts: 474
- Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2010 8:31 pm
Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #10 Scale-Craft SFRD (Santa Fe) Reefer
Ha, That same car was also one of my first doorstop car purchases... I think my very first one was Thomas single dome tank. Your's maybe postwar or the later Thomas ownership with that slogan on the side as I presume the pre 1940 cars did not include the slogan.... Then again, looking at your photo's, your car seems to have the earlier frame so who knows lol. I have noticed the later frame is a fraction wider and will not actually fit the early built up cars.

And a WP I got at the same time, both decently built I think at least decent enough for me lol.

I should have shopped out that middle rail lmao.

You def for the most part can't get away with tunning box stock scalecraft cars and trucks on three rail track with the stock thruck mounting pins that came with the cars lmao

And a WP I got at the same time, both decently built I think at least decent enough for me lol.

I should have shopped out that middle rail lmao.

You def for the most part can't get away with tunning box stock scalecraft cars and trucks on three rail track with the stock thruck mounting pins that came with the cars lmao
Doorstop Rookie
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Carey Williams and 36 guests