webenda wrote:Second, debt is a much cheaper form of financing than equity. It starts with the fact that equity is riskier than debt. Much of the equity is tied up in stocks, which may or may not appreciate. Due to risks in equity, debt is usually a more efficient source of funding.
Say what? As someone who did thirty-seven years in corporate finance I can assure you that debt is far riskier than equity.
When a corporation is formed it typically sells shares to raise the initial cash required for its formation and to purchase the plant/equipment it requires to start operating. Once those shares have passed into the hands of the shareholder and the corporation has its cash it could give a hoot what the share price is. That risk has passed entirely to the shareholder. Share prices go up and down...that has little to no impact on the corporation (perhaps only if it decides it wants to sell additional shares at a later date, and even then the offer price is rarely based on current or historical pricing). Remember, in the pecking order of creditors the shareholder is always at or near the bottom...he/she has virtually no claim on the assets of the corporation, yet the value of
his/her investment hinges on the financial performance of the company as reflected in this highly speculative thing called the share-price.
Now, a corporation might decide it will pay dividends to the shareholders, and those dividends are obligations of the company. They are typically paid out of the corporation's operating profits. However, the corporation sets the dividends, so it may decide it wants to reinvest its profits in the business, doing away with the payment of dividends. Unless you are a major shareholder you have virtually no say in the day-to-day operation of the company, the payment of dividends, the issue of stock, etc.
Debt on the other hand can be crushing. When one buys a home one typically borrows money via a mortgage. In the mortgage agreement there is usually language along the lines of "if the mortgagee (homeowner) for any reason hasn't made a scheduled payment within 45 days of the due date, the debt agreement is null and void and the mortgagee must immediately pay the balance of the loan, plus all accrued interest and penalties". While most banks will provide time extensions for the mortgagee to make good, technically the loan is in default and open to foreclosure.
Similarly, corporate debt agreements carry covenants, i.e. rules by which the company must operate for the bank to continue with the financing arrangement. These are set up for the bank's protection. For instance, a covenant might require the corporation's total debt balance to not exceed five times its net income before taxes. If at any reporting date that condition is found to exist the bank can call the loan, withdraw the credit line, or whatever the arrangement might entail. Investment banks are very unforgiving creatures...a corporation dares not run afoul of its debt covenants.
I do agree that debt is a terrifically misunderstood corporate attribute. It is the lifeblood of the corporation. It is something that you manage. At the same time it is not an 'asset'...it is a huge obligation that can hang around the corporate neck like an anchor. The hope is that the profits you earn exceed the service on the debt. If it does you're good, if not you're humped. Almost all major corporations have it, typically in massive quantities. The concept of paying it back is virtually unheard of....when it comes due you simply refinance it (or you file for bankruptcy and wipe out the bank/bond-holders). The room for error is razor-thin.