The Tridaily Doorstop -- Bob's Mexicano Electric

Discuss All Facets of 2-Rail, 1/48 Scale, Model Railroading
User avatar
R.K. Maroon
Posts: 3141
Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #15 Scale Model Railways NYC Caboose

Postby R.K. Maroon » Mon Mar 28, 2022 12:55 am

ScaleCraft wrote:ScaleCraft...cast frame, integral open coupler pockets, brass crossbar, right?


Yes, good catch. This was an error of omission. The Scale-Craft NYC caboose indeed has a similar frame, but I am pretty sure it's not the same as the one on the model shown above. The cabooses are at the shop but I will check tomorrow.

In the meantime, here is a catalog listing for the SMR NYC caboose:

Image

Three things here. First, I sure wish that was a better photo. If I find one in a different catalog or magazine ad I will post.
Second, the listing does not mention a cast frame, but SMR is known to have used cast frames for their freight cars. Maybe not 100% (I don't know), but a lot. Third, note the other cabooses listed. Sure wish there were photos so we would know what they looked like (*sigh*). There was not a lot of variety of cabooses offered before the war. All the NYC and PRR cabooses you could want, but not for many other railroads. Offerings of C&NW, B&O, and GN cabooses is thus notable. I might have the GN. I will post that here sometime soon.

Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #15 Scale Model Railways NYC Caboose

Postby sarge » Mon Mar 28, 2022 6:19 am

I have to be the anvil on this one. Its a lovely car, but I have my doubts.

Pardon this next bit, please, but is your identification based solely on the catalogue photo and the fact it is different in technique from Walthers, SC, &c?

Unless there is more evidence, I'm thinking scratchbuilt. The catalogue photo gives little evidence as to construction method. It's a popular scratchbuilding or kitmingling subject; Lord knows I've built several myself, still have this B&A version I built whilst sitting in the Sinai.

Image

What causes me to ask? Simply this tiny piece of evidence:

These sides are hand-ruled and hand-scribed:

Image

Then, looking at the construction, it really is pretty much stick-built. For example everything under the roofwalks, the endgrabs, railings, and ladderwork. It really talks to me as a modeller's one-off for all the love of the art I see there.

Now, if there is something that points to SMR definitively that we haven't heard, my apologies. These are not my area of expertise, and they are yours. Even if it was an SMR (or anyone else') kit, there is a lot of the builder talking to me in that piece.

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #15 Scale Model Railways NYC Caboose

Postby ScaleCraft » Mon Mar 28, 2022 12:14 pm

sarge wrote:I have to be the anvil on this one. Its a lovely car, but I have my doubts.



Then, looking at the construction, it really is pretty much stick-built. For example everything under the roofwalks, the endgrabs, railings, and ladderwork. It really talks to me as a modeller's one-off for all the love of the art I see there.

Now, if there is something that points to SMR definitively that we haven't heard, my apologies. These are not my area of expertise, and they are yours. Even if it was an SMR (or anyone else') kit, there is a lot of the builder talking to me in that piece.


True enough, as far as it goes. I had noticed the hand scribed (or cut) sides right off.
But Jimmy describes early on the frame and coupler pockets as being indicative of SMR.
I don't know...I have a bunch of stuff here, and nothing in any pile we positively identified as SMR to compare.
I have a couple of cabeese I thought were identified as SMR.....but PO had 3-railed them.....and neither has the frames (couplers attached to end platforms, Lionel couplers screwed directly to floor). Done long enough ago (Edith, '53) that doesn't even have Talgo mounts, rather fixed Thomas knuckles.
Dave....gone by invitation

User avatar
Rufus T. Firefly
Posts: 42237
Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
Location: To be Determined

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #15 Scale Model Railways NYC Caboose

Postby Rufus T. Firefly » Mon Mar 28, 2022 1:29 pm

.
Last edited by Rufus T. Firefly on Tue Apr 26, 2022 5:13 pm, edited 1 time in total.
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #15 Scale Model Railways NYC Caboose

Postby ScaleCraft » Mon Mar 28, 2022 1:54 pm

Earlier than 39. Look at all the wood side cars by the major (and minor) sellers. My SC reefers for one.
And the one being discussed is obviously hand-done.....you can see where he missed.
Westbrook?

Someone told me once, and no citations to prove it, that commercial wasn't scribed. That's personal use. Commercial (so they told me) was rollers with knife edges...rolled the sides through and voila! (as opposed to the moronic internet version of WaLa!)
Dave....gone by invitation

User avatar
Rufus T. Firefly
Posts: 42237
Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
Location: To be Determined

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #15 Scale Model Railways NYC Caboose

Postby Rufus T. Firefly » Mon Mar 28, 2022 4:51 pm

.
Last edited by Rufus T. Firefly on Tue Apr 26, 2022 5:13 pm, edited 1 time in total.
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #15 Scale Model Railways NYC Caboose

Postby ScaleCraft » Mon Mar 28, 2022 6:42 pm

Rufus T. Firefly wrote:
ScaleCraft wrote:Earlier than 39. Look at all the wood side cars by the major (and minor) sellers. My SC reefers for one.
And the one being discussed is obviously hand-done.....you can see where he missed.


And, so the ones included in the kit I have are later and also obviously hand done, so hand done may or not indicate scratch. The ones in this kit are not very good either; probably keep the drawings and instructions, the roof section is ok, and toss the rest in the can.

And I guess when I state scribed, what I really mean is milled.

Rail Craft caboose I'm working on now - that's 1/16" thick 3-ply play wood with a poplar exterior that's scribed but as I recall Ed Bommer stated that that was not scribed siding but rather imprinted or pressed.

Yup. Pressed. Rollers and blades of a sort.
On your unit with poor scribing, flip the sides over, re-do the blank sides, install them on opposite sides.
Dave....gone by invitation

User avatar
R.K. Maroon
Posts: 3141
Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #15 Scale Model Railways NYC Caboose

Postby R.K. Maroon » Mon Mar 28, 2022 11:03 pm

Sarge's comments regarding the possibility of that the "Scale Model Railways" caboose is actually a scratch-built made me take a second look. Here is the view from the rear:

Image

The cupola is sheet metal. Note the presence of window sashes:

Image

The windows look die-cut and pressed to me, and the presence of a crisply cast frame is, in my opinion, pretty strong evidence that this is a kit car. The box this came in was labeled Scale Model Railways, which by itself is not any proof. However, I acquired this caboose with four other models, all of them accurately labeled, with two of them also SMR products. Anything is possible, of course, so until another example is found then it's not fully settled. For now, however, I plan to keep the SMR label on the box.

By the way, here is the underside of a Scale-Craft NYC caboose:

Image

It is similar in many respects, but a little bit longer than the frame on the SMR caboose.
The link below any photo will display the image full size

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #15 Scale Model Railways NYC Caboose

Postby ScaleCraft » Tue Mar 29, 2022 1:39 am

Now you did it. I'm gonna have to dig out my SC cabeese to see if they have two piece floors.
That stamped, brass cupola wrapper sure looks familiar. A-N? One version of Walthers?
Dave....gone by invitation

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #15 Scale Model Railways NYC Caboose

Postby sarge » Tue Mar 29, 2022 6:28 am

Walthers had a stamped brass cupola wrapper; one of those bits I remember clearly.

I freely admit buying them cheap at the meets for the cast ends and the windows which were the high point of that kit. The Walthers sides were ply that had the grooves rolled, often so poorly they could only be characterised as barely a suggestion. They became a template for replacement sides of modern (at the time, anyway) scribed material, tarted up with those nice window castings and the end castings. The step-boxes were awful from a scale/neurotic standpoint, so new would be made.

I'm still going to hold out that the evidence is flimsy that car is a kit, what with all the handwork and stick by stick assembly, that or if it is a kit its a case where the builder is quite possibly more loudly expressed than the manufacturer. Just looking at the way someone hand-shaved out the kick panels in the doors for example, makes me think the cupola is an oddity, not irrefutable evidence of a kit.

That second case does beg a question about the exercise. At what point does a kit lose its identity and become a scratchbuild? Does my use of the end and window castings from a Walthers kit (and keeping the cavernous box) make it a Walthers car or a scratchbuild?

Putting a question mark on a note and putting it in the box until another pops out the woodwork for comparison and confirmation is the wise thing to do (as we've seen with All Nation SW1s. Right, Jim? GRIN!) A comparison of a second, especially one unbuilt, will not only confirm the origin of this one (one way or the other) but tell you even more about the builder.

Herein lie the pitfalls in O scale archeology, for we are famous throughout our history for precisely this sort of thing. I'm sure I'll be a contributor to this muddying of the waters for future historians by kitmingling, bashing, using kits as parts sources for many different builds, just as so many others have made ferreting out the manufacturing history so difficult. We can't just build it from the box and indeed we might dump out the box only for a couple bits in this project and a few bobs in that.

Of course, that points to the fact that manufacturing history is only one facet of the history of the scale. The attraction of O to the craftsman and the builder adds a complication (and a richness) far beyond the array of models as they appeared on the hobbyshop shelf.
Last edited by sarge on Tue Mar 29, 2022 4:50 pm, edited 3 times in total.

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #15 Scale Model Railways NYC Caboose

Postby sarge » Tue Mar 29, 2022 6:44 am

I'm now going to throw out an interesting thought.

Let us assume for the moment this is indeed an SMR kit. The similarities to the Walthers car are interesting, such as plywood sides that a builder apparently thought needed re-scribed by hand, the brass fold-up cupola...

The weak points are the windows themselves and the fiddlyness of the ends causing the builder to do things like shave the kick-panels of the doors out (or, almost inconceivably, the manufacturer, making for a very complex manufacturing process)

One wonders about the possibility Walthers actually updated SMR's kit after the war, addressing the weakpoints with those lovely castings that were their solution to manufacturability in so many instances, and the postwar Walthers kit is at least the offspring of the SMR if not an improved version sold under the Walthers label, something else they were known for.

User avatar
Rufus T. Firefly
Posts: 42237
Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
Location: To be Determined

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop -- #15 Scale Model Railways NYC Caboose

Postby Rufus T. Firefly » Tue Mar 29, 2022 8:07 am

.
Last edited by Rufus T. Firefly on Tue Apr 26, 2022 5:13 pm, edited 1 time in total.
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.

User avatar
R.K. Maroon
Posts: 3141
Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop #16 -- Alexander New Haven EY-3 Boxcab Electric

Postby R.K. Maroon » Tue Mar 29, 2022 11:29 pm

#16 -- Alexander New Haven EY-3 Boxcab Electric

This was an early find. At that time, I tended to jump at the first model I saw if it was of interest, in part from newbie enthusiasm but also because I had no idea just how rare any of these models were. Not surprisingly, I wound up paying too much for some models. Fortunately for me, we were still in a recession and that schmoe that writes about doorstops for OST hadn't started yet, so prices were more reasonable. As such, my rookie mistakes weren't too costly and I did occasionally wind up with some nice models. This Alexander boxcar electric is one of them:

Image

Image

As best I can tell, it's all original. The paint needs some restoration but fortunately not in the area around the hand lettering. Paint touch up is a challenge though. Color matching any model is often problematic, but then there is the issue of prepping the surface where the paint is missing and feathering the boundary between the old paint and the new. Currently beyond my pay grade.

Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size

User avatar
De Bruin
Posts: 992
Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2017 8:24 pm

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop #16 -- Alexander New Haven EY-3 Boxcab Electric

Postby De Bruin » Wed Mar 30, 2022 12:44 am

Love these, in your experience since getting this bug, do you consider them rare? I ask because the truck and car body on their own are quite good and wonder if you've ever seen them float by in a component, kit or otherwise un-built state. Reminds me of the GE "Pelicans" on the CMStP&P.

Fixing the paint is problematic but I think could be done if the remainder finish isn't chipping or sheathing off, might be looking at your photo. Also appears the green finish coat was applied on the entire model(pants included) with no primer underneath, Yikes.

On a different note I recall reading the prototypes served as switchers at Cedar Hill and possibly the yard and floats at Bay Ridge and Hunters Point, but not for very long.
Political Consultant- Tap into the hidden powers of your public office, insure your future is jail free, well funded. Visit shock and awe upon your adversaries, dominate the media, thrill your followers. contact morbo@happydaysrhereagain.com

User avatar
Rufus T. Firefly
Posts: 42237
Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
Location: To be Determined

Re: The Tridaily Doorstop #16 -- Alexander New Haven EY-3 Boxcab Electric

Postby Rufus T. Firefly » Wed Mar 30, 2022 1:01 pm

.
Last edited by Rufus T. Firefly on Tue Apr 26, 2022 5:13 pm, edited 1 time in total.
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.


Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: up148 and 51 guests