Drifting along; RTR quality, Couplers, EMD cabs...

Discuss All Facets of 2-Rail, 1/48 Scale, Model Railroading
E7
Posts: 8404
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 1:35 am

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby E7 » Tue Dec 28, 2021 9:10 am

ScaleCraft wrote:AFAIK Tenshodo stuff went plastic later, same tooling? The one I picked up at the store to look at was brass.

Maybe splicing an Erie-built nose on would help.


The only thing that would help one of those (I had one once) is a good whack or two with a sledge hammer. Beautiful workmanship and paint, but about a minus 5 on a 1 to 10 accuracy scale. Had a headlight bulb that protruded out of the nose. Looked very much like a modern light bulb. A crown.....NOT! :lol:

up148
Posts: 4801
Joined: Sat Nov 01, 2008 11:52 am

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby up148 » Tue Dec 28, 2021 9:37 am

sarge wrote:Butch, I believe there was a change very late in the game, E7 and E8 slanted, E9 vertical, Fs from FT-F7 slanted, F9 vertical. Since EMD liked to change up the game at times out of synch with model changes, the change might not precisely coincide with the model change-up from E8/F7 to E9/F9.

The Roco F9 I believe got it right, at least for the late ones, and the error happened with the P&D ones as the Roco shell was used as the starting point to backdate the range to include F7 and F3.



Makes a lot of sense. Best explanation I've heard.

E7
Posts: 8404
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 1:35 am

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby E7 » Tue Dec 28, 2021 10:18 am

sarge wrote:Rich, the answer to "why" your conundrum exists might lie in what I believe is good memory. I seem to remember a nuance of the F9 and E9 was a change to a vertical face in the headlight shroud from slanted in the earlier units. An E9 is shown here showing that, but I couldn't immediately find a definitive photo of an F9 side on to match.

Image

There is a pretty unadulterated set of Rio Grande F9s at the the Colorado Museum; perhaps Erik is nearby and could check?

Given that was so and the F9 and E9 did change from slant to vertical at least at some point in production, the Roco shell actually got it right. Then of course the P&D project (carrying it back from the Roco shell) missed that important nuance.


I've long had my suspicions that the 9 series (or at least some of them) were vertical. The first and biggest "problem" is there weren't a lot of roads that had them, especially the F9's. An offshoot of that is there don't seem to be a lot of pictures, but the one of the E9 above is a dandy!

I am 99% sure the late (I think they were retired) NS corporate F9's were styled as such. They were older units brought up to F9 specs, and their light surrounds always looked vertical to me.

It would be interesting to hear the EMD logic for the change if it was anything more than styling.

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby ScaleCraft » Tue Dec 28, 2021 12:32 pm

There is a problem that can occur when we look at restored examples 60+ years after build date.
Who knows what has occurred?

I have a photo of a DC3 with one wing a much shorter DC2.
Happens.

F and E units....were they ever in a wreck? Check your LocoFax.
Nose replaced? Headlight reworked?

I have an era photo of an NP F unit with those double SP type light in bottom headlight position....and never seen another photo like it.

Here is an E9. If I recall, prime movers are gone replaced by one prime mover, but that's internal:

https://www.up.com/cs/groups/public/@up ... iner_m.jpg

Now what? Manufacturer going to make one like that?
Dave....gone by invitation

E7
Posts: 8404
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 1:35 am

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby E7 » Tue Dec 28, 2021 1:45 pm

Dave, I don't disagree with anything you say, but there is an answer to that, and it is Builders photos.

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby ScaleCraft » Tue Dec 28, 2021 2:35 pm

E7 wrote:Dave, I don't disagree with anything you say, but there is an answer to that, and it is Builders photos.

Or drawings, and we've covered erroneous drawings at least twice in this thread.

Builder's Photos usually do not show the detail of the areas of our concerns.

Dig up your EMD Builder's Photo 90 degree side view nose and headlight of an E9 and compare! Ain't one....have to go by drawings....and see above.

There was a story going around 20+ years ago about an east coast importer of multiple scales and gauges....whose Director of Product Development was (in)famous for sneaking into roped off museum areas for photos and measurements (probably thought they'd have to pay royalties if they asked permission)....and photographed, measured, took down data on a BL2 sitting behind a museum. Didn't ask questions...oh, no.
Developed, produced and sold.

Being a museum piece, said museum had the Blombergs out for overhaul, loco was sitting on a spare set of AAR trucks. Guess how the loco was produced.
Dave....gone by invitation

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby sarge » Tue Dec 28, 2021 3:36 pm

Some thoughts:

They are machines being used in an industry. From Day 1 there will be changes, modification, liberties taken as damage repaired, faded paint, shifted colours. What there won't be is an interest in maintaining these things in showroom condition for our enjoyment.

That said, if you're modelling something and you are being neurotic about it, dates of your source photos matter, and it probably won't at all look like it did new. You get to decide if you care.

Drawings? I'll completely disagree with the notion they will be definitive. The only time you'll up your chances is if you have and use the entire book of detail drawings and the builder actually documented the production mods (of which there will be many). Then the result can only be a model in as-built condition. What everyone swears by is the "general arrangement", sometimes known as an erection drawing. All they need to accurately reflect are the labelling of each component to either its detail drawing or the assembly drawing that is itself keyed with the detail drawings in the book. Accuracy of overall form isn't required and often isn't there. Alco general arrangement drawings were pretty notorious and EMD's in the forties and fifties were barely better than sketches. Unless you have the entire several hundred pages of a manufacturer's set for a particular locomotive, you can't call it definitive and, if you do have them and actually are so neurotic you've used them, you're still making it "as-built".

Photos are more definitive than drawings, but builder photos still only show the one polished example as built. If they were definitive, we'd be arguing which side of a steam locomotive model gets the white tires and edging on the running boards, and we'd be modelling the Eddystone plant or Alco's complex in Schenectady or the pickup line at LaGrange, not a railroad.

I'm for the dated in-service photo as the breaker of stalemates. Dated photos tell you what it looked like in the timeperiod you care about. Alco drawings of a Hudson, for example, will be nearly useless if I'm serious about modelling the NYC in 1950. Its probably on its fourth tender by then, the check has been moved to the top of the boiler from the side, the sandbox exchanged for something larger and shop-hammered so matching no drawing at all, then moved to a new position to make room for the checkvalve. The booster is pulled, a new casting for the trailer, &c &c. Thats why we can always find exceptions to anything that starts, "All the GP-whatevers had <insert identifiable feature here>".

Exceptions, though, are exceptions. Unless you're modelling that particular unique locomotive or whatever, you're probably better off avoiding exceptions and modelling the typical appearance of that period if the overall presentation of your layout is "1972 Lehigh Valley in Geneva" or whatever. If you are modelling that particular piece of equipment, though, photos hold more definitive wisdom as to its appearance than drawings.

That should start the discussion off in a new direction! GRIN!

E7
Posts: 8404
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 1:35 am

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby E7 » Tue Dec 28, 2021 4:43 pm

The good news for me is, that of the Roads I LOOSELY follow, only the B&O HAD E9'S AND NONE of them had F9's. From what info I could find, a new "tight fitting" style headlamp (like the one in Dave's Pic). was one of the upgrades of the "9" series. Didn't see anywhere if that change required the sheet metal change from tilted to vertical, but I'm guessing that was the case!

Are we having fun yet? :lol: :lol: :lol:
'

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby ScaleCraft » Tue Dec 28, 2021 6:49 pm

I was always amazed that the UP Heritage fleet would have something in use so...modified.

NO front door, roof strobe, ditch lights, (not sure when they went to strobe, but I've got photos without) single headlight? Here's one at Perris with two. Look at the upper headlight angle:

http://www.mfb-basel.ch/herbertangliker ... t-2016.jpg

"Heritage" to me means something different than what UP portrays. Houses? Can't do anything to them. Autos? Man, you'll gets scowls if you change wheels....or hubcaps....or headlights...or interior.
Note only the Heritage unit seems to have a creased pilot.
UP, 1995:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/ ... 041%29.jpg

As far as drawings, I have so many F unit photos of np stuff....handrails on roof, nose, and without...single and multiple headlights, antennas and not, nose lift rings and not, three portholes and two.

Now we're to Abilene in March 25, 1954 at 2:45 PM.
Dave....gone by invitation

E7
Posts: 8404
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 1:35 am

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby E7 » Thu Dec 30, 2021 12:56 pm

ScaleCraft wrote:Here is an E9. If I recall, prime movers are gone replaced by one prime mover, but that's internal:

https://www.up.com/cs/groups/public/@up ... iner_m.jpg

Now what? Manufacturer going to make one like that?


Actually EMD did. That is built to E9 specs. No nose door and grabs, and new style vertical headlight. The headlight bulbs can be replaced from the outside. (Thanks to Sarge for that bit of info.)

Rich

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby ScaleCraft » Thu Dec 30, 2021 1:17 pm

E7 wrote:
ScaleCraft wrote:Here is an E9. If I recall, prime movers are gone replaced by one prime mover, but that's internal:

https://www.up.com/cs/groups/public/@up ... iner_m.jpg

Now what? Manufacturer going to make one like that?


Actually EMD did. That is built to E9 specs. No nose door and grabs, and new style vertical headlight. The headlight bulbs can be replaced from the outside. (Thanks to Sarge for that bit of info.)

Rich


Somewhere I have a photo of THAT unit un-restored WITH nose door.

https://utahrails.net/up/up-e8-e9.php

"The nose doors on UP 949 and 951 were welded shut in 2003 to improve grade crossing safety following 6936's grade crossing accident (in late 2000), labels applied saying "No Entrance"; doors and door handles removed in late 2003."

I re-iterate. None of the Heritage Fleet UP had smooth noses. 50 years later, suddenly we have them.
Interesting read on door headlights and upper signal lights.
Dave....gone by invitation

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby ScaleCraft » Thu Dec 30, 2021 2:52 pm

Still trying to get my head around this nose door.

Absolute last E9 delivered to UP was 914 (interesting numbering...the newer the engine, the lower the road number) in 1963. I looked!

Here is an in-service photo of said engine in 1965:

http://s3.amazonaws.com/rrpa_photos/61892/up914-2.jpg

Now, what EMD standard for nose doors on E9's is there when one of the last ones out still had doors?

"A1A-A1A passenger train-hauling diesel locomotive built by General Motors' Electro-Motive Division of La Grange, Illinois, between April 1954 and January 1964. "

January is one month out of 1963, the year the last UP was delivered. Maybe EMD did that right at the end of 1963?

Same UP 914 in AMTRAK:

http://www.rrpicturearchives.net/showPi ... id=1931797

Note nose door AND second headlight added from early UP days.
Dave....gone by invitation

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby ScaleCraft » Thu Dec 30, 2021 4:13 pm

Challenge:

I have just finished perusing hundreds and hundreds of E9 photos, old, new, in service, scrap lines, in museums...and not one (other than the two UP Heritage units) have "nose door delete".

Challenge is show me a photo of an E9 in service (or unmodifed by end user) with no nose door.
(and not scrap line with nose door pulled out and an empty hole!)
Not being difficult, just gaining knowledge.

EMD said those doors were there to move between MU'd units
Dave....gone by invitation

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby sarge » Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:47 pm

Somehow there seems to be a confusion introduced here, and I hope I'm not the source.

I know of no E9 originally built without nose doors or with a single power assembly. I believe that is uniquely a UP exec/heritage thing with the carbodies housing what is essentially a GP38-2 inside and the noses made solid.

The only thing I was on about was the headlight rim, slanted or vertical.

E7
Posts: 8404
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 1:35 am

Re: Was PRC/Atlas quality rant, now Couplers

Postby E7 » Thu Dec 30, 2021 9:30 pm

As Sarge said, any versions with NO nose door will be Heritage or redo's of some type. While searching for images of B&O E9's, I did see a some units that looked to be missing the nose door and grabs. My monitor is a piece of crap (small) but they definitely were a pair other than the UP's. Maybe the Illinois Central Heritage units? The way the paint was on the nose, it was hard to tell what was or wasn't there. The paint was totally unlike the original IC scheme!

As for the UP's, I like the look. They are a lot easier on my eyes than all those modern engines painted up in the so called Heritage paint (opinion of course). Considering all the mods that were done to stuff during their revenue careers, I say no big deal, and I like their looks a lot better than anything 2nd gen or newer.

Rich


Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: up148 and 57 guests